Quantifying heat transfer in DMD-based optoelectronic tweezers with infrared thermography

Peter J. Pauzauskie, Hsan-Yin Hsu, Arash Jamshidi, Justin K. Valley, Shao Ning Pei, Ming C. WuProceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE 2010 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper quantifies the thermal effects of optoelectronic tweezers (OET) using infrared thermography, revealing that Joule heating is the primary source of temperature increase. They demonstrate that by removing insulating glass supports and directly contacting the device with a cooling stage, temperature increases can be limited to below 0.5°C, crucial for handling heat-sensitive biological samples.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Optoelectronic tweezers (OET) are a powerful tool for manipulating microscopic objects, including living cells, by combining optical trapping with dielectrophoresis. However, a critical concern for applications involving heat-sensitive biological samples is the potential for localized heating within the OET device. This heating can arise from the applied electric fields (Joule heating) and, to a lesser extent, from optical absorption. Understanding and controlling these thermal effects is essential for ensuring the viability and integrity of the manipulated samples. This paper addresses the need for quantitative measurements of these thermal profiles in OET devices, particularly those utilizing phototransistors (PhOET), to inform their design and operation for sensitive biological applications.

Methods

The researchers employed midwave infrared (3-5 micron) thermographic imaging to measure the temperature profiles of PhOET devices. They investigated two primary configurations: one where the PhOET device was supported by a glass coverslip (acting as a thermal insulator) and another where the device was in direct contact with a thermoelectric cooling stage. The experimental setup involved a DMD-based OET system, a function generator to apply AC voltages, and an infrared camera positioned to capture thermal images. They also performed finite element simulations using COMSOL to model heat transfer within the device and validate their experimental findings. The simulations focused on Joule heating of the electrolyte and heat transfer through the silicon wafer.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental measurements and simulations rather than pre-existing datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Joule Heating Dominates: The study clearly identifies Joule heating of the electrolyte solution as the primary contributor to temperature increases in PhOET devices, rather than optical absorption from the DMD projector.
  • Thermal Insulation is a Major Factor: The presence of a glass coverslip significantly increases device temperature due to its thermal insulating properties. Removing this insulation is a key strategy for thermal management.
  • Direct Cooling is Highly Effective: Direct contact between the PhOET device and a thermoelectric cooling stage dramatically reduces temperature increases, limiting them to well below 1°C.
  • Optical Illumination Adds Minimal Heat: The additional heating from the low-intensity optical illumination used for trapping is minimal, on the order of 0.2°C, and is rapidly compensated for by the cooling stage.
  • Finite Element Modeling Validates Experiments: The simulation results closely matched experimental observations, reinforcing the understanding of heat transfer mechanisms and the dominance of Joule heating.

Key Results

  • With Glass Insulation:
    • At 20 Vpp, 1 MHz, temperature increases of approximately 2.5°C were observed.
  • The ratio of temperature increase at 20 Vpp to 15 Vpp was found to be ~1.9, consistent with the quadratic dependence of Joule heating on voltage.
  • DMD illumination added an additional temperature increase of about 0.2°C.
  • Without Glass Insulation (Direct Contact with Cooling Stage):
    • At 20 Vpp, 1 MHz, temperature increases were limited to approximately 0.4°C.
  • At 15 Vpp, 1 MHz, the temperature increase was observed to be ~0.1°C, about 10 times lower than with glass insulation.
  • The finite element simulation predicted temperature increases of around 0.5°C for the device without illumination and direct cooling, which aligns well with experimental results.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations: * The study focused on steady-state temperature measurements. Dynamic temperature changes during rapid OET operation were not extensively explored. * The measurements were performed on PhOET devices fabricated with a specific silicon wafer and glass coverslip. Variations in materials or fabrication could influence thermal behavior.

Future Work: * The authors suggest future work will focus on measuring in situ device temperatures with and without DLP® illumination, implying a deeper dive into the combined effects. * Further investigation into optimizing thermal management strategies for various OET applications, especially those requiring precise temperature control for live cell experiments, would be a natural progression.

Summary updated

Abstract

Optoelectronic tweezers (OET) have emerged in recent years as a powerful form of optically-induced dielectrophoresis for addressing single cells and trapping individual nanostructures with DMD-based virtual-electrodes. In this technique an alternating electric field is used to induce a dipole within structures of interest while very low-intensity optical images are used to produce local electric field gradients that create dynamic trapping potentials. Addressing living cells, particularly for heat-sensitive cell lines, with OET's optical virtual-electrodes requires an in-depth understanding of heating profiles within OET devices. In this work we present quantitative measurements of the thermal characteristics of single-crystalline-silicon phototransistor based optoelectronic tweezers (PhOET). Midwave infrared (3 - 5 micron) thermographic imaging is used to determine relative heating in PhOET devices both with and without DMD-based optical actuation. Temperature increases of approximately 2°C from electrolyte Joule-heating are observable in the absence of DMD-illumination when glass is used as a support for PhOET devices. An additional temperature increase of no more than 0.2°C is observed when DMD-illumination is used. Furthermore, significantly reduced heating can be achieved when devices are fabricated in direct contact with a metallic heat-sink.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{pauzauskie2010quantifying,
  author = {Peter J. Pauzauskie and Hsan-Yin Hsu and Arash Jamshidi and Justin K. Valley and Shao Ning Pei and Ming C. Wu},
  title = {{Quantifying heat transfer in DMD-based optoelectronic tweezers with infrared thermography}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1117/12.846247},
}
Figure