Quantifying the Comprehensive Water Resources and Environment Carrying Capacity in Wuhan City Based on the “Human-Water-City” Framework

Huiyuan Liu, Yi Dong, Jun Xia, Guoqing Wang, Jun MaWater 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel "Human-Water-City" (HWC) framework and a quantitative model to assess Wuhan's comprehensive water resources and environmental carrying capacity (CWRECC). The study reveals that while Wuhan has sufficient water quantity, water quality issues lead to an overloaded state in certain years, highlighting the need for improved environmental protection to ensure sustainable urban development.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Rapid economic growth and urbanization in China have created significant conflicts between development and resource sustainability, particularly concerning water. Urban areas face challenges like water scarcity and environmental degradation. Existing methods for assessing water carrying capacity often focus on single dimensions or provide relative scores, failing to capture the complex, interconnected feedback loops between human activities, water resources, and the urban environment. This paper aims to address this by developing a comprehensive, quantitative model that integrates both water quantity and quality, considering the dynamic "Human-Water-City" interactions, to determine the actual sustainable limits for population and economic development.

Methods

The core of this research is the development of a "Human-Water-City" (HWC) feedback framework. This framework conceptualizes humans, water, and the city as interconnected subsystems, encompassing modules like population, human well-being, water resources, water environment, urban economy, and urban environment.

Based on this framework, the authors propose a quantitative model for Comprehensive Water Resources and Environmental Carrying Capacity (CWRECC). This model integrates water quantity (water resources carrying capacity) and water quality (water environment carrying capacity) dimensions. Crucially, it applies the "Cannikin Law" principle, which states that a system's capacity is limited by its weakest component. Therefore, the CWRECC is determined by the minimum of the water resources carrying capacity and the water environment carrying capacity for each year.

The model then uses this CWRECC to calculate the maximum sustainable population and Gross Domestic Product (GDP) that Wuhan can support. This involves solving a system of equations derived from the HWC feedback mechanisms, using historical data for various parameters.

Datasets

The study utilizes data for Wuhan City from 2013 to 2020. The primary data sources include:

  • Wuhan Statistical Yearbook: For socioeconomic data.
  • Water Resources Bulletin of Wuhan City and Hubei Province: For water resources information.
  • Environmental Quality Bulletin of Wuhan City: For water quality data.
  • Water extraction permit licenses: From the Changjiang Water Resources Commission for transit water data.
  • Chinese national standards: For pollutant concentration references (e.g., "Surface Water Environmental Quality Standards" GB3838-2002, "Water Quality Standards for Urban Sewage Discharge" GB_T 31962-2015, "Pollutant Discharge Standards for Urban Sewage Treatment Plants" GB 18918-2002).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Cannikin Law" is crucial for realistic carrying capacity assessment: Simply having abundant water quantity isn't enough; the weakest link (in this case, water quality) dictates the overall sustainable capacity. This is a critical insight for urban planning.
  • Wuhan's water quantity is abundant, but quality is the bottleneck: The study clearly shows that Wuhan has more than enough water to meet its needs in terms of volume. However, pollution issues mean that the quality of that water limits how much development can be supported.
  • The HWC framework provides a holistic view: By explicitly linking human activities, water systems, and the urban environment, the framework helps understand complex feedback loops that traditional single-indicator approaches miss.
  • Overload periods are linked to environmental stress: The identified years of CWRECC overload (2013, 2014, 2018, 2019) correlate with periods of water environmental strain, suggesting a direct impact of pollution on sustainable development.

Key Results

  • Water Resources Carrying Capacity: From 2013-2020, Wuhan's water resources carrying capacity could sustain populations ranging from 22.63 to 61.17 million and GDP from 1946.6 to 7988.9 billion yuan. This indicates a sustainable state in terms of water quantity.
  • Water Environment Carrying Capacity: In 2013, 2014, 2018, and 2019, the CWRECC was overloaded. During these years, the sustainable population was limited to 9.88-10.57 million, and GDP to 849.5-1538.9 billion yuan, falling short of actual figures.
  • Integrated CWRECC: The integrated index (I) showed favorable conditions in 2016 (0.56) and 2020 (0.57), but dropped to its lowest in 2018-2019 (0.24), largely due to reduced precipitation impacting water cycle efficiency.
  • Population and GDP Limits: The study found that the water environment carrying capacity was the more restrictive constraint, determining the maximum sustainable population and GDP. In overload years, actual population and GDP exceeded these CWRECC thresholds.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data limitations: While the study uses available data, the complexity of non-point source pollution and its migration processes means current research in this area is still maturing.
  • Model assumptions: The model assumes a steady-state for water environment calculations and disregards pollutant exchange with surrounding cities.
  • Future work: The authors suggest that the HWC framework and CWRECC model are adaptable to other urban contexts. Future research could focus on refining the model by incorporating more detailed feedback mechanisms and exploring the impact of climate change on water resources and carrying capacity. The study also highlights the need for authorities to prioritize water environmental protection and allocate sufficient attention to ensure sustainable water resource management.

Summary updated

Abstract

In recent years, China’s rapid economic growth and urbanization have heightened the conflict between economic development and resource sustainability, leading to severe urban water challenges, including scarcity and environmental degradation. This study proposes a quantitative model that integrates the “Human-Water-City” (HWC) feedback mechanisms to assess and measure urban comprehensive water resources and environmental carrying capacity (CWRECC), aimed at addressing urban water sustainability challenges. The CWRECC integrates water quantity and quality dimensions following the principles of the “Cannikin Law”—selecting the lower envelope between water resources and water environment carrying capacities, which emphasizes the importance of weaknesses in enhancing the overall system. The maximum sustainable population and Gross Domestic Product (GDP) under the CWRECC constraints can be obtained using this quantitative method. A case study was conducted in Wuhan City. The results show that Wuhan has abundant water resources. From 2013 to 2020, if only considering the water quantity aspect, the water resources carrying capacity could support a population ranging from 22.63 to 61.17 million and a GDP between 1946.6 and 7988.9 billion yuan, maintaining a sustainable state throughout the period. However, when considering both water quantity and quality, the CWRECC revealed an overloaded state in 2013, 2014, 2018, and 2019, primarily attributable to significant water environmental issues. In 2013, 2014, 2018, and 2019, the quantified CWRECC could sustain populations of 9.88 million, 10.01 million, 10.33 million, and 10.57 million people, and support a GDP of 849.5 billion, 976.5 billion, 1402.9 billion, and 1538.9 billion yuan, respectively. Both the population and GDP capacities fell short of the actual recorded values for those years. The findings demonstrate that Wuhan needs to make greater efforts in water environmental protection to sustain the harmonious development within the HWC. This empirical study highlights the model’s potential to provide a scientific foundation for urban water resources management and environmental protection strategies.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2025quantifying,
  author = {Huiyuan Liu and Yi Dong and Jun Xia and Guoqing Wang and Jun Ma},
  title = {{Quantifying the Comprehensive Water Resources and Environment Carrying Capacity in Wuhan City Based on the “Human-Water-City” Framework}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/w17162489},
}
Figure