Quantum Computation of Conical Intersections on a Programmable Superconducting Quantum Processor

Shoukuan Zhao, Diandong Tang, Xiaoxiao Xiao, Ruixia Wang, Qiming Sun, Zhe Chen, Xiaoxia Cai, Zhendong Li, Haifeng Yu, Wei‐Hai FangThe Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reports the first successful implementation of a hybrid quantum-classical algorithm (VQE-SA-CASSCF) on a superconducting quantum processor to study conical intersections (CIs) in molecules. This breakthrough demonstrates the potential of current quantum hardware for tackling complex photochemical problems that are intractable for classical computers.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Conical intersections (CIs) are crucial points in molecular potential energy surfaces where electronic states become degenerate, leading to ultrafast photochemical processes like isomerization and photoionization. Accurately calculating these CIs is essential for understanding and predicting chemical reactions. However, traditional quantum chemistry methods, such as state-averaged complete active space self-consistent field (SA-CASSCF), face significant computational challenges, with costs scaling exponentially with the number of relevant electrons and orbitals. This makes studying CIs in larger, more complex molecules computationally prohibitive on classical computers. While quantum computing offers a promising alternative, its practical application to CIs on real quantum hardware has remained largely unexplored.

Methods

The authors introduce and implement a hybrid quantum-classical approach called Variational Quantum Eigensolver State-Average Complete Active Space Self-Consistent Field (VQE-SA-CASSCF). This method combines the strengths of quantum and classical computing:

  • Quantum Part (VQE): A parameterized quantum circuit (PQC) is used to prepare trial wavefunctions for multiple electronic states within a defined "active space" (a subset of chemically relevant orbitals). The variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) algorithm then iteratively adjusts the parameters of the PQC to find the lowest energy states.
  • Classical Part (Optimization): Reduced density matrices (RDMs) obtained from the quantum computation are fed into classical optimization routines. These routines update the molecular orbitals (MOs) to improve the description of the electronic structure.

This process forms a two-loop iterative cycle: one loop for optimizing the wavefunction parameters on the quantum computer and another for optimizing the molecular orbitals on the classical computer. To enhance performance on noisy quantum hardware, they employed several strategies:

  • Hardware Improvements: Careful calibration of qubits and gates.
  • Algorithmic Enhancements:
    • Qubit-ADAPT: Used to derive shorter, more efficient quantum circuits.
  • Grouping Technique: Exploits qubit-wise commutativity to reduce the number of measurements required.
  • Error Mitigation (EM): Techniques like symmetry projection were applied to reduce the impact of noise and improve accuracy.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on theoretical models of molecules rather than datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Feasibility of VQE-SA-CASSCF on Real Hardware: The paper demonstrates that VQE-SA-CASSCF, a complex quantum algorithm, can indeed be successfully implemented and run on a programmable superconducting quantum processor. This is a significant step beyond theoretical proposals.
  • Importance of Orbital Optimization: The study highlights that optimizing molecular orbitals (MOs) in conjunction with wavefunction parameters is crucial for accurately describing conical intersections. Simply using fixed MOs (like in VQE-based CASCI) can lead to incorrect ordering of electronic states.
  • Error Mitigation is Crucial: The results show that error mitigation techniques are essential for obtaining accurate results on current noisy quantum devices. The effectiveness of different EM strategies varied depending on the complexity of the system and the circuit depth.
  • NISQ Devices Can Tackle Real Problems: The successful application to ethylene and hydrogen molecules suggests that even current noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices, with appropriate algorithmic and hardware improvements, can begin to address problems in quantum chemistry that are beyond classical reach.

Key Results

  • Ethylene (C₂H₄): The VQE-SA-CASSCF method successfully reproduced the conical intersection between the ground and first excited states of ethylene. The experimental results showed good agreement with theoretical predictions, especially when using error mitigation. Orbital optimization was shown to be critical for correctly predicting the relative ordering of electronic states.
  • Triatomic Hydrogen (H₃): The study also investigated H₃, a system with a symmetry-required conical intersection. This case presented greater challenges due to a larger active space and more complex Hamiltonian. The paper demonstrated that a more sophisticated error mitigation strategy (EM2) was necessary for accurate results on this more complex system, outperforming simpler methods.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Noise Sensitivity: Despite error mitigation, the results are still affected by noise, particularly for more complex systems with longer quantum circuits. The convergence criteria for H₃ had to be relaxed due to noise.
  • Scalability: While successful for small molecules, the current approach still faces challenges in scaling to larger and more complex systems due to the increasing number of qubits and circuit depth required.
  • Alternative Solvers: The authors suggest exploring other quantum algorithms, such as systematically improvable hardware-efficient ansätze, which might offer better accuracy with shallower circuits.
  • Processor Stability: The paper emphasizes the need for improved quantum processor stability for long, iterative calculations, which are common in quantum chemistry simulations.
  • Further Study: Future work could focus on identifying the optimal quantum solver for active space problems and developing more robust strategies for improving quantum processor stability.

Summary updated

Abstract

Conical intersections (CIs) are pivotal in many photochemical processes. Traditional quantum chemistry methods, such as the state-average multiconfigurational methods, face computational hurdles in solving the electronic Schrödinger equation within the active space on classical computers. While quantum computing offers a potential solution, its feasibility in studying CIs, particularly on real quantum hardware, remains largely unexplored. Here, we present the first successful realization of a hybrid quantum-classical state-average complete active space self-consistent field method based on the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE-SA-CASSCF) on a superconducting quantum processor. This approach is applied to investigate CIs in two prototypical systems─ethylene (C<sub>2</sub>H<sub>4</sub>) and triatomic hydrogen (H<sub>3</sub>). We illustrate that VQE-SA-CASSCF, coupled with ongoing hardware and algorithmic enhancements, can lead to a correct description of CIs on existing quantum devices. These results lay the groundwork for exploring the potential of quantum computing to study CIs in more complex systems in the future.
BibTeX
@article{zhao2024quantum,
  author = {Shoukuan Zhao and Diandong Tang and Xiaoxiao Xiao and Ruixia Wang and Qiming Sun and Zhe Chen and Xiaoxia Cai and Zhendong Li and Haifeng Yu and Wei‐Hai Fang},
  title = {{Quantum Computation of Conical Intersections on a Programmable Superconducting Quantum Processor}},
  journal = {The Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1021/acs.jpclett.4c01314},
}
Figure