Quantum Discord Witness With Uncharacterized Devices

Rong Wang, Yao Yao, Zhen‐Qiang YinarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Quantum discord represents a correlation beyond classicality that could be useful for many quantum information tasks, and therefore is viewed as a valuable quantum resource. Theoretically, whether a bipartite quantum state has a non-zero amount of quantum discord or not can be determined once its density matrix is given. Experimentally, however, it is not easy to perform a reliable tomography on the state, especially when considering the imperfection of devices and the high dimensionality of system. Here, inspired by the so-called dimension witness, we propose a new approach using uncharacterized measurements to witness quantum discord of an unknown bipartite state within arbitrary dimension system. Furthermore, $2 \times 2$ measurements are sufficient for any bipartite state of arbitrarily large dimension. For any two-qubit state, we show that the maximum of witness happens when one performs mutually orthogonal basis measurement on each qubit. Our method exhibits high robustness against device imperfections, such as error tolerance, indicating its experimental feasibility.

Introduction

In the realm of quantum information, entanglement is often considered the primary resource for quantum advantage. However, Quantum Discord (QD) represents a broader class of quantum correlations that can exist even in states that are not entangled. QD is a valuable resource for tasks such as mixed-state quantum computing and remote state preparation, often proving more robust against environmental noise than entanglement.

The primary challenge lies in detection. Traditionally, confirming the presence of QD requires Quantum State Tomography, a process that reconstructs the entire quantum state. This is resource-intensive; as the system's dimension ($d$) grows, the number of required measurements scales as $d^2 \times d^2$. Furthermore, most existing methods assume the use of "perfect," fully characterized devices. In practice, laboratory hardware often has unknown biases and imperfections. This paper addresses the need for a practical, "device-independent-inspired" witness for QD that works for high-dimensional systems without requiring an exhaustive number of measurements.

Methodology

The researchers propose a nonlinear discord witness inspired by the concept of dimension witnesses. The setup involves Alice and Bob sharing an unknown bipartite quantum state.

Experimental setup for witnessing quantum discord with uncharacterized devices.

As illustrated in the figure above, Alice and Bob each use a "black box" measurement device. Alice chooses between two settings ($x=0,1$) and Bob chooses between two ($y=0,1$). They calculate the covariance of their outcomes ($Q_{xy}$) for each combination of settings. The witness ($W$) is defined as the determinant of the resulting $2 \times 2$ matrix:

$$W = \det \begin{pmatrix} Q_{00} & Q_{01} \\ Q_{10} & Q_{11} \end{pmatrix}$$

Using the Bloch sphere representation, the authors prove that for any state with zero discord, the mathematical rank of the correlation matrix is low, causing the determinant ($W$) to vanish. Therefore, if $W \neq 0$, the state must possess quantum discord. Crucially, $2 \times 2$ measurement settings are sufficient for systems of any dimension, provided the devices can probe the relevant subspaces.

Key Results and Robustness

A central insight of this work is that nonlinearity is essential. Because the set of states with zero discord is non-convex, standard linear witness operators often fail. The determinant approach provides the necessary nonlinearity to identify these states effectively.

Witness value as a function of the proportion of the singlet state in a Werner state mixture.

The performance of the witness was tested using simulated Werner states (mixtures of a pure singlet state and white noise). As shown in the figure above, the witness remains positive for all purity levels $p > 0$. In contrast, entanglement in these states only appears when $p > 1/3$, confirming that this witness can detect quantum correlations that entanglement tests miss.

For qubits, the witness is maximized when Alice and Bob use Mutually Unbiased Bases (MUBs), such as the Pauli X and Z bases. The method also exhibits high robustness; the witness value decreases linearly with experimental error, and it can successfully identify discord even with detection efficiencies as low as 60-70%.

Conclusion

This paper provides a rigorous proof that a non-zero $W$ is a sufficient condition for the presence of quantum discord in any bipartite system. While the devices do not need to be characterized, the method relies on assumptions of independence between the source and measurements. The next logical step is physical implementation using platforms like photons or trapped ions to demonstrate this witness in real-world laboratory settings where uncharacterized noise is a factor.

Summary updated

Abstract

Quantum discord represents a correlation beyond classicality that could be useful for many quantum information tasks, and therefore is viewed as a valuable quantum resource. Theoretically, whether a bipartite quantum state has a non-zero amount of quantum discord or not can be determined once its density matrix is given. Experimentally, however, it is not easy to perform a reliable tomography on the state, especially when considering the imperfection of devices and the high dimensionality of system. Here, inspired by the so-called dimension witness, we propose a new approach using uncharacterized measurements to witness quantum discord of an unknown bipartite state within arbitrary dimension system. Furthermore, $2 \times 2$ measurements are sufficient for any bipartite state of arbitrarily large dimension. For any two-qubit state, we show that the maximum of witness happens when one performs mutually orthogonal basis measurement on each qubit. Our method exhibits high robustness against device imperfections, such as error tolerance, indicating its experimental feasibility.
BibTeX
@misc{wang2023quantum,
  author = {Rong Wang and Yao Yao and Zhen‐Qiang Yin},
  title = {{Quantum Discord Witness With Uncharacterized Devices}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2303.11167},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2303.11167},
}
Figure