Quantitatively Measured Infrapatellar Fat Pad Signal Intensity Alteration is Associated with Joint Effusion-Synovitis in Knee Osteoarthritis

Guangfeng Ruan, Yan Zhang, Zhaohua Zhu, Peihua Cao, Xiaoshuai Wang, Jia Li, Su’an Tang, Tianyu Chen, Weiyu Han, Xin Lin, Di Chen, Benny Antony, Tania Winzenberg, Anita E. Wluka, Flavia Cicuttini, Changhai DingResearch 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Knee osteoarthritis (OA) is increasingly recognized as a complex inflammatory disease involving the entire joint, rather than just cartilage wear. This study investigates the longitudinal relationship between signal intensity changes in the infrapatellar fat pad (IPFP) and joint effusion-synovitis. Analyzing 255 patients over two years using quantitative MRI, researchers found that abnormal "noisy" or hyperintense signals within the IPFP are strong indicators of broader joint inflammation. All four quantitative IPFP parameters measured were positively associated with total and sub-regional effusion-synovitis volumes, suggesting these two imaging biomarkers are closely intertwined in OA progression.

Introduction

Knee OA involves the whole joint, including the synovium (joint lining) and the infrapatellar fat pad (IPFP), a wedge of fat located below the kneecap. While the IPFP provides cushioning, in OA it can produce pro-inflammatory cytokines. Given their anatomical proximity, the IPFP and synovium likely interact. However, previous research often relied on subjective manual grading. This study addresses the need for objective, quantitative evidence to determine if fat pad abnormalities are associated with joint effusion-synovitis (swelling and inflammation) over time.

Methods

The researchers utilized data from the Vitamin D Effect on Osteoarthritis (VIDEO) study, analyzing 255 individuals (aged 50–79) with symptomatic knee OA. Participants were followed over two years with 1.5T MRI scans.

The study employed a novel quantitative approach:

  • IPFP Signal Intensity: A semi-automated MATLAB-based program was used to segment the IPFP. Four parameters were calculated: signal standard deviation (sDev), upper quartile of high-intensity regions (UQ (H)), percentage of high-intensity volume, and a "clustering factor."
  • Effusion-Synovitis: Measured quantitatively as volume (ml) using OsiriX Lite software and semi-quantitatively using the WORMS scoring system.
MRI segmentation of the infrapatellar fat pad (IPFP) and effusion-synovitis.

Mixed-effects models adjusted for age, sex, BMI, and vitamin D levels to ensure the association between the fat pad and inflammation was independent of these factors.

Key Results

The study found that all four quantitative measures of IPFP signal alteration were positively and significantly associated with joint inflammation over two years:

  • Total Volume: Higher IPFP signal intensity parameters were strongly linked to increased total effusion-synovitis volume (all P < 0.05).
  • Sub-regions: Associations held true for both the suprapatellar pouch and other joint cavities.
  • Consistency: Findings were consistent across both quantitative volume (ml) and semi-quantitative WORMS scores.
  • Baseline Stats: At the start, the median total effusion-synovitis volume was 6.74 ml, with a mean IPFP signal standard deviation of 8.41.

Discussion

The results reinforce the concept of the IPFP as an inflammatory hub rather than a passive cushion. High signal intensity on T2-weighted MRI—representing edema or inflammation—within the fat pad serves as a reliable proxy for the inflammatory state of the entire joint. The study suggests a "coexistent pattern" where the IPFP and synovium act as a single functional unit in OA inflammation. Furthermore, using continuous numerical data (quantitative analysis) allowed for more nuanced associations than traditional discrete grading.

Limitations and Future Work

As a post hoc analysis of the VIDEO study, results might be influenced by the original trial's interventions, though models adjusted for this. The focus on hyperintense signals means hypointense signals (potentially representing fibrosis) were not explored. While a strong association was found, causality remains unproven; future research is needed to determine the exact "cross-talk" mechanism between these tissues. Finally, the cohort's specific pain levels and OA grades may limit generalizability to very early or late-stage OA.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background: Abnormal infrapatellar fat pad (IPFP) plays a detrimental role in knee osteoarthritis (OA) by producing pro-inflammatory cytokines. IPFP may interact with synovium because of their adjacent anatomical positions; however, whether abnormal IPFP can contribute to effusion-synovitis in knee OA is unclear.Methods: Among 255 knee OA patients, IPFP signal intensity alteration represented by four measurement parameters [standard deviation of IPFP signal intensity (IPFP sDev), upper quartile value of IPFP high signal intensity region (IPFP UQ (H)), ratio of IPFP high signal intensity region volume to whole IPFP volume (IPFP percentage (H)), and clustering factor of IPFP high signal intensity (IPFP clustering factor (H))] was measured quantitatively at baseline and two-year follow-up using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Effusion-synovitis of the suprapatellar pouch and other cavities were measured both quantitatively and semi-quantitatively as effusion-synovitis volume and effusion-synovitis score at baseline and two-year follow-up using MRI. Mixed-effects models were used to assess the associations between IPFP signal intensity alteration and effusion-synovitis over two years.Results: In multivariable analyses, all four parameters of IPFP signal intensity alteration were positively associated with total effusion-synovitis volume and effusion-synovitis volumes of the suprapatellar pouch and of other cavities over two years (all P <0.05). They were also associated with the semi-quantitative measure of effusion-synovitis except for IPFP percentage (H) with effusion-synovitis in other cavities. Conclusion: Quantitatively measured IPFP signal intensity alteration is positively associated with joint effusion-synovitis in people with knee OA, suggesting that IPFP signal intensity alteration may contribute to effusion-synovitis and a coexistent pattern of these two imaging biomarkers could exist in knee OA patients.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ruan2021quantitatively,
  author = {Guangfeng Ruan and Yan Zhang and Zhaohua Zhu and Peihua Cao and Xiaoshuai Wang and Jia Li and Su’an Tang and Tianyu Chen and Weiyu Han and Xin Lin and Di Chen and Benny Antony and Tania Winzenberg and Anita E. Wluka and Flavia Cicuttini and Changhai Ding},
  title = {{Quantitatively Measured Infrapatellar Fat Pad Signal Intensity Alteration is Associated with Joint Effusion-Synovitis in Knee Osteoarthritis}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-404837/v1},
}
Figure