Quantum communication through devices with indefinite input-output direction

Zixuan Liu, Ming–Hsuan Yang, Giulio ChiribellaarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Certain quantum devices, such as half-wave plates and quarter-wave plates in quantum optics, are bidirectional, meaning that the roles of their input and output ports can be exchanged. Bidirectional devices can be used in a forward mode and a backward mode, corresponding to two opposite choices of the input-output direction. They can also be used in a coherent superposition of the forward and backward modes, giving rise to new operations with indefinite input-output direction. In this work we explore the potential of input-output indefiniteness for the transfer of classical and quantum information through noisy channels. We first formulate a model of communication from a sender to a receiver via a noisy channel used in indefinite input-output direction. Then, we show that indefiniteness of the input-output direction yields advantages over standard communication protocols in which the given noisy channel is used in a fixed input-output direction. These advantages range from a general reduction of noise in bidirectional processes, to heralded noiseless transmission of quantum states, and, in some special cases, to a complete noise removal. The noise reduction due to input-output indefiniteness can be experimentally demonstrated with current photonic technologies, providing a way to investigate the operational consequences of exotic scenarios characterised by coherent quantum superpositions of forward-time and backward-time processes.

Beyond Fixed Directions in Quantum Channels

In classical information theory, communication channels are typically assumed to have a fixed, well-defined direction: a signal travels from Alice to Bob. Quantum Shannon theory has traditionally followed this "fixed configuration" mindset. However, recent advancements in quantum control have shown that the configuration of communication devices can itself be governed by quantum mechanics. Examples include sending a photon along two paths simultaneously (indefinite path) or using two gates in a superposition of orders (indefinite causal order).

This research introduces a specific, exotic type of quantum control: indefinite input-output direction. Many optical devices, such as wave plates, are inherently bidirectional. A photon can traverse them from "bottom to top" (forward) or "top to bottom" (backward). By placing a single noisy bidirectional device in a quantum superposition of both directions—a concept termed a "quantum time flip"—researchers have demonstrated that it is possible to beat noise levels that would otherwise destroy information.

The core concept of indefinite input-output direction: (a) forward mode, (b) backward mode, and (c) a coherent superposition of both directions.

The Communication Protocol

The proposed model involves three parties: Alice (the sender), Bob (the receiver), and Charlie (the "provider" who controls the device configuration). The process follows four key steps:

  1. The Quantum Time Flip: Charlie uses a control qubit to determine the direction a particle traverses a bidirectional device. If the control is in state $|0\rangle$, the device acts as channel $\mathcal{C}$ (forward); if $|1\rangle$, it acts as $\mathcal{C}^T$ (the transpose, or backward).
  2. Coherent Superposition: Charlie prepares the control qubit in a maximally coherent state $|+\rangle = (|0\rangle + |1\rangle)/\sqrt{2}$. This puts the communication channel into a superposition of forward and backward modes.
  3. Heralded Correction: After the particle passes through the device, Charlie measures the control qubit in the Fourier basis ($\{|+\rangle, |-\rangle\}$) and sends the result to Bob via a classical side-channel.
  4. Mathematical Analysis: The study focuses on transposition-invariant channels (where $\mathcal{C} = \mathcal{C}^T$), such as depolarizing and dephasing noise models.
The communication setup where Alice sends a signal through a device controlled by Charlie, who superposes the forward and backward paths before Bob receives the message.

Breaking the Noise Barrier

The "magic" of the quantum time flip lies in quantum interference. For transposition-invariant channels, the superposition of directions causes symmetric Kraus operators (errors) to correlate with the $|+\rangle$ control state and anti-symmetric operators to correlate with the $|-\rangle$ state. This separation allows the measurement of the control qubit to act as a "herald." If Charlie obtains a specific result, Bob knows exactly how to undo the noise, effectively creating a noiseless sub-channel.

Key Results

  • Classical Capacity Boost: For a completely depolarizing channel ($q=1$), which normally has zero capacity, the indefinite direction protocol achieves a classical capacity of 0.3113 bits per use. This is significantly higher than using two identical channels in a superposition of causal orders (0.049 bits) or paths (0.16 bits).
  • Quantum Capacity Gains: In the depolarizing model, the quantum capacity remains non-zero even when the noise level is high enough to kill the capacity of a standard fixed-direction channel.
  • Perfect Transmission: For dephasing noise, the protocol enables perfect, deterministic quantum communication (1 qubit per use) regardless of the noise level. By measuring the control qubit, Bob can perfectly rotate the received state back to Alice's original input.

Implications and Future Outlook

While the protocol requires bidirectional devices (mathematically bistochastic channels), many common optical components fit this description. Current photonic technology, utilizing wave plates and interferometers, is already capable of demonstrating these effects in a laboratory setting.

Beyond immediate communication advantages, this framework provides a rigorous way to study "exotic" scenarios where the arrow of time might be in a quantum superposition. Future work may explore combining indefinite direction with indefinite causal order, potentially offering even greater advantages in quantum thermodynamics and the development of a future quantum internet.

Summary updated

Abstract

Certain quantum devices, such as half-wave plates and quarter-wave plates in quantum optics, are bidirectional, meaning that the roles of their input and output ports can be exchanged. Bidirectional devices can be used in a forward mode and a backward mode, corresponding to two opposite choices of the input-output direction. They can also be used in a coherent superposition of the forward and backward modes, giving rise to new operations with indefinite input-output direction. In this work we explore the potential of input-output indefiniteness for the transfer of classical and quantum information through noisy channels. We first formulate a model of communication from a sender to a receiver via a noisy channel used in indefinite input-output direction. Then, we show that indefiniteness of the input-output direction yields advantages over standard communication protocols in which the given noisy channel is used in a fixed input-output direction. These advantages range from a general reduction of noise in bidirectional processes, to heralded noiseless transmission of quantum states, and, in some special cases, to a complete noise removal. The noise reduction due to input-output indefiniteness can be experimentally demonstrated with current photonic technologies, providing a way to investigate the operational consequences of exotic scenarios characterised by coherent quantum superpositions of forward-time and backward-time processes.
BibTeX
@misc{liu2022quantum,
  author = {Zixuan Liu and Ming–Hsuan Yang and Giulio Chiribella},
  title = {{Quantum communication through devices with indefinite input-output direction}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2212.08265},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08265},
}
Figure