Quantification of the Coordination Degree between Dianchi Lake Protection and Watershed Social-Economic Development: A Scenario-Based Analysis

Hansheng Kong, Yilei Lu, Xin Dong, Si-yu ZengSustainability 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper develops a novel integrated approach to quantify the coordination between socio-economic development and environmental protection in the Dianchi Lake basin. By analyzing ten future development scenarios, they identify a "High Protection-Medium Development" scenario as the most suitable for achieving sustainable development and meeting water quality targets by 2025.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Dianchi Lake, a vital freshwater resource in China, faces severe water pollution and eutrophication despite significant investment. This environmental degradation acts as a major bottleneck for the region's sustainable development. While previous studies focused on technical solutions for pollutant reduction, this research addresses the critical need for a policy-oriented approach that quantifies the complex interplay between socio-economic growth and environmental protection. The paper aims to identify future development pathways that balance these competing demands, ensuring long-term ecological health and regional prosperity.

Methods

The study employs a multi-faceted approach:

  • Coupling Coordination Degree (CCD) Model: This established model is adapted to quantify the degree of coordination between two subsystems: socio-economic development and the water environment. The model uses a set of indicators (e.g., GDP growth, urbanization rate, COD emissions, ammonia nitrogen levels) to calculate development indices for each subsystem, which are then combined to derive a coordination degree. The entropy weighting method is used to objectively determine the importance of each indicator.
  • Scenario Analysis: Ten distinct future development scenarios are designed for the Dianchi Lake basin, varying in their socio-economic development and water environment protection strategies (e.g., High-High, Medium-Medium, Low-Low). These scenarios represent different potential development trajectories.
  • Environmental Fluid Dynamics Code (EFDC) Model: This three-dimensional water quality model is used to simulate and verify the water quality outcomes under selected typical scenarios. It helps assess whether the proposed development pathways can achieve specific water quality targets.

Datasets

The study utilizes historical data for the Dianchi Lake basin to calibrate and verify the models. Specific datasets mentioned include:

  • Meteorological data (average annual temperature, average annual rainfall).
  • Socio-economic data (population, GDP, urban and rural income, industrial and agricultural added value).
  • Environmental data (water quality parameters like COD and ammonia nitrogen, sewage treatment rates, water use efficiency).
  • Historical water quality monitoring data for Dianchi Lake (e.g., annual average COD concentration in 2015).

No new datasets were introduced; rather, existing data was used to parameterize the models and define the scenarios.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "sweet spot" for Dianchi Lake: The research strongly suggests that a "High Protection-Medium Development" (H-M) scenario offers the most promising path forward. This highlights that aggressive socio-economic growth without commensurate environmental protection is unsustainable, and overly strict protection without development can also lead to imbalances.
  • Economic growth control is key: The study identifies that controlling economic growth rates (specifically GDP growth) and managing industrial development are crucial levers for improving the coordination degree. This is a significant policy implication, suggesting that slowing down rapid growth can paradoxically lead to better long-term outcomes.
  • Non-point source pollution is a major challenge: The paper emphasizes the importance of addressing non-point source pollution (e.g., from agriculture) as a highly effective strategy for improving the water environment subsystem. This points to the need for targeted rural environmental policies.
  • Water quality targets are achievable: The EFDC model simulations confirm that the H-M scenario can indeed meet the water quality targets for Dianchi Lake by 2025, providing a data-driven validation of the proposed development strategy.

Key Results

  • Best Scenario: The "High Protection-Medium Development" (H-M) scenario and the "Medium Development-Medium Protection" (M-M, or Planning) scenario were identified as the most suitable for future planning based on coordination analysis.
  • Water Quality Improvement: The H-M scenario demonstrated the most significant improvement in water quality, with simulated COD and ammonia nitrogen concentrations meeting or exceeding Class II and Class III water standards in most areas by 2025.
  • Policy Recommendations: To achieve the H-M scenario, the paper suggests:
  • Reducing expected GDP growth to 9.5% and population growth to 1.9%.
  • Maintaining industrial development growth at approximately 10.7%.
  • Strictly controlling agricultural and service sectors with poor pollution control.
  • Reducing COD emissions by 18% and ammonia nitrogen by 22%.
  • Increasing sewage treatment rates to approximately 98%.
  • Unsuitable Scenarios: Scenarios with "Low Protection" (e.g., L-H, L-M, L-L) were found to lead to significant system imbalance and water environment deterioration, making them unsuitable for future planning.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Time Scale: The authors acknowledge that the simulation time range (2016-2025) is relatively short.
  • Indicator Scope: They suggest that future research could expand the time scale and include a wider range of indicators, particularly other forms of water pollutants.
  • Model Granularity: While the EFDC model provides valuable insights, further refinement of pollutant input data and spatial distribution could enhance accuracy.

The paper's integrated approach and scenario-based analysis provide a robust framework for decision-making in complex socio-environmental systems, offering valuable lessons for other regions facing similar challenges.

Summary updated

Abstract

Dianchi Lake is the largest freshwater lake on the Yunnan–Guizhou Plateau near Kunming City, China. As one of the most polluted lakes in China, although billions of U.S. dollars have been spent trying to clean it up, water pollution and eutrophication are still a bottleneck for regional sustainable development. This research established an integrated approach for the evaluation of the coupling coordination degree to support future planning of the Dianchi Lake basin. Ten future scenarios for possible development directions of Dianchi Lake basin were designed to find the best balance between development and protection. Among these scenarios, a high protection–medium development scenario is the most suitable scenario for future development planning. To further improve the coordination degree, economic growth control and non-point source governance were the most effective and feasible approaches. Furthermore, a water quality model was used to verify the coordination degree. It was found that the high protection–medium development scenario can reach the water quality target in 2025. The coordination degree evaluation could be a practical link to help equilibrate the socio-economic development and environmental protection of the Dianchi Lake basin.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kong2020quantification,
  author = {Hansheng Kong and Yilei Lu and Xin Dong and Si-yu Zeng},
  title = {{Quantification of the Coordination Degree between Dianchi Lake Protection and Watershed Social-Economic Development: A Scenario-Based Analysis}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/su13010116},
}
Figure