Quantifying and Comparing the Cooling Effects of Three Different Morphologies of Urban Parks in Chengdu

Xiaojing Feng, Jiahao Yu, Chuliang Xin, Tianhao Ye, Tian’ao Wang, Honglin Chen, Xuemei Zhang, Lili ZhangLand 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study quantifies the cooling effects of urban parks in Chengdu by classifying park morphologies and analyzing their impact on local temperatures. It reveals that round parks generally offer the best cooling, with specific thresholds for park area and perimeter influencing cooling distance and area, and an optimal shape index for maximizing cooling efficiency.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The urban heat island (UHI) effect, characterized by elevated temperatures in urban areas compared to their rural surroundings, is a growing concern due to its negative impacts on human health, energy consumption, and overall quality of life. Urban parks are recognized as a crucial strategy for mitigating UHI. However, while the general cooling effect of parks is well-established, the specific influence of their morphology (shape, size, and boundary complexity) on this cooling effect remains underexplored. Existing research often uses simplified classifications (e.g., circular vs. square) and lacks a comprehensive, quantitative assessment of how different park shapes and characteristics contribute to cooling. This paper aims to fill this gap by providing a detailed, morphology-driven analysis of urban park cooling in Chengdu, a rapidly urbanizing city.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach:

  1. Morphological Classification: They developed a quantitative method to classify urban parks based on four key morphological indicators: area, perimeter, length-width ratio, and shape index. This classification went beyond simple geometric shapes to capture more complex park forms.
  2. Cooling Effect Assessment: Using Landsat-8 thermal infrared data, they derived Land Surface Temperature (LST) and then calculated four cooling indicators:
  3. Park Cooling Distance (PCD): The maximum distance from the park edge that experiences a cooling effect.
  4. Park Cooling Area (PCA): The total area influenced by the park's cooling effect.
  5. Park Cooling Intensity (PCI): The maximum temperature difference between the park's interior and its surroundings.
  6. Park Cooling Efficiency (PCE): The ratio of the cooling area to the park's total area, indicating how effectively the park cools its surroundings per unit of its own area.
  7. Spatial Statistics and Regression Analysis: These techniques were used to analyze the relationships between the morphological characteristics of the parks and their cooling indicators. They specifically looked for thresholds and optimal values for morphological parameters.

Datasets

  • Landsat-8 TIRS Satellite Imagery: Acquired on August 11, 2019, for the study area of Chengdu. This data was used to derive Land Surface Temperature (LST).
  • Urban Park Catalog: Provided by the Chengdu Landscape Park Bureau, containing data for 117 urban parks in the central city of Chengdu. This served as the basis for morphological analysis.
  • Geospatial Data: Open platforms like Guihuayun.cn and Amap.com were used to obtain urban park area data (AOIs).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Morphology Matters: The study strongly reinforces that not all parks cool equally; their shape and form are critical determinants of their effectiveness.
  • Round is Often Better (for Efficiency): Round parks, especially those with complex boundaries (higher shape index), demonstrated superior cooling efficiency and intensity, suggesting they are more economical in their cooling impact per unit area.
  • Size and Shape Thresholds are Key: The research identified specific thresholds for park area and perimeter beyond which the cooling effect's rate of increase diminishes or changes significantly. This is crucial for urban planning.
  • Complexity vs. Fragmentation: While a complex boundary (higher shape index) can enhance cooling, excessive fragmentation (indicated by a very high shape index) can reduce overall effectiveness.

Key Results

  • Morphological Classification: 117 parks were classified into five main types, with "strip parks" being the most numerous (60), followed by "round parks" (35).
  • Best Performing Morphology: Round parks exhibited the best overall cooling effect, with a cooling efficiency of 0.7.
  • Cooling Area Thresholds: The study identified thresholds for park area (30 ha) and perimeter (4000 m) that influence the park cooling area. Beyond 30 ha, the rate of cooling area increase slows.
  • Cooling Distance Thresholds: For cooling distance, the area threshold was found to be around 70 ha, beyond which the cooling range expansion slowed. A perimeter of 4000 m showed a significant increase in cooling distance, with a steeper increase beyond 9000 m.
  • Optimal Shape Index: The cooling efficiency of a park was found to be maximized when its shape index was approximately 2.8.
  • Correlation Findings: Park area and perimeter showed strong positive correlations with cooling area (PCA) and cooling distance (PCD). The shape index was significantly correlated with cooling efficiency (PCE).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Exclusion of Disturbances: While efforts were made to exclude large water bodies and green areas from buffer zones, the study acknowledges that other surrounding land uses and the three-dimensional urban structure (buildings) can influence cooling effects and were not fully accounted for.
  • LST vs. Air Temperature: The study used LST, which can differ from air temperature due to factors like vegetation and surface properties. Future work could integrate crowdsourced weather station data for a more direct air temperature assessment.
  • Local Scale Factors: Factors like surface evapotranspiration and topographic elevation can contribute to discrepancies between LST and air temperature at a local scale, suggesting these could be explored further.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest incorporating more detailed land use data and 3D urban structure information into future analyses. They also propose using crowdsourced weather station data to enhance the practical value of urban park cooling studies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Urban parks have significant cooling effects, which can both mitigate the urban heat is-land effect and are crucial to the sustainable development of the human habitat. Although studies have been conducted to explore the influence of urban park morphology on the cooling effect of parks, they are not sufficiently in depth. Therefore, this paper took 117 urban parks in the central city of Chengdu as the research objects based on the perspective of the quantitative classification of urban park morphology. Then, remote sensing interpretation, spatial statistics, and regression analysis were used, and the four indicators of cooling intensity, cooling distance, cooling area, and cooling efficiency of urban parks were integrated to explore the cooling effect of the different morphological types of urban parks. The results show that (1) urban parks in Chengdu could be divided into five categories, among which the cooling effect of round parks was the best, and the cooling efficiency was 0.7. (2) In terms of park cooling area, urban parks’ area and perimeter thresholds were 30 ha and 4000 m, respectively. (3) When the area and perimeter of urban parks reached 70 ha and 3000 m, respectively, the increase in the cooling distance slowed down. (4) The cooling efficiency of the park was best when the shape index (indicating the complexity of the park boundaries) of the urban park was 2.8. The results of the study provide theoretical support for the intensive use of urban park green space and help the construction and promotion of a beautiful and livable park city in Chengdu.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{feng2023quantifying,
  author = {Xiaojing Feng and Jiahao Yu and Chuliang Xin and Tianhao Ye and Tian’ao Wang and Honglin Chen and Xuemei Zhang and Lili Zhang},
  title = {{Quantifying and Comparing the Cooling Effects of Three Different Morphologies of Urban Parks in Chengdu}},
  booktitle = {Land},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/land12020451},
}
Figure