Quantum corrections to fidelity decay in chaotic systems

Boris Gutkin, Daniel Waltner, Martha Gutiérrez, Jack Kuipers, Klaus RichterPhysical 2010 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper develops a semiclassical theory to explain quantum corrections to the decay of fidelity in chaotic systems. By analyzing correlations between classical orbits, the authors derive expressions that match established random matrix theory predictions and offer a unified view of fidelity decay across different regimes, including the impact of Ehrenfest time and time-dependent perturbations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how quantum systems lose their coherence and predictability over time is crucial in fields like quantum information and quantum chaos. Fidelity, a measure of how well a quantum state survives a perturbation, is a key metric. While previous work using Random Matrix Theory (RMT) and supersymmetry has described fidelity decay, these methods are often limited to specific regimes (like the Fermi's Golden Rule regime) and don't fully capture system-specific details or deviations from universal behavior. Specifically, semiclassical approaches, while good at describing the leading exponential decay (Lyapunov regime), have struggled to explain the smaller, but important, "quantum corrections" that arise from interference effects. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing a semiclassical framework that can reproduce these corrections and offer a more unified understanding of fidelity decay across various regimes.

Methods

The core of this paper lies in a sophisticated semiclassical approach that goes beyond the standard "diagonal approximation." Instead of just considering a single classical trajectory or pairs of identical trajectories, the authors analyze correlated pairs of classical orbits. These correlations, particularly those involving "encounter stretches" where trajectories briefly interact or overlap, are identified as the source of quantum interference.

Key techniques include:

  • Semiclassical Van Vleck formula: Used to express quantum propagators in terms of classical actions.
  • Analysis of correlated trajectory pairs: The central innovation, focusing on orbits that are topologically related and share "encounter regions."
  • Diagrammatic expansion: Similar to techniques used in spectral statistics, this allows for systematic inclusion of contributions from different types of orbit correlations.
  • Laplace transforms: Employed to analyze the relationship between fidelity amplitude and spectral form factors.
  • Treatment of perturbation: The authors consider both static and time-dependent perturbations, and analyze their impact on the action differences along trajectories.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical development and derivation of expressions, not on experimental data fitting or simulation benchmarks.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Correlated orbits are key to quantum corrections: The paper demonstrates that the subtle quantum corrections to fidelity decay, often missed by simpler semiclassical methods, arise from interference between specific pairs of classical orbits that exhibit correlations (e.g., "encounter stretches").
  • Unified treatment of fidelity decay: The semiclassical approach successfully unifies the description of fidelity decay across the Fermi's Golden Rule (FGR) and Lyapunov regimes, showing how quantum corrections are suppressed in the latter.
  • Connection to RMT and spectral statistics: The work establishes a direct link between fidelity amplitude and parametric spectral form factors, confirming a relationship previously derived within RMT. This provides a semiclassical interpretation of this important identity.
  • Ehrenfest time effects: The theory naturally incorporates the influence of the Ehrenfest time, revealing how it can lead to a delay in the onset of quantum corrections, making the system appear more "classical" for short times.
  • Suppression of corrections for time-varying perturbations: The paper shows that quantum interference effects, which lead to a reduction in fidelity, are suppressed when the perturbation varies in time, counter-intuitively enhancing the overall fidelity.

Key Results

  • Agreement with RMT: The derived semiclassical expressions for the fidelity amplitude in the FGR regime match predictions from RMT and supersymmetry.
  • Quantum corrections identified: The theory quantifies quantum corrections that lead to a reduction in fidelity amplitude, particularly in time-reversal symmetric systems (e.g., GOE, GUE cases).
  • Unified description: The approach provides a consistent framework for fidelity decay in both the FGR and Lyapunov regimes.
  • Ehrenfest time delay: For time-reversal symmetric systems, quantum corrections are shown to be delayed by a time related to the Ehrenfest time and system parameters.
  • Suppression for time-dependent perturbations: For time-varying perturbations, quantum corrections are suppressed, leading to an increased fidelity amplitude.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Time scale limitation: The current semiclassical formalism is primarily valid for times t less than the Heisenberg time ($T_H$). Extending the theory to longer times is a significant open challenge, which would allow for a semiclassical understanding of fidelity revival phenomena.
  • Weak perturbation assumption: While the approach goes beyond linear response, the derivation of quantum corrections often relies on the perturbation being "small" in some sense, or at least not completely dominating the system dynamics.
  • Local perturbations: The current work focuses on global perturbations. Extending the theory to local perturbations, which can lead to different decay regimes (e.g., "escape rate" regime), is a promising avenue.
  • General spin particles: The relationship between fidelity and spectral form factor holds for GOE and GUE cases but not for general spin-$s$ particles in the symplectic case. Further investigation is needed here.
  • Experimental verification: While the theory provides detailed predictions, direct experimental verification of these specific quantum corrections across all regimes would be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

By considering correlations between classical orbits we derive semiclassical expressions for the decay of the quantum fidelity amplitude for classically chaotic quantum systems, as well as for its squared modulus, the fidelity or Loschmidt echo. Our semiclassical results for the fidelity amplitude agree with random matrix theory (RMT) and supersymmetry predictions in the universal Fermi-golden rule regime. The calculated quantum corrections can be viewed as arising from a static random perturbation acting on nearly self-retracing interfering paths, and hence will be suppressed for time-varying perturbations. Moreover, using trajectory-based methods we show a relation, recently obtained in RMT, between the fidelity amplitude and the cross-form factor for parametric level correlations. Beyond RMT, we compute Ehrenfest-time effects on the fidelity amplitude. Furthermore our semiclassical approach allows for a unified treatment of the fidelity, both in the Fermi-golden rule and Lyapunov regimes, demonstrating that quantum corrections are suppressed in the latter.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gutkin2010quantum,
  author = {Boris Gutkin and Daniel Waltner and Martha Gutiérrez and Jack Kuipers and Klaus Richter},
  title = {{Quantum corrections to fidelity decay in chaotic systems}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1103/physreve.81.036222},
}
Figure