Quantification of black carbon mixing state from traffic: implications for aerosol optical properties

Megan D. Willis, Robert M. Healy, Nicole Riemer, Matthew West, Jonathan M. Wang, Cheol–Heon Jeong, John Wenger, Greg J. Evans, Jonathan P. D. Abbatt, A. K. Y. Lee2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This study quantifies the mixing state of black carbon (BC) particles emitted from traffic, revealing that BC is primarily found in "BC-rich" particles, not uniformly distributed. Accurately accounting for this initial mixing state significantly impacts modeled aerosol optical properties, particularly the single scattering albedo, by up to 0.1, highlighting its importance for climate modeling.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Black carbon (BC) is a potent absorber of solar radiation, playing a significant role in climate warming. However, its precise climatic impact is poorly understood, largely due to the complex and variable physical and chemical properties of BC-containing aerosols. A key factor influencing these properties is the "mixing state" – how BC is distributed within individual aerosol particles, especially at the point of emission. Previous studies have struggled to simultaneously quantify BC's mixing state and the composition of other co-emitted aerosols. This lack of detailed information makes it difficult to accurately model BC's optical properties and, consequently, its radiative forcing. This paper aims to address this gap by providing quantitative measurements of BC mixing state from traffic emissions and using these to drive a sophisticated aerosol model.

Methods

The researchers employed a soot-particle aerosol mass spectrometer (SP-AMS) equipped with a light-scattering module. This instrument allows for the direct measurement of refractory black carbon (rBC) and associated organic species at the single-particle level. They also utilized ensemble measurements to capture a broader range of particle sizes and positive matrix factorization (PMF) to identify distinct aerosol sources.

A key aspect of their approach was the particle-resolved aerosol box model, PartMC-MOSAIC. This model simulates the evolution of aerosol populations by tracking individual particles and their interactions. Crucially, the authors used their SP-AMS measurements to initialize this model with realistic mixing state information, comparing simulations that assumed a uniform initial composition versus those constrained by their observed mixing state.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from two urban field campaigns in Toronto, Canada:

  • Roadside study: Focused on fresh vehicle emissions near a busy road.
  • Non-roadside study: Focused on aged aerosols away from major roadways.

The primary dataset consists of single-particle and ensemble mass spectrometry measurements of aerosol composition and mixing state.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Traffic emissions create distinct particle types: BC isn't just sprinkled into every particle; traffic emissions result in two main types of particles: those rich in hydrocarbon-like organic aerosol (HOA-rich) and those rich in black carbon (rBC-rich).
  • BC mass is concentrated: Approximately 90% of the total black carbon mass resides in the "rBC-rich" particle fraction, with HOA-rich particles containing very little BC.
  • Initial mixing state matters significantly for optical properties: The way BC is mixed within particles at the moment of emission has a substantial impact on how those particles interact with light, even after a day of atmospheric processing.
  • Uniform mixing is a poor assumption: Assuming BC is uniformly distributed within all particles leads to significant overestimations of absorption and changes in scattering, impacting climate forcing calculations.

Key Results

  • HOA-rich particles: Average BC mass fraction of 0.02–0.08.
  • rBC-rich particles: Average BC mass fraction of 0.72–0.93.
  • Model simulations: Accurately representing the initial mixing state of BC emissions in the PartMC-MOSAIC model resulted in an increase of approximately 0.1 in the single scattering albedo (SSA) compared to simulations assuming uniform initial mixing. This difference persisted throughout the simulated 24-hour ageing period.
  • No significant differences were observed in calculated cloud condensation nuclei activity, likely due to similar hygroscopicity of rBC and HOA.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Mie calculations: The authors acknowledge that Mie calculations, commonly used for optical property estimations, may not be fully appropriate for non-spherical, coated BC particles found in the real atmosphere.
  • Future work: The study suggests that this approach for quantifying BC mixing state from traffic can be extended to other emission sources. Furthermore, these measurements are crucial for driving more accurate model assessments of black carbon's broader climate impacts.

Summary updated

Abstract

The climatic impacts of black carbon (BC) aerosol, an important absorber of solar radiation in the atmosphere, remain poorly constrained and are intimately related to its particle-scale physical and chemical properties. Using particle-resolved modelling informed by quantitative measurements from a soot-particle aerosol mass spectrometer, we confirm that the mixing state (the distribution of co-emitted aerosol amongst fresh BC-containing particles) at the time of emission significantly affects BC-aerosol optical properties even after a day of atmospheric processing. Both single particle and ensemble aerosol mass spectrometry observations indicate that BC near the point of emission co-exists with hydrocarbon-like organic aerosol in two distinct particle types: HOA-rich and BC-rich particles. The average mass fraction of black carbon in HOA-rich and BC-rich particles was 0.02–0.08 and 0.72–0.93, respectively. Notably, approximately 90 % of BC mass resides in BC-rich particles. This new measurement capability provides quantitative insight into the physical and chemical nature of BC-containing particles and is used to drive a particle-resolved aerosol box model. Significant differences in calculated single scattering albedo (an increase of 0.1) arise from accurate treatment of initial particle mixing state as compared to the assumption of uniform aerosol composition at the point of BC injection into the atmosphere.
BibTeX
@misc{willis2015quantification,
  author = {Megan D. Willis and Robert M. Healy and Nicole Riemer and Matthew West and Jonathan M. Wang and Cheol–Heon Jeong and John Wenger and Greg J. Evans and Jonathan P. D. Abbatt and A. K. Y. Lee},
  title = {{Quantification of black carbon mixing state from traffic: implications for aerosol optical properties}},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.5194/acpd-15-33555-2015},
}
Figure