Quantum interference in the time-of-flight distribution

Md. Manirul Ali, Hsi‐Sheng GoanJournal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical 2009 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We propose a scheme to experimentally observe matter-wave interference in the time domain, specifically in the arrival-time or the time-of-flight (TOF) distribution for atomic BEC Schrodinger-cat state represented by superposition of macroscopically separated wave packets in space. This is in contrast to interference in space at a fixed time observed in reported BEC experiments. We predict and quantify the quantum interference in the TOF distribution calculated from the modulus of the quantum probability current density (rather than the TOF distributions obtained from a purely classical or semi-classical treatment in many reported experiments). The interference and hence the coherence in the quantum TOF signal disappears in the large-mass limit. Our scheme has the potential to probe the validity of various other theoretical approaches of calculating the quantum arrival time distribution.

Introduction

In standard quantum mechanics, time is treated as a parameter rather than a dynamical operator. This fundamental distinction has led to a long-standing debate regarding the rigorous calculation of arrival-time distributions—the probability that a particle will arrive at a detector at a specific time. While Time-of-Flight (TOF) measurements are ubiquitous in cold atom physics, typically used to determine temperature or confirm Bose-Einstein Condensation (BEC), they are almost exclusively analyzed using classical or semi-classical trajectories.

These classical models are sufficient for bulk clouds but fail to capture purely quantum phenomena such as temporal interference. This paper proposes an experimental scheme to observe quantum interference in the time domain by measuring the arrival times of a BEC in a "Schrödinger-cat" state—a superposition of two spatially separated wave packets. Unlike traditional experiments that seek interference patterns in space at a fixed time, this approach predicts measurable "fringes" in the TOF distribution at a fixed location.

Theoretical Framework and Methodology

The researchers utilize the probability current density approach to define the quantum TOF distribution. The initial state is modeled as a superposition of two Gaussian wave packets separated by a distance $d$ along the vertical $z$-axis. The evolution of these packets is governed by the 1D and 3D Schrödinger equations (specifically the Gross-Pitaevskii equation for non-interacting bosons) as they fall freely under gravity ($V = mgz$).

Instead of imaging the entire cloud at a single instant, the measurement focuses on the probability current $|J(z, t)|$ at a fixed detector height $H$. Gravity plays a vital role in this setup; it acts as an amplifier that "pulls" the vertically separated packets toward the detector, ensuring a high enough atom flux to make the interference pattern detectable. Numerical simulations were performed using parameters for various alkali atoms, including Sodium, Potassium, Rubidium, and Cesium, to investigate the effects of mass and initial wave packet width on the resulting signal.

Results and Analysis

The most significant finding is the emergence of temporal interference fringes. When recording particle counts at a detector over small time windows, the quantum model predicts a series of sharp peaks and valleys rather than a smooth distribution.

The classical Time-of-Flight (TOF) distribution, serving as a baseline for comparison with quantum interference patterns.

As shown in Figure 1, a classical treatment of the TOF distribution results in a smooth, Gaussian-like curve. In contrast, the quantum "cat state" introduces high-frequency oscillations within this envelope. The sensitivity of these fringes is highly dependent on the experimental geometry and atomic properties:

  • Fringe Sensitivity: The number of interference fringes increases with the initial vertical separation ($d$) between the wave packets. For sodium atoms at $1 \mu K$, a separation of $50 \mu m$ produces a highly oscillatory pattern.
  • Mass Dependence: Lighter atoms (e.g., Sodium) exhibit much clearer temporal interference than heavier atoms (e.g., Cesium). As mass increases, the wave packets spread less, reducing the temporal overlap necessary for interference. In the large-mass limit, the distribution converges toward the classical result seen in Figure 1.
  • Spatial vs. Temporal Setup: The study demonstrates that for interference to appear in the TOF distribution, the packets must be separated vertically. Horizontal separation leads to the interference term being "wiped out" during the integration over the detector surface.

Conclusion and Future Work

This proposed experiment serves as a potential "tie-breaker" for competing mathematical definitions of quantum arrival time. By providing a clear prediction of temporal fringes, it offers a way to test the validity of the probability current density approach against other theoretical frameworks.

Future experimental realizations must address the challenges of inter-atomic interactions, as s-wave scattering in a real BEC might smear the interference pattern. Furthermore, observing these fringes requires extremely high temporal resolution and nanokelvin-range temperatures to prevent thermal noise from obscuring the quantum signal. Success in this domain would represent a significant step forward in our understanding of time in the quantum regime.

Summary updated

Abstract

We propose a scheme to experimentally observe matter-wave interference in the time domain, specifically in the arrival-time or the time-of-flight (TOF) distribution for atomic BEC Schrodinger-cat state represented by superposition of macroscopically separated wave packets in space. This is in contrast to interference in space at a fixed time observed in reported BEC experiments. We predict and quantify the quantum interference in the TOF distribution calculated from the modulus of the quantum probability current density (rather than the TOF distributions obtained from a purely classical or semi-classical treatment in many reported experiments). The interference and hence the coherence in the quantum TOF signal disappears in the large-mass limit. Our scheme has the potential to probe the validity of various other theoretical approaches (Phys. Rep. 338, 353 (2000)) of calculating the quantum arrival time distribution.
BibTeX
@article{ali2009quantum,
  author = {Md. Manirul Ali and Hsi‐Sheng Goan},
  title = {{Quantum interference in the time-of-flight distribution}},
  journal = {Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1088/1751-8113/42/38/385303},
}
Figure