Quantification of nematic cell polarity in three-dimensional tissues

André Scholich, Simon Syga, Hernán Morales-Navarrete, Fabian Segovia-Miranda, Hidenori Nonaka, Kirstin Meyer, Walter de Back, Lutz Brusch, Yannis Kalaidzidis, Marino Zerial, Frank Jülicher, Benjamin M. FriedrichPLOS Computational Biology 2020 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel mathematical framework, inspired by liquid crystal physics, to quantify complex "nematic cell polarity" in 3D tissues. They demonstrate its application to liver tissue, revealing a coordinated, tissue-wide organization of cell polarity that aligns with the blood transport network, suggesting a liquid-crystal-like behavior in biological tissues.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how cells organize their internal structures and surface proteins to establish polarity is fundamental to tissue function. While simple epithelial tissues exhibit a clear "vectorial" polarity (e.g., apical vs. basal), complex 3D tissues like the liver present a challenge. Hepatocytes in the liver have intricate apical membrane domains that don't conform to a single vector. This paper aims to develop a quantitative method to describe and analyze these complex, non-vectorial polarity patterns in 3D, and to understand how they are organized at the tissue level, particularly in relation to the surrounding microenvironment.

Methods

The authors propose a framework based on a multipole expansion of surface protein distributions, analogous to Fourier analysis. This allows them to decompose complex polarity patterns into different "modes." They specifically focus on the nematic mode, which captures orientational order without a defined direction (like a double-headed arrow). To quantify this, they introduce "co-orientational order parameters" (COOPs), generalizing concepts from liquid crystal physics. These COOPs are applied to 3D reconstructions of individual hepatocytes and then to ensembles of cells to reveal tissue-level organization. They also developed a "cuboid representation" to visualize these nematic polarity axes.

Datasets

The study utilizes 3D reconstructions of mouse liver tissue, specifically focusing on apical membrane domains of hepatocytes. They also use data from kidney epithelial cells for comparison. The data appears to be derived from high-resolution imaging, as described in previous work by some of the authors. No new benchmark datasets are introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Nematic Cell Polarity: The concept of "nematic cell polarity" is introduced to describe complex, non-vectorial polarity patterns, moving beyond the simple apical-basal vector.
  • Liquid Crystal Analogy: Liver tissue exhibits characteristics of a biaxial liquid crystal, with coordinated cell polarity aligning with the sinusoidal blood transport network.
  • COOPs for 3D Tissues: Co-orientational order parameters (COOPs) provide a robust way to quantify orientational order in 3D, even in the presence of curved director fields, overcoming limitations of traditional order parameters.
  • Sinusoidal Network as a Cue: The local anisotropy of the sinusoidal network appears to play a crucial role in orienting hepatocyte polarity.
  • Phase Biaxiality: The co-alignment between hepatocyte polarity and the sinusoidal network is not just uniaxial but "phase-biaxial," meaning it involves two distinct reference axes.

Key Results

  • Kidney epithelial cells predominantly exhibit vectorial cell polarity, as expected.
  • Hepatocytes in liver tissue display nematic cell polarity, characterized by a dominant second mode in their spherical power spectrum.
  • Hepatocyte nematic polarity is organized in a coordinated, tissue-wide manner, following curved director fields within the liver lobule.
  • This nematic cell polarity is biaxial and aligns with the local biaxial anisotropy of the sinusoidal blood transport network.
  • A minimal interaction model, focusing on the alignment of the hepatocyte's "ring axis" with the sinusoidal network's "plane axis," successfully reproduces the observed co-orientational order parameters.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their framework is a generalization of concepts from liquid crystals and that the biological interpretation of these parameters is still being explored. They suggest that this methodology could be applied to other tissues or in-vitro organoids to study tissue development, genetic perturbations, or disease states. The minimal interaction model provides a starting point for understanding the physical basis of this co-alignment, but further investigation into the precise nature of the interaction between sinusoids and hepatocytes is warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

Author summary Cell polarity enables cells to carry out specific functions. Cell polarity is characterized by the formation of different plasma membrane domains, each with specific composition of proteins, phospholipids and cytoskeletal components. In simple epithelial sheets, or tube-like tissues such as kidney, epithelial cells are known to display a single apical domain, facing a lumenal cavity, and a single basal domain on the opposite side of the cell, facing a basal layer of extracellular matrix. This apico-basal polarity defines a vector of cell polarity, which provides a direction of fluid transport, e.g., from the basal side of the sheet to the lumen-facing side. In more complex, three-dimensional epithelial tissues, such as liver tissue with its complex network of blood-transporting sinusoids, the membrane domains of hepatocyte cells display more intricate patterns, including rings and antipodal pairs of apical membrane. Here, we develop a mathematical framework to precisely characterize and quantify complex polarity patterns. Thereby, we reveal ordered patterns of cell polarity that span across a liver lobule. Our new method builds on physical concepts originally developed for ordered phases of liquid crystals. It provides a versatile tool to characterize the spatial organization of a complex three-dimensional tissue.
BibTeX
@article{scholich2020quantification,
  author = {André Scholich and Simon Syga and Hernán Morales-Navarrete and Fabian Segovia-Miranda and Hidenori Nonaka and Kirstin Meyer and Walter de Back and Lutz Brusch and Yannis Kalaidzidis and Marino Zerial and Frank Jülicher and Benjamin M. Friedrich},
  title = {{Quantification of nematic cell polarity in three-dimensional tissues}},
  journal = {PLOS Computational Biology},
  year = {2020},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=j6mBJgEJBU},
}
Figure