TL;DR
This study explores how hosting mega-events like the F1 Grand Prix and Winter Olympics impacts residents' quality of life, moving beyond purely economic metrics. It reveals that subjective experiences, social exchange, and individual perspectives are crucial in shaping how residents perceive these events, highlighting the need for socio-cultural policies in long-term event planning.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
While mega-events are often justified by their economic benefits, this paper argues that these benefits are not always directly felt by local residents, leading to indifference or even negative sentiment. The authors identify a gap in research that solely focuses on economic impacts, proposing that a deeper understanding of residents' quality of life is essential for evaluating the true success of mega-events. They aim to explore the diverse phenomena surrounding mega-events and their relationship to residents' subjective well-being, particularly from an "insider's perspective" (emic approach), which is often overlooked in traditional, quantitative studies.
Methods
The study employs a qualitative research methodology, specifically participant observation and in-depth interviews, to gain an "insider's perspective" on residents' quality of life. This approach is chosen over surveys, which can be disruptive or impossible in mega-event contexts. The researchers adopted Spradley's qualitative research method, focusing on four key aspects: the mega-event venue, time, performance, and performers. The analysis involved:
- Domain Analysis: Identifying and categorizing various phenomena related to the mega-event and residents' lives.
- Taxonomic Analysis: Structuring the extracted domains to understand the quality of life indicators.
- Componential Analysis: Systematically identifying indicators and attributes within the domains to understand the relationships and differences in perceptions.
- Contrasting Questions: Used to highlight differences in perception based on resident types and event effects.
Datasets
The study utilized data collected from residents in two distinct mega-event host locations:
- F1 Korean Grand Prix (2010-2012): Data was collected from residents in Mokpo, Korea, over four years (2010-2013) through observation and interviews.
- 2018 Pyeongchang Winter Olympics: Data was collected from residents in Pyeongchang and Gangneung, Korea, in 2018 and 2021.
No new benchmarks were introduced; the focus was on qualitative data collection from existing event contexts.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Beyond Economics: The study strongly emphasizes that residents' quality of life is not solely determined by economic benefits. Subjective experiences, social interactions, and emotional well-being play a significant role.
- Diverse Perceptions: Residents' perceptions of mega-events vary significantly based on their direct economic engagement. Those with direct economic ties (e.g., business owners) often prioritize financial gains, while others focus on broader community benefits and personal experiences.
- Social Exchange is Key: The concept of social exchange, both individual/private and collective/social, is central to understanding how residents perceive the impact of mega-events on their quality of life.
- Community Spirit Matters: A strong sense of community, including pride, belonging, and local attachment, positively influences residents' quality of life and their overall perception of mega-events.
- Long-Term vs. Short-Term: The paper advocates for a shift towards socio-cultural policies that foster long-term community development, rather than solely focusing on short-term economic gains from mega-events.
Key Results
The study identified seven key indicators of residents' quality of life related to mega-event hosting:
- Socioeconomic effects: Including local promotion, community development, and regional economic vitalization.
- Local community educational effect: Improvements in service attitudes, tourism perception, and globalization of life.
- Infrastructure improvement effect: Enhancements in transportation and accommodation facilities.
- Personal leisure and cultural experience: Opportunities for enjoyment and new experiences.
- Mental benefit to life: Positive emotional expressions, sense of accomplishment, and pride.
- Community spirit: Enhanced local pride, sense of belonging, and collective identity.
- Direct economic exchange: Financial transactions and revenue increases for those directly involved.
The research found that residents with direct economic exchange experience tended to have a more positive perception, especially regarding economic benefits. However, even ordinary citizens reported positive impacts through leisure, cultural experiences, and a strengthened sense of community. Conversely, negative impacts like inconvenience, price inflation, and social disruption were also noted.
Limitations and Future Work
- Geographical Context: The study's geographical scope was limited to the southwestern and eastern regions of Korea. The authors suggest replicating the study in other regions and with a broader range of stakeholders to compare findings.
- Qualitative vs. Quantitative: While the qualitative approach provided rich insights, the authors suggest that future studies could incorporate survey data for quantitative analysis to enrich the findings.
- Longitudinal Study: A prospective study could conduct a longitudinal analysis to observe the changes and influences of mega-event impacts on residents over time.
- Broader Stakeholder Engagement: The study focused on residents; future research could explore the perspectives of other stakeholders involved in mega-events.
Summary updated