TL;DR
This review synthesizes the clinical applications of wearable sensing and feedback for human gait analysis and intervention. It highlights the growing potential of these technologies to improve mobility and treat movement disorders, identifying key areas of application and suggesting future research directions.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The proliferation of miniaturized electronics has led to a surge in wearable devices and "quantified self" movements, where individuals track their own health and activity data. While these technologies are becoming commonplace, their actual clinical impact on human gait analysis and intervention remains unclear. This paper aims to bridge this knowledge gap by reviewing existing research on wearable sensing and feedback for gait, assessing their clinical applications, and identifying areas for future development. The authors are motivated by the potential of these portable systems to extend advanced gait analysis and intervention techniques, previously confined to research labs, to a broader population, especially those with movement disorders.
Methods
This paper is a systematic literature review. The authors searched four electronic databases (Medline, SCI-EXPANDED, CINAHL, and Cochrane Central Register for Controlled Trials) for articles published up to March 2013. The search terms combined "wearable" with "gait" and either "sensing" or "feedback." Inclusion criteria focused on articles employing wearable sensing or feedback for movements of the foot, ankle, shank, thigh, hip, pelvis, and trunk during gait. Articles were excluded if they involved non-living subjects, non-primary research, or activities other than gait. The review extracted data on study design, subject type, walking surface, gait parameters, sensor type, and feedback sensation type.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. This is a review article, not an empirical study that collected or analyzed specific datasets.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Bridging the Lab-to-Life Gap: Wearable systems offer a unique advantage over traditional lab-based equipment by enabling gait analysis and intervention in natural, real-world environments (home, work). This is crucial because gait patterns can differ significantly between controlled lab settings and everyday life.
- Quantified Self's Clinical Potential: The "quantified self" movement, while often focused on data collection, has direct clinical applications in gait. Wearable systems can move beyond simple data logging to facilitate "meaning-making" and "action-taking" for improved health outcomes.
- Sensing Dominates Feedback: The research landscape is heavily skewed towards wearable sensing for gait analysis, with significantly fewer studies exploring wearable feedback for intervention. This suggests a substantial opportunity for developing and validating wearable feedback systems.
- Common Gait Parameters: For both sensing and feedback, the knee and trunk were the most frequently targeted segments for gait parameter measurement. Kinematics (angles, velocities, accelerations) were more commonly studied than kinetics (forces, moments).
- Haptic Feedback's Promise: Haptic (touch) feedback is the most common sensation used for gait intervention, offering a promising avenue for retraining, especially in situations where visual or auditory feedback might be distracting or less effective in real-world scenarios.
Key Results
- Four Major Clinical Applications: The review identified four primary clinical applications for wearable sensing and feedback in gait:
- Identifying Movement Disorders: Detecting kinematic differences in patients (e.g., osteoarthritis, Parkinson's disease, hemiplegia) compared to healthy controls.
- Assessing Surgical Outcomes: Quantifying kinematic changes before and after surgical procedures (e.g., knee replacement, hip arthroplasty).
- Improving Walking Stability: Using feedback to reduce excessive trunk sway.
- Reducing Joint Loading: Employing feedback to modify gait patterns that decrease stress on joints, particularly the knee.
- Prevalent Patient Populations: For studies involving patients, osteoarthritis, vestibular loss, Parkinson's disease, and post-stroke hemiplegia were the most common.
- Dominant Sensor Technology: Inertial Measurement Units (IMUs), combining accelerometers and gyroscopes, were the most widely used wearable sensors.
- Feedback Modalities: Haptic (touch) and auditory feedback were the most common sensations used for intervention.
- Article Distribution: Out of 1344 articles initially retrieved, 76 met the inclusion criteria. A significant majority (70%) were published in the last 10 years prior to the review, indicating a rapidly growing field.
Limitations and Future Work
- Laboratory Bias: The vast majority of studies were conducted in laboratory settings, limiting the generalizability of findings to real-world environments.
- Healthy Subject Focus: Most research has focused on healthy individuals, with less investigation into patient populations.
- Limited Feedback Research: Wearable feedback for gait intervention is significantly less explored than sensing.
- Future Directions: The authors strongly advocate for future research to focus on:
- Patient Populations: Shifting research efforts to understand and address the gait needs of individuals with movement disorders.
- Natural Environments: Conducting studies in real-world settings (home, work) to assess the practical utility and effectiveness of wearable systems.
- Continuous, Long-Term Monitoring and Intervention: Leveraging the portability of wearables for sustained data collection and ongoing gait retraining, which is crucial for managing chronic conditions and achieving lasting behavioral changes.
- Exploring Untapped Feedback Modalities: While taste and smell were not used, the authors suggest creative future research could explore these.
Summary updated