Quantifying and Characterizing Urban Leisure Activities by Merging Multiple Sensing Big Data: A Case Study of Nanjing, China

Shaojun Liu, Long Yao, Ling Zhang, Hao LiuLand 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel framework for understanding urban leisure activities by integrating multiple big data sources, including mobile signaling data, points of interest, and building information. By developing a spatiotemporal dasymetric interpolation method, the researchers provide a fine-grained analysis of where and when people engage in leisure, revealing key patterns and preferences in Nanjing, China.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how people use urban public spaces for leisure is crucial for effective urban planning, resource allocation, and enhancing quality of life. Traditional methods like surveys are time-consuming and prone to self-reporting bias. While big data offers a promising alternative, existing approaches often struggle with data sparsity, spatial uncertainty, and a lack of fine-grained temporal and spatial resolution. Specifically, this paper addresses the challenge of accurately mapping and characterizing urban leisure activities at a detailed level, considering both the "where" (spatial distribution) and "when" (temporal patterns) of these activities, as well as the types of leisure pursued.

Methods

The study proposes a five-step framework:

  1. Personal Activity Chain Construction: Mobile Signaling Data (MSD) is used to reconstruct individual daily activity chains, identifying stops and their durations. A speed and distance filter is applied to distinguish actual stops from mere transit.
  2. Home-Work Identification and Activity Timeshare Aggregation: To isolate leisure activities, common activities like "home" and "work" are identified and excluded. This involves classifying users as locals or visitors and analyzing their longest stay times to infer home and work locations. Remaining activities are aggregated into four time periods (early morning, morning, afternoon, night).
  3. Urban Leisure Districts (ULD) Extraction: Points of Interest (POIs) and Areas of Interest (AOIs) related to leisure are used to define potential leisure areas. The DBSCAN algorithm is employed to cluster these points and identify Urban Leisure Districts (ULDs), which represent the spatial scope of leisure activities.
  4. Spatiotemporal Capacity and Attraction Enhancement: The "capacity" of ULDs is evaluated by considering building footprints and floor heights, while "attraction" or popularity is measured using online review data (Dianping). "Openness" (operating hours) is also incorporated as a temporal constraint.
  5. Urban Leisure Estimation Using Dasymetric Spatiotemporal Interpolation: A novel dasymetric interpolation method is used to refine the spatiotemporal distribution of leisure activities. This method integrates the aggregated MSD data with the spatial and temporal constraints derived from ULDs, building data, and online reviews to produce a fine-scale estimation.

Datasets

  • Mobile Signaling Data (MSD): Obtained from a major Chinese mobile provider, covering 1-14 April 2019, with approximately 3.36 million users in Nanjing. This data captures communication logs (calls, SMS, internet usage) every half hour, with a positioning accuracy of 50-500m.
  • Points of Interest (POIs) and Areas of Interest (AOIs): Collected from AMAP and Baidu Map. This includes data on various functional land uses, with a subset specifically identified as leisure-related (e.g., museums, parks, restaurants, shopping malls).
  • Building Footprints and Floor Heights: Obtained from AMAP, providing detailed urban surface information.
  • Dianping Data: User reviews and ratings from the Dianping website, used to measure the popularity and attractiveness of leisure venues.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Data Fusion is Key: The study highlights the power of integrating diverse big data sources (mobility, points of interest, building data, online reviews) to overcome the limitations of any single source.
  • Beyond POI Density: The research moves beyond simply using POI density to represent leisure space, incorporating actual human activity traces and temporal constraints for a more accurate picture.
  • Urban Leisure Districts (ULDs): The concept of ULDs, derived from clustering leisure POIs, provides a more nuanced understanding of urban leisure spatial configurations than traditional density-based analyses.
  • Temporal Dynamics Matter: Leisure activities exhibit distinct diurnal and weekly patterns, with afternoons and weekends being particularly significant periods.
  • Spatial Inequality in Leisure: Leisure participation is unevenly distributed across the city, with the main urban area showing the highest activity, suggesting a correlation between resource agglomeration and participation.

Key Results

  • Leisure is Pervasive: Leisure activities constitute a significant portion of daily life, accounting for approximately 18.3% of weekday activities and 22.0% of weekend activities.
  • Afternoon Peak: The afternoon is identified as the primary breakout period for urban leisure, especially on weekends.
  • Recreation Dominates: Entertainment and sightseeing are the most popular leisure activities.
  • Weekday vs. Weekend Differences: While leisure activities increase on weekends, the diurnal patterns show more pronounced differences between weekdays and weekends, particularly in the afternoon.
  • Spatial Heterogeneity: Leisure participation is highest in the main city and lowest in the Xianlin secondary city, correlating with the distribution of leisure resources.
  • Resource Allocation Matters: Spatial regression modeling indicates that the configuration of leisure facilities significantly explains leisure activity patterns, especially in the main urban area.

Limitations and Future Work

  • MSD Uncertainty: The inherent spatiotemporal uncertainty of cellular positioning in MSD can lead to some recognition errors, potentially misclassifying short relaxation periods or non-stationary workers as leisure.
  • Behavioral Nuances: The study did not delve into detailed personal behaviors like travel distance, frequency of activities, or specific mobility patterns, which are important for understanding human predictability.
  • Demographic Factors: Privacy concerns prevented the inclusion of demographic characteristics (age, gender, education) in the analysis, which could offer further insights into leisure behavior.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Classifying human communities based on long-term behaviors to improve activity recognition accuracy.
  • Investigating the driving mechanisms of leisure activity distribution, such as population density, traffic accessibility, and individual emotions.
  • Exploring the impact of demographic characteristics on leisure behavior by obtaining anonymized data.
  • Optimizing urban leisure resource layouts and supporting business site selection.

Summary updated

Abstract

Studying the spatiotemporal pattern of urban leisure activities helps us to understand the development and utilization of urban public space, people’s quality of life, and the happiness index. It has outstanding value for improving rational resource allocation, stimulating urban vitality, and promoting sustainable urban development. This study aims at discovering the spatiotemporal distribution patterns and people’s behavioral preferences of urban leisure activities using quantitative technology merging ubiquitous sensing big data. On the basis of modeling individual activity traces using mobile signaling data (MSD), we developed a space-time constrained dasymetric interpolation method to refine the urban leisure activity spatiotemporal distribution. We conducted an empirical study in Nanjing, China. The results indicate that leisure plays an essential role in daily human life, both on weekdays and weekends. Significant differences exist in spatiotemporal and type selection in urban leisure. The weekend afternoon is the breakout period of leisure, and entertainment is the most popular leisure activity. Furthermore, the correlation between leisure resource allocation and leisure activity participation was argued. Our findings confirm that data-driven approaches would be a promising method for analyzing human behavior patterns; therefore, assisting in land planning decisions and promoting social justice and sustainability.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2021quantifying,
  author = {Shaojun Liu and Long Yao and Ling Zhang and Hao Liu},
  title = {{Quantifying and Characterizing Urban Leisure Activities by Merging Multiple Sensing Big Data: A Case Study of Nanjing, China}},
  booktitle = {Land},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/land10111214},
}
Figure