Quantum Proton Effects from Density Matrix Renormalization Group Calculations

Robin Feldmann, Andrea Muolo, Alberto Baiardi, Markus ReiherJournal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2022 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We recently introduced the nuclear-electronic all-particle density matrix renormalization group (NEAP-DMRG) method to solve the molecular Schrödinger equation based on a stochastically optimized orbital basis without invoking the Born-Oppenheimer approximation. In this work, we combine the DMRG method with the nuclear-electronic Hartree-Fock (NEHF-DMRG) approach, treating nuclei and electrons on the same footing. Inter- and intraspecies correlations are described within the DMRG method without truncating the excitation degree of the full configuration interaction wave function. We extend the concept of orbital entanglement and mutual information to nuclear-electronic wave functions and demonstrate that they are reliable metrics to detect strong correlation effects. We apply the NEHF-DMRG method to the $\text{HeHHe}^+$ molecular ion and $\text{HCN}$ to obtain accurate proton densities, ground-state total energies, and vibrational transition frequencies.

Introduction: Beyond the Born-Oppenheimer Approximation

In traditional quantum chemistry, the Born-Oppenheimer (BO) approximation is the standard paradigm. It assumes that because atomic nuclei are significantly heavier than electrons, they can be treated as stationary point charges. While this approximation holds for many chemical systems, it falters when dealing with light nuclei—most notably protons.

Protons exhibit pronounced quantum behaviors, including tunneling and zero-point vibrations, which are fundamental to hydrogen transfer reactions, enzyme catalysis, and fuel cell chemistry. To accurately capture these "quantum proton effects," one must treat nuclei and electrons as part of a unified quantum system. However, this all-particle approach introduces a "factorial scaling" problem: the number of possible configurations for the particles grows exponentially, making exact solutions computationally prohibitive. Existing multi-reference methods often truncate these configurations to remain feasible, which frequently results in the "over-localization" of protons, failing to represent their true delocalized quantum nature.

Methodology: The NEHF-DMRG Framework

To address these challenges, we developed the NEHF-DMRG framework. This method combines two sophisticated computational techniques to solve the molecular Schrödinger equation without relying on the BO approximation:

  1. Nuclear-Electronic Hartree-Fock (NEHF): This serves as the initial mean-field description, where each particle (electron or nucleus) moves within the average field created by all other particles.
  2. Density Matrix Renormalization Group (DMRG): Originally developed for condensed matter physics, DMRG acts as a powerful solver to capture complex correlations. By representing the wave function as a Matrix Product State (MPS), DMRG achieves polynomial scaling rather than factorial, allowing for a more complete description of the system without truncating the excitation degree.

Entanglement as a Diagnostic Tool

A key innovation in this work is the application of quantum information theory to nuclear-electronic systems. We utilize von Neumann entropy and mutual information to quantify "orbital entanglement." This data is used in two critical ways:

  • Fiedler Ordering: Entanglement data allows us to optimally arrange orbitals on the DMRG lattice. By placing highly connected orbitals close to one another, we significantly accelerate the convergence of the algorithm.
  • Natural Orbital (NO) Pruning: By analyzing Natural Orbital Occupation Numbers (NOONs), we can identify and remove unimportant orbitals. In our tests, we successfully pruned 50-60% of protonic orbitals with negligible occupation, reducing the computational burden without sacrificing precision.

Results and Discussion

Benchmarking with $\text{HeHHe}^+$

The $\text{HeHHe}^+$ (helium-hydronium) ion served as our primary benchmark. We compared NEHF-DMRG against grid-based methods (Fourier Grid Hamiltonian) and modern configuration interaction methods like Heat-Bath CI (HBCI). Our results showed that NEHF-DMRG energy converged to within 1 $\mu$Ha (micro-Hartree) of the reference data, matching or exceeding the accuracy of state-of-the-art methods.

The HCN Challenge

Hydrogen Cyanide ($\text{HCN}$) represents a more complex test case for nuclear-electronic methods. A major challenge in multireference studies is accurately predicting the proton density—the "cloud" representing the proton's position. We found that NEHF-DMRG produced a proton density significantly closer to grid-based references than previous truncated methods. Because DMRG does not truncate the excitation degree, it captures the high-order electron-proton correlations necessary to describe the delocalized nature of the proton accurately.

Our findings also highlighted the importance of high angular momentum in basis sets. To qualitatively match gold-standard data, the electronic basis sets located at the proton's position must be highly flexible, as the electron-proton correlation remains the most difficult component of the wave function to model.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

The NEHF-DMRG method provides a robust, systematically improvable framework for studying quantum proton effects. By treating protons and electrons on equal footing and leveraging entanglement metrics for optimization, we have achieved state-of-the-art accuracy in both total energy and particle density.

Future work will focus on several key areas:

  • Proton Affinities: Applying the method to bond-breaking and formation scenarios.
  • Time-Dependent DMRG: Extending the theory to simulate real-time dynamics, such as attosecond electron movement during chemical reactions.
  • Automation: Integrating entanglement metrics into algorithms like AutoCAS to automatically select the "active space" of orbitals, further reducing the need for manual intervention in complex chemical setups.

Summary updated

Abstract

We recently introduced [<i>J. Chem. Phys.</i> <b>2020,</b> <i>152,</i> 204103] the nuclear-electronic all-particle density matrix renormalization group (NEAP-DMRG) method to solve the molecular Schrödinger equation, based on a stochastically optimized orbital basis, without invoking the Born-Oppenheimer approximation. In this work, we combine the DMRG method with the nuclear-electronic Hartree-Fock (NEHF-DMRG) approach, treating nuclei and electrons on the same footing. Inter- and intraspecies correlations are described within the DMRG method without truncating the excitation degree of the full configuration interaction wave function. We extend the concept of orbital entanglement and mutual information to nuclear-electronic wave functions and demonstrate that they are reliable metrics to detect strong correlation effects. We apply the NEHF-DMRG method to the HeHHe<sup>+</sup> molecular ion, to obtain accurate proton densities, ground-state total energies, and vibrational transition frequencies by comparison with state-of-the-art data obtained with grid-based approaches and modern configuration interaction methods. For HCN, we improve on the accuracy of the latter approaches with respect to both the ground-state absolute energy and proton density, which is a major challenge for multireference nuclear-electronic state-of-the-art methods.
BibTeX
@article{feldmann2022quantum,
  author = {Robin Feldmann and Andrea Muolo and Alberto Baiardi and Markus Reiher},
  title = {{Quantum Proton Effects from Density Matrix Renormalization Group Calculations}},
  journal = {Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1021/acs.jctc.1c00913},
}
Figure