Quantifying the impact of air pollution from coal-fired electricity generation on crop productivity in India

Kirat Singh, David B. Lobell, Inês L. AzevedoProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study quantifies the significant crop losses in India caused by nitrogen dioxide (NO2) emissions from coal-fired power plants, revealing that these damages can exceed 10% in heavily exposed regions. Importantly, the intensity of crop damage per unit of electricity generated is often higher than mortality damage intensity, suggesting that policies aimed at reducing coal emissions should prioritize crop productivity alongside health benefits.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

India faces a critical challenge in balancing its growing demand for food and electricity. While coal power is a dominant energy source, its contribution to air pollution is well-documented, with known impacts on human health. However, the specific impact of coal-fired electricity generation on crop productivity in India, a major agricultural nation and global food supplier, has remained quantitatively unassessed. This paper aims to fill that gap by estimating crop losses from NO2 emissions, a key pollutant from coal combustion, and comparing these agricultural damages to mortality damages.

Methods

The researchers developed a novel regression model to attribute NO2 concentrations over cropland to emissions from specific coal power stations. This model leverages:

  • Station-level electricity generation data: Daily generation figures for each power plant.
  • Wind direction data: To understand how emissions are dispersed.
  • Satellite-measured NO2 concentrations: Tropospheric Vertical Column Density (TVCD) data from TROPOMI.
  • Crop greenness data: Near-Infrared reflectance of vegetation (NIRv) from MODIS, used as a proxy for crop health and productivity.

A key methodological innovation is the use of wind direction fluctuations as an instrumental variable. By analyzing how changes in wind direction alter the exposure of cropland to emissions from a specific power station, the study can isolate the impact of coal-fired generation on NO2 levels and, subsequently, on crop yields. This approach allows for the estimation of crop damages even at distances up to 100 km from power plants. The study then uses established exposure-response relationships to translate NO2 impacts on crop greenness into yield loss estimates for rice and wheat.

Datasets

The study utilized several key datasets:

  • TROPOMI NO2 TVCD data: Daily measurements of nitrogen dioxide concentrations.
  • Central Electricity Authority (CEA) data: Daily electricity generation time series for Indian power plants.
  • ERA5-Land Reanalysis data: Daily wind direction, temperature, and precipitation data.
  • MODIS data: Near-Infrared reflectance of vegetation (NIRv) estimates.
  • ESA WorldCover dataset: A cropland mask.
  • Indian Ministry of Agriculture and Farmers Welfare data: State-level crop output estimates for rice and wheat.
  • Previous research data: Unit-level estimates of premature mortality associated with NO2, SO2, and PM2.5 emissions from Indian coal plants.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Widespread impact of coal NO2: Coal emissions don't just affect nearby areas; their impact on NO2 concentrations and crop productivity extends up to 100 km from power stations.
  • Significant yield losses: In regions heavily exposed to coal-linked NO2, annual yield losses for rice and wheat can exceed 10%, a substantial figure equivalent to several years of average yield growth.
  • Damage intensity matters: While absolute crop damages from individual stations are often lower than mortality damages, the intensity of crop damage (damage per GWh of electricity generated) is frequently higher. This highlights that reducing coal generation can be more cost-effective for agricultural gains than for health gains in many locations.
  • Divergent priorities: The power stations causing the largest crop losses are not necessarily the same ones causing the highest mortality. This suggests that optimizing emissions reductions requires considering both impacts.
  • Co-optimization is key: Simultaneously optimizing for crop gains and mortality reduction leads to a more equitable distribution of social benefits and a more comprehensive policy approach.

Key Results

  • In parts of West Bengal, Madhya Pradesh, and Uttar Pradesh, annual yield losses from coal-linked NO2 exceed 10%.
  • These losses are equivalent to approximately 6 years of average annual yield growth for rice and wheat between 2011 and 2020.
  • Rice damage intensity exceeds mortality damage intensity at 58 out of 144 studied power stations.
  • Wheat damage intensity exceeds mortality damage intensity at 35 out of 144 studied power stations.
  • Monetized potential gains from eliminating coal NO2 emissions are estimated at approximately US$420 million/year for rice and US$400 million/year for wheat across the top ten producing states.
  • Co-optimizing for mortality and crop damages when reducing 10% of annual generation yields total benefits of approximately US$2.02 billion/year, with crop gains contributing significantly.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Confounding emissions: The attribution model cannot definitively exclude the impact of other non-coal NO2 emission sources that might be colocated with coal power stations.
  • Indirect pathways: The study's NO2 coefficient captures the net impact of various processes (direct phytotoxicity, ozone formation, aerosol effects) but doesn't fully disentangle them. Future work could explore these mechanisms separately using more advanced satellite data.
  • Other pollutants and crops: The analysis focuses solely on NO2 and rice/wheat. It does not account for other air pollutants from coal generation (SO2, PM2.5) or other important crops, potentially underestimating total damages.
  • Seasonal vs. Annual impacts: Comparing seasonal crop damages with annual mortality damages presents a challenge. Future research could investigate the human health impacts of seasonal emissions from coal power plants to enable more direct comparisons.

The authors suggest that future research could combine TROPOMI NO2 observations with geocoded NOx emission inventories to better isolate noncoal sources, and explore the separation of different NO2 impact mechanisms. They also highlight the need to consider other crops and pollutants for a more complete picture of coal's agricultural impact.

Summary updated

Abstract

Air pollution from coal electricity generation is a major driver of poor air quality in India and its effects on human health have been extensively studied. Despite considerable evidence that the same pollution also reduces crop productivity, we lack similar quantitative assessments of coal electricity's crop damages. Here, we estimate rice and wheat crop losses from coal generation's nitrogen dioxide (NO<sub>2</sub>) emissions using a regression model that combines station-level electricity generation and wind direction, satellite-measured NO<sub>2</sub>, and its association with crop productivity. Coal emissions impact yields up to 100 km away from power stations. In parts of West Bengal, Madhya Pradesh, and Uttar Pradesh heavily exposed to coal-linked NO<sub>2</sub>, annual yield losses exceed 10%, equivalent to approximately 6 y worth of average annual yield growth in both rice and wheat in India between 2011 and 2020. While station-specific crop damages (value of lost output) are almost always lower than mortality damages (monetized value of annual premature PM<sub>2.5</sub>-related deaths), crop damage intensity (crop damage per GWh of electricity generated) is frequently higher than mortality damage intensity (mortality damage/GWh). Rice damage intensity exceeds mortality damage intensity at 58, and wheat damage intensity at 35 of the 144 power stations studied. The stations associated with the largest crop losses differ from those associated with the highest mortality. Co-optimizing for crop gains and mortality reduction slightly increases and meaningfully changes the distribution of social benefits from reducing emissions, highlighting the importance of considering crop losses alongside health impacts when regulating coal electricity emissions in India.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{singh2025quantifying,
  author = {Kirat Singh and David B. Lobell and Inês L. Azevedo},
  title = {{Quantifying the impact of air pollution from coal-fired electricity generation on crop productivity in India}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.2421679122},
}
Figure