Quantitative Characterization of Macrophage, Lymphocyte, and Neutrophil Subtypes Within the Foreign Body Granuloma of Human Mesh Explants by 5-Marker Multiplex Fluorescence Microscopy

U. Klinge, Axel Dievernich, Johannes StegmaierFrontiers in Medicine 2022 · DOI

Abstract

Foreign bodies such as fibers of a surgical mesh induce a typical reaction with an inflammatory infiltrate that forms a surrounding granuloma. This infiltrate is dominated by macrophages, lymphocytes, and neutrophils, whereas its extent of collaboration is widely unknown. In this study, we analyzed 12 samples of surgical meshes explanted from humans by multiplex analyses with three different 5-marker panels - 1. macrophage panel: CD68, CD86, CD105, CD163, and CD206;

  1. lymphocyte panel: CD3, CD4, CD8, CD20, and CD68; and 3. neutrophil panel: CD15, histone, MPO, NE, and CD68. Measurement of fluorescence intensity within nuclear masks resulting from DAPI nuclear staining allows exact quantification of cells considered "positive" at a user-defined mean intensity threshold of > 100. Obviously, however, there is no natural threshold as a biological criterion for an intensity that separates "positive" stained cells from unstained cells ("negative"). Multiplex staining of 5 markers always reveals a high rate of coexpression for almost all of the 2^5 possible marker combinations (= 32 combinations, when using 5 markers simultaneously). The present staining results demonstrate that various morphological and functional subtypes of macrophages, lymphocytes, and neutrophils are abundant in the foreign body granuloma (FBG), which were investigated by regions of interest (ROI) with an area of 1 mm^2. The widespread coexpression of two or more markers underscores the complex collaboration network of the inflammatory infiltrate. The ability to combine spatial distribution with exact numerical analysis may offer new perspectives for our understanding of the complex interactions in this multidimensional process.

Introduction

Surgical meshes represent the standard of care for hernia repair, yet their implantation frequently triggers a chronic inflammatory response known as a Foreign Body Granuloma (FBG). While the primary constituents of this infiltrate—macrophages, lymphocytes, and neutrophils—are well-identified, their specific functional subtypes and interactive "collaboration" remain poorly understood. Traditional immunohistochemistry, typically limited to one or two markers, fails to capture the holistic complexity of the immune microenvironment. This study addresses this gap by employing high-dimensional multiplex fluorescence microscopy to provide a quantitative and spatial map of the FBG in human mesh explants.

Materials and Methods

The study analyzed 12 surgical meshes explanted from human patients (materials included Polypropylene, Polyvinylidene fluoride, and Polyester) incorporated for periods ranging from 2 months to 17 years. Explantation was necessitated by clinical complications such as recurrence, chronic pain, or infection.

Researchers utilized 5-marker multiplex fluorescence microscopy to simultaneously detect five cellular markers alongside a DAPI nuclear stain on single tissue sections. Three specialized panels were developed:

  1. Macrophage Panel: CD68 (pan-marker), CD86 (M1/pro-inflammatory), CD105 (activation), CD163, and CD206 (M2/anti-inflammatory).
  2. Lymphocyte Panel: CD3 (T-cells), CD4 (helper T-cells), CD8 (cytotoxic T-cells), CD20 (B-cells), and CD68.
  3. Neutrophil Panel: CD15 (neutrophils), Histone H3, Myeloperoxidase (MPO), Neutrophil Elastase (NE), and CD68.
Multiplex fluorescence imaging of the macrophage panel on polypropylene fibers, showing individual markers and their overlay.

Automated image cytometry was performed using StrataQuest software. DAPI staining was used to generate "nuclear masks," enabling the measurement of mean fluorescence intensity for each marker within individual cells. A threshold of >100 was established to quantify all 2^5 (32) possible combinations of marker expression per panel.

Results

The quantitative mapping revealed a dense and diverse immune infiltrate. In a representative 1 mm^2 Region of Interest (ROI) containing approximately 2,000 cells, the FBG typically comprised 400 macrophages (CD68+), 300 T-cells (CD3+), and 260 neutrophils (CD15+).

Significant differences were observed between the FBG and the surrounding scar tissue. Specifically, CD86+ (M1) and CD206+ (M2) macrophages were significantly more prevalent within the FBG compared to scar tissue (p < 0.044 and p < 0.000, respectively). Furthermore, the analysis of all 32 possible marker combinations highlighted the extreme complexity of the infiltrate; for instance, a subset of cells expressed all five macrophage markers simultaneously.

Quantitative analysis of macrophage marker combinations and comparison between Foreign Body Granuloma (FBG) and scar tissue.

Discussion

A key finding of this research is the "blurred cloud" of coexpression. Rather than distinct "positive" and "negative" populations, scatter plots indicated a continuous spectrum of marker intensities. This suggests high cellular plasticity, where immune cells in a granuloma exist in transitional functional states rather than rigid categories.

The high rate of coexpression—nearly 70% of CD68+ macrophages also expressed the M1 marker CD86, often alongside M2 markers—underscores a complex "collaboration network." Additionally, the study confirmed the presence of Neutrophil Extracellular Traps (NETs) within the FBG, identified by extranuclear DAPI staining colocalized with MPO and NE, indicating that neutrophils are active structural participants in chronic inflammation.

Spatial analysis further revealed non-random distribution: macrophages and CD4+ T-helper cells tended to cluster near mesh fibers, while CD20+ B-cells formed clusters at greater distances.

Conclusion and Limitations

While the study provides a new standard for quantifying the FBG, it is limited by the subjective nature of intensity thresholding and a relatively small sample size of 12 explants. Future research involving larger cohorts and higher-plex panels (10+ markers) could link specific immune signatures to clinical outcomes, moving toward precision medicine in surgical mesh selection and patient management.

Summary updated

Abstract

Foreign bodies such as fibers of a surgical mesh induce a typical reaction with an inflammatory infiltrate that forms a surrounding granuloma. This infiltrate is dominated by macrophages, lymphocytes, and neutrophils, whereas its extent of collaboration is widely unknown. In this study, we analyzed 12 samples of surgical meshes explanted from humans by multiplex analyses with three different 5-marker panels - 1. macrophage panel: CD68, CD86, CD105, CD163, and CD206; 2. lymphocyte panel: CD3, CD4, CD8, CD20, and CD68; and 3. neutrophil panel: CD15, histone, MPO, NE, and CD68. Measurement of fluorescence intensity within nuclear masks resulting from DAPI nuclear staining allows exact quantification of cells considered "positive" at a user-defined mean intensity threshold of > 100. Obviously, however, there is no natural threshold as a biological criterion for an intensity that separates "positive" stained cells from unstained cells ("negative"). Multiplex staining of 5 markers always reveals a high rate of coexpression for almost all of the 2<sup>5</sup> possible marker combinations (= 32 combinations, when using 5 markers simultaneously). The present staining results demonstrate that various morphological and functional subtypes of macrophages, lymphocytes, and neutrophils are abundant in the foreign body granuloma (FBG), which were investigated by regions of interest (ROI) with an area of 1 mm<sup>2</sup>. The widespread coexpression of two or more markers underscores the complex collaboration network of the inflammatory infiltrate. The ability to combine spatial distribution with exact numerical analysis may offer new perspectives for our understanding of the complex interactions in this multidimensional process.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{klinge2022quantitative,
  author = {U. Klinge and Axel Dievernich and Johannes Stegmaier},
  title = {{Quantitative Characterization of Macrophage, Lymphocyte, and Neutrophil Subtypes Within the Foreign Body Granuloma of Human Mesh Explants by 5-Marker Multiplex Fluorescence Microscopy}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Medicine},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fmed.2022.777439},
}
Figure