Quantitative Comparison of Genesis and Pore Structure Characteristics of Siliceous Minerals in Marine Shale With Different TOC Contents–A Case Study on the Shale of Lower Silurian Longmaxi Formation in Sichuan Basin, Southern China

Kun Zhang, Yan Song, Zhenxue Jiang, Dongsheng Xu, Lintao Li, Xuejiao Yuan, Pei Liu, Fengli Han, Liangyi Tang, Xueying Wang, Liwen Zhang, Jinbo Jiang, Zehao Zheng, Xuecheng ChenFrontiers in Earth Science 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study provides a quantitative framework for understanding how Total Organic Carbon (TOC) levels influence the origin of siliceous minerals and the resulting pore architecture in China’s Longmaxi marine shale. The researchers demonstrate that high-TOC shales possess superior gas storage and flow potential due to a unique blend of biogenic silicon and well-connected, elliptical organic pores.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As China ramps up its shale gas exploration, particularly in the Sichuan Basin, geologists are moving beyond simply finding gas to optimizing how they extract it. A critical factor in "sweet spot" selection is the reservoir's pore structure—the microscopic plumbing that stores and moves gas.

While researchers have long known that TOC and siliceous (silica-rich) minerals are vital, most previous studies were qualitative. We lacked a clear, quantitative understanding of where the silica comes from (its "genesis") and how different TOC concentrations fundamentally change the physical shape and connectivity of the pores. This paper bridges that gap by comparing "organic-bearing" (low TOC) and "organic-rich" (high TOC) shales to see how their mineral origins dictate their reservoir quality.

Methods

The authors employed a multi-disciplinary "full-aperture" approach to characterize the shale samples from the JiaoYe 1 Well:

  • Genesis Analysis: To determine the origin of the silica, the team used elemental logging data (Si, Al, Fe, Mn). They calculated "excess silicon" by comparing the Si/Al ratio to standard background shale levels. They then used an Al-Fe-Mn triangle diagram to distinguish whether this excess was biogenic (from ancient organisms like radiolarians) or hydrothermal.
  • Pore Quantification: Because pores range from sub-nanometer to micrometers in size, no single test works. They combined carbon dioxide adsorption (for micropores <2nm), nitrogen adsorption (for mesopores 2–50nm), and high-pressure mercury intrusion (for macropores >50nm).
  • High-Resolution Imaging: They used FIB-SEM (Focused Ion Beam Scanning Electron Microscopy) and FIB-HIM (Helium Ion Microscopy). While SEM is standard, HIM provides superior depth of field and resolution, allowing the researchers to see the 3D-like connectivity of the pore networks.

Datasets

The primary data came from core samples and logging data from the JiaoYe 1 Well, a key exploration well in the first member of the Lower Silurian Longmaxi Formation in the southern Sichuan Basin. The study also integrated elemental logging data provided by Schlumberger and comparative mineralogical data from existing literature (e.g., Guo et al., 2016).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Silicon Switch": The origin of silica changes with TOC. In shales with 1–2% TOC, the silica is almost entirely "terrigenous detrital"—essentially silt washed in from land. However, in organic-rich shales (TOC >2%), up to 20% of the silica is biogenic. This biogenic silica often forms a rigid framework that helps protect organic pores from being crushed by geological pressure.
  • Pore Morphology Matters: It’s not just about the amount of space, but the shape. Organic-rich shales are dominated by elliptical organic pores with high connectivity. In contrast, low-TOC shales are dominated by clay mineral pores which are irregular, isolated, and prone to collapse, leading to poor storage and flow.
  • The Role of "Foramina": Using FIB-HIM, the researchers identified "foramina"—tiny, throat-like openings embedded within larger macropores. These act as critical seepage channels, significantly enhancing the connectivity of the organic matter network.

Key Results

  • Organic-Rich Shale (TOC >2%):
    • Pore Type: Primarily organic pores (51%).
  • Size Distribution: Dominated by micro-pores (32.1%) and mesopores (54%).
  • Performance: High number of pores, elliptical shapes, and "good" connectivity/storage capacity.
  • Organic-Bearing Shale (TOC 1–2%):
    • Pore Type: Primarily clay mineral pores (71%).
  • Size Distribution: Dominated by macro-pores (57.3%).
  • Performance: Fewer pores, irregular shapes, and "poor" connectivity.
  • Genesis: Quantified that biogenic silica content in the target section ranges from 0% in low-TOC zones to 20% in high-TOC zones.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while their quantitative methods are a step forward, they are not yet "comprehensive enough" to capture every nuance of different sedimentary phases (such as comparing terrestrial vs. marine shales). The study is also localized to the JiaoYe 1 Well; regional tectonic variations across the Sichuan Basin could influence these ratios.

Future research could focus on how the interplay between organic and inorganic diagenesis (the chemical changes as sediment turns to rock) specifically controls the evolution of these "foramina" channels over millions of years.

Summary updated

Abstract

China has abundant shale gas resources with great exploration potential, and stage progress has been made in this aspect. The sedimentary environment and reservoir characteristics are important aspects of the study on shale gas accumulation. Previous studies have mostly been carried out from a “qualitative” perspective, but not from a “quantitative” one. There is a lack of comparative studies on “marine shales with different TOC contents”. This paper takes the marine shale of the first member of the Longmaxi Formation (Long 1 Fm) in southern Sichuan Basin, Southern China, as the research object. The core samples were taken to carry out analyses (mineral composition analysis, TOC content analysis, porosity analysis) and experiments (carbon dioxide and nitrogen adsorption experiments, high-pressure mercury intrusion, FIB-SEM, and FIB-HIM experiments). The element logging data were collected to conduct the quantitative comparison of genesis and pore structure characteristics of siliceous minerals in marine shale with different TOC contents in this area. The conclusions are as follows: first, a formula is used to calculate and determine whether there is excessive silicon; then the Al-Fe-Mn triangle diagram is used to analyze the genesis of excessive silicon, so as to quantitatively analyze the genesis of siliceous minerals in shale: the siliceous minerals of organic shale (1% &amp;lt; TOC &amp;lt;2%) in the member studied are almost terrigenous detrital genesis; most siliceous minerals in organic-rich shale (TOC &amp;gt;2%) are detrital genesis, and a small part (0–20%) are biogenic. Carbon dioxide and nitrogen adsorption experiments, as well as high-pressure mercury intrusion experiments are adopted to quantitatively characterize the whole-aperture pore structure characteristics. The pore development characteristics of different shale components are analyzed by combing FIB-SEM and FIB-HIM experiments. The organic-bearing shales in the target section of this study area mainly develop clay mineral pores (71%), and are dominated by macro-pores (57.3%) with a low number of pores, irregular-shaped pores, as well as poor storage capacity and connectivity; the organic-rich shales in the target section of this study area mainly develop organic pores (51%), and are dominated by micro-pores (32.1%) and mesopores (54%) that are large in number and elliptical-shaped, with good storage capacity and good connectivity. The results of this study help to improve the understanding of the pore size of marine shales, the origin of siliceous minerals in marine shales, and the pore structure characteristics of marine shales, which are of great theoretical and practical significance for improving the theory of shale gas formation and guiding the selection of shale gas sweet spot.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2022quantitative,
  author = {Kun Zhang and Yan Song and Zhenxue Jiang and Dongsheng Xu and Lintao Li and Xuejiao Yuan and Pei Liu and Fengli Han and Liangyi Tang and Xueying Wang and Liwen Zhang and Jinbo Jiang and Zehao Zheng and Xuecheng Chen},
  title = {{Quantitative Comparison of Genesis and Pore Structure Characteristics of Siliceous Minerals in Marine Shale With Different TOC Contents–A Case Study on the Shale of Lower Silurian Longmaxi Formation in Sichuan Basin, Southern China}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Earth Science},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/feart.2022.887160},
}

Loading related content...

Figure