Quantitative 3D analysis of complex single border cell behaviors in coordinated collective cell migration

Adam Cliffe, David P. Doupé, Hsin-Ho Sung, Isaac Kok Hwee Lim, Kok Haur Ong, Li Cheng, Weimiao YuNature Communications 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces CCMToolKit, a novel 4D (3D + time) image analysis toolkit for quantifying collective cell migration in the Drosophila border cell system. It enables detailed analysis of individual cell behaviors within a migrating cluster, revealing distinct "running" and "rotating" migration modes and uncovering that individual cells are surprisingly more active during slower, rotating migration.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Collective cell migration is fundamental to many biological processes, from development to disease. While imaging these complex, coordinated movements in 3D is becoming feasible, quantifying the behavior of individual cells within a migrating cluster has remained a significant challenge. Previous studies often relied on 2D projections or simplified analyses, missing crucial 3D dynamics. This paper addresses the need for a robust computational solution to precisely analyze and quantify individual cell behaviors and their coordination within a 3D migrating cluster, specifically in the well-established Drosophila border cell system.

Methods

The core of this work is the CCMToolKit, a comprehensive image analysis pipeline. Key steps include:

  • Image Pre-processing: Correcting for photo-bleaching, anisotropic voxel sizes, and signal-to-noise ratios.
  • Nuclei Segmentation: Employing a Gaussian Mixture Model (GMM) to segment individual nuclei.
  • Nuclei/Cell Tracking: A novel approach using a global cost function optimization based on appearance and spatial proximity to track nuclei and cells across time, ensuring accurate association even with variable speeds.
  • Cell Segmentation: Utilizing a marker-controlled watershed algorithm, seeded by the segmented nuclei, to delineate cell membranes.
  • Quantitative Feature Extraction: Measuring parameters like nucleus/cell volume, speed, external and internal cell-cell contact surfaces, cluster polarization (GP), and angular momentum (AM).
  • Morphological Dynamics Analysis: A method to estimate cell surface deformation in 3D over time, allowing for the quantification of internal and external cell extensions.
  • Running/Rotating Mode Classification: Defining and quantifying two distinct migration modes based on GP and AM values.

Datasets

The study utilizes 3D time-lapse microscopy data of migrating Drosophila border cell clusters. Specific details on the number of movies or time points analyzed for each specific result are provided throughout the paper (e.g., 42 migrating clusters analyzed for running/rotating classification, 116 time points for rotating, 134 for running). The authors also generated specific datasets with single cell or polar cell labeling to aid in volume and boundary calibration.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Individual Cell Activity in Rotating Mode: Counter-intuitively, individual cells are more active (based on six measured parameters) during the slower "rotating" migration mode compared to the faster "running" mode. This suggests that slower migration doesn't equate to cellular quiescence.
  • Distinct Migration Modes: The paper quantitatively defines and differentiates "running" (high polarization, low angular momentum) and "rotating" (low polarization, high angular momentum) migration modes, moving beyond qualitative observations.
  • Neighbor Exchange: The toolkit can identify and quantify "neighbor exchange," where individual cells swap positions within the cluster, highlighting the dynamic nature of cell positioning.
  • Internal Cell Extensions: The study identifies and quantifies "cluster internal cell extensions" during rotating mode, which were previously difficult to characterize and are linked to cluster rotation and neighbor exchange.
  • External Protrusions Drive Running: Cluster external protrusions are strongly correlated with the "running" mode, suggesting they are key drivers of directed forward movement.

Key Results

  • CCMToolKit Performance: The toolkit achieves high accuracy in segmentation and tracking, with a reported true positive rate >82% and false negative rate of ~15% compared to manual segmentation. It also demonstrates more consistent cell volume measurements than manual methods.
  • Migration Speeds: Border cells typically move at low speeds (<5 µm/min) with occasional bursts of higher speed (~10 µm/min). The average speed in 3D is higher than previous 2D reports due to the inclusion of the z-axis.
  • Running vs. Rotating: Running mode is associated with significantly larger external protrusions (~150 µm³/min) compared to rotating mode (~25 µm³/min). Internal cell extensions are strongly associated with rotating mode.
  • Cell Activity: Six measured parameters indicate cells are slightly more active in rotating mode than running mode.
  • Neighbor Exchange: The temporal topology change metric successfully identified multiple instances of neighbor exchange in movies.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Segmentation Limitations: While robust, segmentation accuracy is still limited by current microscopy techniques, particularly in resolving fine membrane structures. Segmentation errors can occur, especially when membranes are close or noisy.
  • Temporal Resolution: The current temporal resolution might limit definitive conclusions on certain dynamic processes, such as the periodic behavior of positive deformation energy.
  • Continuum of Behaviors: The paper acknowledges that migration modes exist on a continuum, and some behaviors may not fit neatly into the defined running or rotating categories.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest further investigation into the mechanisms driving transitions between running and rotating modes, measuring tension, and assessing signaling pathway reporters. The CCMToolKit is presented as a valuable tool for characterizing mutant phenotypes and exploring other cell migration problems.

Summary updated

Abstract

Understanding the mechanisms of collective cell migration is crucial for cancer metastasis, wound healing and many developmental processes. Imaging a migrating cluster in vivo is feasible, but the quantification of individual cell behaviours remains challenging. We have developed an image analysis toolkit, CCMToolKit, to quantify the Drosophila border cell system. In addition to chaotic motion, previous studies reported that the migrating cells are able to migrate in a highly coordinated pattern. We quantify the rotating and running migration modes in 3D while also observing a range of intermediate behaviours. Running mode is driven by cluster external protrusions. Rotating mode is associated with cluster internal cell extensions that could not be easily characterized. Although the cluster moves slower while rotating, individual cells retain their mobility and are in fact slightly more active than in running mode. We also show that individual cells may exchange positions during migration.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cliffe2017quantitative,
  author = {Adam Cliffe and David P. Doupé and Hsin-Ho Sung and Isaac Kok Hwee Lim and Kok Haur Ong and Li Cheng and Weimiao Yu},
  title = {{Quantitative 3D analysis of complex single border cell behaviors in coordinated collective cell migration}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1038/ncomms14905},
}

Loading related content...

Figure