Quantum Maps Between CPTP and HPTP

Ningping Cao, Maxwell Fitzsimmons, Zachary Mann, Rajesh Pereira, Raymond LaflammearXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: For an open quantum system to evolve under CPTP maps, assumptions are made on the initial correlations between the system and the environment. Hermitian-preserving trace-preserving (HPTP) maps are considered as the local dynamic maps beyond CPTP. In this paper, we provide a succinct answer to the question of what physical maps are in the HPTP realm by two approaches. The first is by taking one step out of the CPTP set, which provides us with Semi-Positivity (SP) TP maps. The second way is by examining the physicality of HPTP maps, which leads to Semi-Nonnegative (SN) TP maps. Physical interpretations and geometrical structures are studied for these maps. The non-CP SPTP maps $\Psi$ correspond to the quantum non-Markovian process under the CP-divisibility definition ($\Psi= \Xi\circ \Phi^{-1}$, where $\Xi$ and $\Phi$ are CPTP). When removing the invertibility assumption on $\Phi$, we land in the set of SNTP maps. A by-product of set relations is an answer to the following question -- what kind of dynamics the system will go through when the previous dynamic $\Phi$ is non-invertible. In this case, the only locally well-defined maps are in $SN\backslash SP$, they live on the boundary of $SN$. Otherwise, the non-local information will be irreplaceable in the system's dynamic. With the understanding of physical maps beyond CPTP, we prove that the current quantum error correction scheme is still sufficient to correct quantum non-Markovian errors. In some special cases, lack of complete positivity could provide us with more error correction methods with less overhead.

Introduction: Beyond the CPTP Assumption

In standard quantum information theory, the evolution of an open system is typically described using Completely Positive Trace-Preserving (CPTP) maps. This framework relies on the critical assumption that the system and its environment begin in a separable, uncorrelated state. However, real-world physical systems frequently exhibit initial correlations. When these correlations exist, the local evolution of the system may deviate from CPTP, falling into the broader category of Hermitian-Preserving Trace-Preserving (HPTP) maps.

The challenge lies in the fact that the HPTP set is mathematically vast, containing many maps that lack physical meaning. This research identifies which of these maps are "physical" and characterizes their relationship to non-Markovian dynamics, where environmental memory feeds back into the system.

Defining Physicality: SP and SN Maps

The authors approach the problem from two distinct directions to identify physical maps within the HPTP realm:

  1. Semi-Positive (SP) Maps: These are defined as maps that can be decomposed as $\Psi = \Xi \circ \Phi^{-1}$, where both $\Xi$ and $\Phi$ are standard CPTP maps. This structure is a hallmark of non-Markovianity under the definition of CP-divisibility.
  2. Semi-Nonnegative (SN) Maps: These represent the most general class of maps capable of sending at least one valid density matrix to another valid density matrix. If a map is not at least SN, it can never produce a valid quantum state and is considered non-physical.
The context unitary $U_c$ creates initial correlations between system $S$ and environment $E$ at time $t_1$, leading to non-CP dynamics for the subsequent evolution $U$.

To realize these maps physically, the authors utilize a "Context Unitary" model. This model demonstrates that non-CP maps arise naturally when a unitary operation creates specific correlations before the primary evolution occurs. This provides a bridge between abstract HPTP maps and concrete physical processes.

Geometric Structure and Information Backflow

Through geometric analysis, the researchers characterized the sets of these maps as "star-shaped" structures within the HPTP space. Unlike CPTP and Positive maps, which are convex and compact, SP and SN maps are unbounded. This suggests that non-CP noise can "expand" the state space in ways standard noise cannot.

Geometric hierarchy of quantum maps, illustrating the nested relationship between CPTP, PTP, SPTP, and the broader HPTP space.

Because SP maps can involve the inverse of a CPTP map, they mathematically represent information backflow. This occurs when information previously lost to the environment returns to the system, a defining feature of non-Markovian dynamics.

Key Results and Error Correction

The study establishes a clear hierarchy: $CP \subseteq P \subseteq SPR \subseteq SN \subseteq HP$. A significant finding is the robustness of Quantum Error Correction (QEC). The authors prove that the standard Knill-Laflamme criteria remain sufficient to correct errors even when the noise is non-CP (specifically SPTP).

Furthermore, the research suggests that the lack of complete positivity might occasionally offer advantages. If the noise is invertible, as is the case with some SP maps, information might be restorable with less overhead than required by complex subspace codes.

Limitations and Future Outlook

While providing a rigorous framework, the authors note that the distinction between SN and SP maps becomes more complex in higher-dimensional Hilbert spaces. Unlike qubits, higher-dimensional state spaces possess "flat facets," making the boundary of physical maps harder to define. Additionally, when maps are not locally well-defined (falling outside the SN set), the system's dynamics become dominated by non-local information, which remains a challenging area for future modeling and characterization protocols like Randomized Benchmarking.

Summary updated

Abstract

For an open quantum system to evolve under CPTP maps, assumptions are made on the initial correlations between the system and the environment. Hermitian-preserving trace-preserving (HPTP) maps are considered as the local dynamic maps beyond CPTP. In this paper, we provide a succinct answer to the question of what physical maps are in the HPTP realm by two approaches. The first is by taking one step out of the CPTP set, which provides us with Semi-Positivity (SP) TP maps. The second way is by examining the physicality of HPTP maps, which leads to Semi-Nonnegative (SN) TP maps. Physical interpretations and geometrical structures are studied for these maps. The non-CP SPTP maps $Ψ$ correspond to the quantum non-Markovian process under the CP-divisibility definition ($Ψ= Ξ\circ Φ^{-1}$, where $Ξ$ and $Φ$ are CPTP). When removing the invertibility assumption on $Φ$, we land in the set of SNTP maps. A by-product of set relations is an answer to the following question -- what kind of dynamics the system will go through when the previous dynamic $Φ$ is non-invertible. In this case, the only locally well-defined maps are in $SN\backslash SP$, they live on the boundary of $SN$. Otherwise, the non-local information will be irreplaceable in the system's dynamic. With the understanding of physical maps beyond CPTP, we prove that the current quantum error correction scheme is still sufficient to correct quantum non-Markovian errors. In some special cases, lack of complete positivity could provide us with more error correction methods with less overhead.
BibTeX
@misc{cao2023quantum,
  author = {Ningping Cao and Maxwell Fitzsimmons and Zachary Mann and Rajesh Pereira and Raymond Laflamme},
  title = {{Quantum Maps Between CPTP and HPTP}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2308.01894},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2308.01894},
}
Figure