Quantum Enhanced Josephson Junction Field-Effect Transistors for Logic Applications

Wei Pan, Aaron J. Muhowski, William M. Martinez, Courtney L.h. Sovinec, Juan P. Mendez, Denis MamaluySSRN 2024

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a new type of Josephson junction field-effect transistor (JJFET) using a novel InAs/GaSb heterostructure. This design leverages an excitonic insulator phase transition to achieve a significantly higher gain factor, bringing JJFETs closer to practical use in low-power superconducting computing.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The relentless demand for more powerful and efficient computing necessitates advancements beyond traditional silicon transistors, which are approaching fundamental scaling limits. Superconducting computing offers a compelling alternative, promising orders of magnitude lower power consumption. Josephson junction field-effect transistors (JJFETs) are a promising candidate for superconducting logic due to their low power operation and compatibility with existing design tools. However, a critical parameter for JJFETs to perform Boolean logic is the "gain factor" ($\alpha_J$), which must be greater than 1. Conventional JJFETs, using classical semiconductor channels, suffer from a gradual dependence of their critical current on gate bias, resulting in a very low gain factor (around 0.001), making them unsuitable for logic applications. This paper addresses the challenge of significantly increasing this gain factor to enable practical JJFET-based logic.

Methods

The core innovation lies in the device architecture and material choice. The authors propose a "quantum enhanced" JJFET that utilizes a zero-energy-gap InAs/GaSb heterostructure. This material system is chosen because it can undergo an excitonic insulator (EI) quantum phase transition. By tuning the gate voltage ($V_g$), the device can be driven through this transition. The EI phase transition leads to a sharp change in the material's properties, specifically a strong dependence of the superconducting coherence length ($\xi_c$) on the gate bias. This strong dependence, in turn, causes a sharp transition in the superconducting critical current ($I_c$) with gate voltage, a stark contrast to the gradual change seen in conventional JJFETs.

The fabrication involved standard microfabrication techniques: photolithography and wet etching to define the mesa, e-beam lithography for superconducting tantalum (Ta) electrodes, and atomic layer deposition for an insulating layer. DC measurements were performed using a Keithley source meter, and low-frequency phase lock-in measurements utilized a Stanford Research Systems SR830.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Excitonic Insulator Phase Transition as a Gain Amplifier: The paper demonstrates that the sharp transition in the excitonic insulator phase of the InAs/GaSb heterostructure can dramatically amplify the effect of gate voltage on the superconducting critical current. This is the key mechanism for boosting the gain factor.
  • Stronger Coherence Length Dependence: Unlike classical JJFETs where the coherence length ($\xi_c$) scales weakly with carrier density (e.g., $\xi_c \propto n^{0.5}$), the EI transition regime in this heterostructure exhibits a much stronger dependence ($\xi_c \propto n^{2.5}$). This amplified dependence is crucial for achieving a high gain factor.
  • Bridging the Gap to Logic Applications: While the measured gain factor is still below 1, it is over 50 times larger than previously reported for conventional JJFETs. This significant improvement makes the device a much more viable candidate for future logic applications.
  • Material System Advantage: The InAs/GaSb heterostructure is highlighted as an ideal system due to its high mobility, band-engineering tunability, and compatibility with microelectronics processing, particularly its ability to form transparent interfaces with superconductors.

Key Results

  • A JJFET was fabricated using a zero-gap InAs/GaSb heterostructure.
  • The superconducting critical current ($I_c$) was observed to jump sharply from zero to a finite value as the gate bias was varied, indicating a strong gate modulation.
  • A gain factor ($\alpha_J$) of approximately 0.06 was measured.
  • This measured gain factor is more than 50 times higher than that reported for conventional JJFETs (around 0.001).
  • The device exhibits a "knee-like" behavior in its I-V curves, indicative of a quasi-critical current, even without achieving a true zero-voltage supercurrent state due to the relatively large separation of electrodes.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Gain Factor Below Unity: The primary limitation is that the measured gain factor ($\alpha_J \approx 0.06$) is still less than the required value of 1 for Boolean logic operations.
  • True Supercurrent State: The device did not exhibit a true supercurrent state (zero voltage drop) due to the electrode separation of ~500 nm.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest two main avenues for improvement:
  • Reducing the Josephson junction length to enable a true supercurrent state.
  • Replacing the tantalum electrodes with aluminum, which is known to form better interfaces with InAs quantum wells.
  • Optimizing heterostructure growth parameters to achieve an even sharper excitonic insulator transition, leading to a larger $dI_c/dV_g$ and thus a higher gain factor.

The authors are optimistic that these improvements will pave the way for JJFETs primed for Boolean logic operations.

Summary updated

Abstract

The need of data centers for cloud and network computing has dramatically increased power consumption. In 2014, data centers in the U.S. consumed an estimated 70 billion kWh, representing about 1.8% of total U.S. electricity consumption [“United States Data Center Energy Usage Report," published in June 2016 and supported by the Federal Energy Management Program of the U.S. Department of Energy]. Worldwide, the International Energy Agency estimates that currently about 1% of all global electricity is used by data centers. It is expected that by 2030 the electricity use of information and communications technology may exceed 20% of all global electricity. The microelectronics industry has been focusing on aggressively shrinking the size of logic and memory devices to reduce power consumption. However, this scaling is going to eventually stop as we approach the fundamental materials limit. Moreover, the power dissipation due to the increased number of transistors is also expected to be a limiting factor for processor performance. Superconducting computing has been suggested as a promising approach for low-energy, power-efficient circuit applications. Moreover, using superconducting interconnects can further reduce power consumption. Josephson junction field-effect transistors (JJFET, Fig. a) have recently emerged as a promising candidate for superconducting computing. JJFETs are particularly useful for low power consumption applications as they are operated with, in the superconducting regime, zero voltage drop across its source and drain. Feasibility of using JJFETs for logic operations has been explored [1]. Moreover, high noise margin has been demonstrated for the logic inputs [2]. Compared to single flux quantum approach, JJFET circuits can use designs similar to conventional silicon MOSFETs [1]. For JJFETs to perform logic operations, the gain-factor (α R ) value must be larger than 1. Here α R = dI c /d(V g –V t ) x πΔ/I c , Δ is the superconducting gap, V g the gate bias voltage, V t the threshold voltage. I c ∝ exp(-L/ξ c ) is the critical supercurrent, where L is the channel length and ξ c the carrier coherence length [3]. In a conventional JJFET, ξ c ∝ (V g –V t ) 0.5 (Fig. b), and thus dI c /d(V g –V t ) is small (Fig. c). This translates to a requirement of superconducting transition temperature of ~ 400K for α R larger than 1, far exceeding any recorded critical temperatures. As such, it is impossible to use conventional JJFETs for logic operations. Here, we propose a novel type of JJFET based on quantum phase transition, such as the excitonic insulator (EI) transition in a type-II InAs/GaSb heterostructure [4,5], for low-energy, power-efficient logic applications. The nature of the collective phenomenon in the EI quantum phase transition can provide a sharp transition of the supercurrent states (e.g., ξ c ∝ (V g –V t ) 5 and dI c /d(V g –V t ) very large, as shown in Figs. b and c, respectively) which will enable α R larger than 1 with an easy-to-achieve superconducting transition temperature of ~ 40K. In this talk, we will present some preliminary results demonstrating that indeed the gain factor in these quantum enhanced JJFETs can be greatly improved, thus making them a promising candidate for logic applications. Sandia National Laboratories is a multimission laboratory managed and operated by NTESS LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Honeywell International Inc. for the U.S. DOE’s NNSA under contract DE-NA0003525. This paper describes objective technical results and analysis. Any subjective views or opinions that might be expressed in the paper do not necessarily represent the views of the U.S. DOE or the United States Government. References: F. Wen et al., IEEE Transactions on Electron Devices 66, 5367 (2019). S.R.S. Raman et al., IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity 31, 1800105 (2021). D.J. Frank, superconductor-semiconductor hybrid transistors, Cryogenics, 30 (1990), doi:10.1016/0011-2275(90)90198-L L. Du et al., Nature Communications 8, 1971 (2017). W. Yu et al., New J. Phys. 20, 053062 (2018). Figure caption: (a) A schematic of JJFET device structure. (b) Schematic density dependence of carrier coherence length ξ c vs. gate voltage in classical and quantum JJFETs, respectively. (c) The corresponding current I c in classical and quantum JJFETs. Figure 1
BibTeX
@misc{pan2024quantum,
  author = {Wei Pan and Aaron J. Muhowski and William M. Martinez and Courtney L.H. Sovinec and Juan P. Mendez and Denis Mamaluy},
  title = {{Quantum Enhanced Josephson Junction Field-Effect Transistors for Logic Applications}},
  year = {2024},
  howpublished = {SSRN},
}
Figure