Quantitative texture analysis in two-dimensional echocardiography: application to the diagnosis of experimental myocardial contusion.

David J. Skorton, Stephen M. Collins, James Nichols, Natesa G. Pandian, Judith A. Bean, Richard E. KerberCirculation 1983 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces quantitative texture analysis of 2D echocardiograms as a novel method to detect myocardial contusion, a difficult-to-diagnose injury. By analyzing the spatial distribution of echo amplitudes, they demonstrated that specific texture measures can reliably differentiate healthy from injured heart tissue in an experimental model.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Standard echocardiography primarily focuses on large, smooth structures like the endocardium and epicardium. However, the subtle backscatter from the myocardium itself, which carries information about its microscopic structure, has been less explored for diagnostic purposes. This is particularly problematic for conditions like myocardial contusion, which can be asymptomatic and easily overlooked, especially when associated with other chest wall injuries. Current diagnostic methods for contusion are often non-specific, highlighting a need for more precise and objective techniques.

Methods

The researchers employed quantitative texture analysis on 2D echocardiograms. This involved:

  • Image Acquisition: Standard short-axis 2D echocardiograms were obtained from six anesthetized dogs before and approximately 30 minutes after inducing blunt chest trauma.
  • Image Preprocessing: Images were smoothed using a five-pixel weighted average filter to reduce artifacts from the sector scan lines.
  • Texture Measures: A suite of quantitative texture measures were applied to regions of interest (ROI) within the echocardiograms. These measures fall into four categories:
  • Gray Level Histogram Statistics: Primarily focused on the mean gray level (average echo amplitude).
  • Edge Count: Identified edge points using a gradient-based operator to quantify image heterogeneity.
  • Gray Level Run-Length Statistics: Measured the heterogeneity of gray levels and the relative size of echocardiographic reflections.
  • Gray Level Difference Statistics: Assessed gray level differences between pixels separated by various distances and directions.
  • Directional Analysis: Crucially, texture calculations were performed along both horizontal (range) and vertical (azimuthal/lateral) directions.
  • Statistical Analysis: Multivariate analysis of variance (MANOVA) was used to compare texture measures between normal and contused regions, with a stringent significance level (p < .008) due to multiple comparisons.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset of 2D echocardiograms from six adult mongrel dogs. These were acquired before and after experimental blunt chest trauma. The "dataset" consists of these controlled experimental images, not a collection of patient data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Texture as a Biomarker: The core idea is that microscopic changes in myocardial tissue (like hemorrhage and myofibrillar fragmentation from contusion) alter how ultrasound waves scatter, leading to detectable changes in image texture.
  • Beyond Brightness: While contused regions appeared brighter (increased mean gray level), the real power lay in analyzing the spatial distribution of these echoes – the texture.
  • Direction Matters: The study revealed that texture analysis was significantly more effective when performed along the azimuthal (lateral) direction compared to the range (vertical) direction. This suggests that the way ultrasound scatters and is resolved laterally is more sensitive to the microstructural changes in myocardial contusion.
  • Quantifying the Unseen: This work moves beyond qualitative visual assessment of echocardiograms to provide objective, quantitative metrics for tissue characterization.

Key Results

  • Pre-trauma vs. Post-trauma: No significant differences in texture were found between normal regions and regions destined to be contused before trauma. Similarly, normal regions in pre-trauma vs. post-trauma images showed no significant differences, validating the control.
  • Post-trauma Differentiation: Twelve texture variables successfully differentiated normal from contused regions after trauma (p values ranging from .0057 to .0001).
  • Specific Findings:
    • Mean gray level was significantly increased in contused regions.
  • Long run emphasis (a run-length statistic) was larger in contused regions, indicating larger individual echo reflections.
  • All four gray level difference statistics (for separations of 1 and 2 pixels horizontally) and two of them (for separation of 4 pixels horizontally) were significantly altered in contused regions.
  • Directional Efficacy: Texture measures along the vertical (azimuthal) direction were effective, while those along the horizontal direction were not.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Limitations: The study used a model of severe, gross myocardial injury. The effectiveness of texture analysis for detecting more subtle, microscopic alterations (e.g., early fibrosis or infiltrative cardiomyopathies) remains to be explored.
  • Physical Mechanisms: A deeper understanding of the physical mechanisms linking ultrasound interaction with myocardial microstructure, acoustic speckle patterns, and displayed image texture is needed.
  • Instrument Dependency: The influence of instrument settings, transducer geometry, focusing methods, and gain compensation on displayed image texture needs further investigation to ensure generalizability.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that quantitative texture calculations could be useful for detecting other myocardial abnormalities like necrosis, fibrosis, and infiltrative cardiomyopathies. They propose further research into the physical basis of speckle and the impact of imaging parameters.

Summary updated

Abstract

We postulated that the analysis of regional image texture in two-dimensional (2D) echocardiograms would be an accurate method to differentiate normal from abnormal myocardial structure. We tested this hypothesis with quantitative texture measures to study the regional, spatial distribution of echo amplitudes in 2D echocardiograms performed before and immediately after blunt left chest trauma was induced in six anesthetized dogs. After trauma the contused region of myocardium appeared brighter and exhibited an altered myocardial texture. By use of a set quantitative texture measures, we found no significant differences in pretrauma images when normal regions were compared with regions to be contused. Also, we found no difference when we compared the normal regions in each animal in pretrauma vs posttrauma images. Twelve measures, however, differentiated normal from contused regions within the posttrauma images (p values ranged from .0057 to .0001 by multivariate analysis of variance). These texture measures were capable of differentiating normal from abnormal tissue only when texture along the azimuthal (lateral) direction was calculated. We conclude that regions of myocardial contusion exhibit visibly altered local echo-amplitude patterns (altered image texture) and that these image texture alterations may be quantified with digital image analysis techniques. These findings suggest that quantitative texture calculations may be a useful approach to ultrasound tissue characterization.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{skorton1983quantitative,
  author = {David J. Skorton and Stephen M. Collins and James Nichols and Natesa G. Pandian and Judith A. Bean and Richard E. Kerber},
  title = {{Quantitative texture analysis in two-dimensional echocardiography: application to the diagnosis of experimental myocardial contusion.}},
  booktitle = {Circulation},
  year = {1983},
  doi = {10.1161/01.cir.68.1.217},
}
Figure