Quantum entanglement in carbon–carbon, carbon–phosphorus and silicon–silicon bonds

Matthieu Mottet, Paweł Tecmer, Katharina Bogusławski, Örs Legeza, Markus ReiherPhysical 2014 · DOI · arXiv

Chemical bonds and bond orders are fundamental concepts in chemistry, yet they lack a direct physical observable in quantum mechanics. This study demonstrates that quantum entanglement measures—specifically single-orbital entropy and mutual information—can provide a rigorous, non-ambiguous definition of chemical bonding. By extending this analysis from simple diatomic molecules to polyatomic systems like ethane, ethene, and acetylene, the researchers show that entanglement can accurately predict bond orders and resolve the complex dissociation processes of individual $\sigma$ and $\pi$ bonds.

The Problem of Defining the Chemical Bond

Traditional bond definitions, such as Lewis structures or simple electron counting, often struggle with highly correlated electronic systems or complex transition states. In the strict language of quantum mechanics, a chemical bond is not a physical observable; there is no mathematical operator that yields a "bond" as an expectation value. This research addresses the need for a quantitative tool to interpret complex electronic wave functions, revealing how atoms share information and correlation to form stable structures.

Methodology

The methodology combines high-level computational chemistry with quantum information theory:

  • DMRG (Density Matrix Renormalization Group): Used to calculate electronic wave functions, capturing the "static correlation" essential for describing bond breaking.
  • Entanglement Metrics: Two key metrics are derived from the many-particle reduced density matrix:
  • Single-orbital entropy ($s(1)_i$): Quantifies the entanglement of a single orbital with the rest of the system.
  • Mutual information ($I_{i,j}$): Measures the correlation between two specific orbitals embedded in the environment of the rest.

By monitoring these measures during systematic bond stretching (dissociation analysis), the authors identify the orbitals contributing to specific bonds and determine the bond order.

Figure 2: Orbital entanglement analysis for ethene ($C_2H_4$) at equilibrium ($1.0 r_e$) and stretched ($2.0 r_e$) geometries. The diagrams show mutual information (left) and single-orbital entropy (center), highlighting the strong entanglement of $\sigma$ and $\pi$ orbital pairs as the bond breaks.

Key Insights: Entanglement as a Bond Fingerprint

A key insight is that entanglement acts as a bond "fingerprint." As a bond stretches toward dissociation, the associated bonding and antibonding orbital pairs become strongly entangled, causing a distinct jump in entropy diagrams. This allows for a literal "counting" of bonds. For instance, in ethene, the analysis distinguishes between the $\pi$-bond and the stronger $\sigma$-bond, showing that the $\pi$-bond weakens and entangles faster as the carbon atoms are pulled apart.

The study also addresses the "$C_2$ mystery." Unlike the clear triple bond of acetylene, the carbon dimer ($C_2$) shows a complex transition: at equilibrium, it appears as a single $\sigma$-bonded system, but it transitions through a triply-bonded state during stretching before becoming doubly-bonded.

Quantitative Results and Validation

The study validated bond orders for ethane (1), ethene (2), and acetylene (3), and confirmed a formal triple bond in carbon-phosphorus compounds like $[CP]^-$ and $HCP$, showing patterns similar to the $N_2$ molecule. Furthermore, it highlights the unique "trans-bent" nature of silicon-silicon bonds, which differ fundamentally from their carbon analogs due to their preference for low-spin states.

Figure 3: Sorted mutual information values for the studied molecules. The plots illustrate the quantitative thresholds for strong ($10^{-1}$) and weak ($10^{-3}$) entanglement across different chemical species.

The authors established quantitative thresholds for these interactions: "strongly entangled" orbital pairs typically exhibit mutual information values $I_{i,j} \approx 10^{-1}$, while "weakly entangled" pairs hover around $10^{-3}$. The most significant result is the proof-of-concept that these measures, previously limited to simple two-atom molecules, work reliably for larger polyatomic systems.

Limitations and Future Work

While powerful, the approach has limitations. Using delocalized natural orbitals can sometimes obscure specific effects like antiferromagnetic coupling. Additionally, the computational cost of DMRG currently limits the application to relatively small systems. Future optimizations could enable the study of larger proteins or complex catalysts, where traditional bonding models completely break down.

Summary updated

Abstract

The chemical bond is an important local concept to understand chemical compounds and processes. Unfortunately, like most local concepts, the chemical bond and the bond order do not correspond to any physical observable and thus cannot be determined as an expectation value of a quantum chemical operator. We recently demonstrated [Boguslawski et al., J. Chem. Theory Comput., 2013, 9, 2959-2973] that one- and two-orbital-based entanglement measures can be applied to interpret electronic wave functions in terms of orbital correlation. Orbital entanglement emerged as a powerful tool to provide a qualitative understanding of bond-forming and bond-breaking processes, and allowed for an estimation of bond orders of simple diatomic molecules beyond the classical bonding models. In this article we demonstrate that the orbital entanglement analysis can be extended to polyatomic molecules to understand chemical bonding.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mottet2014quantum,
  author = {Matthieu Mottet and Paweł Tecmer and Katharina Bogusławski and Örs Legeza and Markus Reiher},
  title = {{Quantum entanglement in carbon–carbon, carbon–phosphorus and silicon–silicon bonds}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1039/c4cp00277f},
}
Figure