Quality improvement activity for improving pain management in acute extremity injuries in the emergency department

Hyung Lan Chang, Jin Hee Jung, Young Ho Kwak, Do Kyun Kim, Jin Hee Lee, Jae Yun Jung, Hyuksool Kwon, So Hyun Paek, Joong Wan Park, Jonghwan ShinClinical 2018 · DOI

Abstract

ED-based quality improvement activities including education and change of pain score documentation can improve the rate of analgesic prescription and time to prescription for patients with extremity injury in the ED.

Introduction

Despite pain being the primary reason for Emergency Department (ED) visits, "oligoanalgesia"—the under-treatment of pain—remains a persistent global issue. In South Korea, pain assessment was not a regulatory requirement in many EDs until 2016. Medical staff often underestimated the severity of patient pain or were too overwhelmed by ED congestion to prioritize pain management. Prior to this study, pain scores were rarely recorded (less than 2% of cases), and patients with painful extremity injuries often waited nearly two hours to receive their first dose of pain medication.

Methods

Researchers conducted a retrospective pre-post interventional study at an 800-bed hospital in Seoul, comparing Period I (May–August 2013, pre-intervention) and Period II (May–August 2014, post-intervention). The intervention, conducted between January and April 2014, followed a structured quality improvement (QI) process.

Flowchart of the quality improvement activity implemented in the emergency department.

The three-pronged intervention included:

  1. Perception Survey: Identifying barriers such as ED crowding and lack of awareness among physicians and nurses.
  2. Education: "Grand round" meetings and monthly team meetings to emphasize early pain relief.
  3. EMR Optimization: A "nudge" strategy where the default value for the pain score field in the Electronic Medical Record (EMR) was changed from "no" to "yes," prompting triage nurses to record a numeric rating scale (0–10).

The study analyzed 1,739 adult patients with acute extremity injuries (ICD-10 codes S40–S99), with 867 in Period I and 872 in Period II.

Results

The intervention led to statistically significant improvements across primary metrics:

  • Analgesic Prescription Rate: Increased from 20.3% to 28.8% overall. For moderate-to-severe injuries, the rate rose from 36.4% to 44.5%.
  • Speed of Care: The mean time to the first analgesic prescription dropped from 116.6 minutes to 64.0 minutes—a 45% reduction.
  • Documentation: Pain score recording on nursing charts increased from 1.4% to 51.6%.
  • Predictive Factors: Multivariable analysis identified the post-intervention period as a strong independent predictor of receiving pain medication (Odds Ratio: 1.934).

Discussion

The study highlights the effectiveness of "choice architecture" in clinical software. By simply switching an EMR default setting, documentation rates skyrocketed. Furthermore, the initial survey revealed a discrepancy between staff perception (believing they managed pain adequately) and reality (only 20% of patients receiving analgesics). This underscores the necessity of objective data in QI activities. Simple, low-resource interventions—education and documentation nudges—can yield significant clinical improvements without requiring additional personnel or expensive technology.

Limitations and Future Work

This single-center study relied on retrospective EMR data, which may not capture all patient-provider interactions. Despite improvements, nearly 50% of patients still lacked recorded pain scores, and prescription rates for moderate-to-severe pain remained lower than ideal. Future initiatives could explore "standing orders" for nurses or real-time feedback mechanisms to further bridge the gap in pain management.

Summary updated

Abstract

ED-based quality improvement activities including education and change of pain score documentation can improve the rate of analgesic prescription and time to prescription for patients with extremity injury in the ED.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chang2018quality,
  author = {Hyung Lan Chang and Jin Hee Jung and Young Ho Kwak and Do Kyun Kim and Jin Hee Lee and Jae Yun Jung and Hyuksool Kwon and So Hyun Paek and Joong Wan Park and Jonghwan Shin},
  title = {{Quality improvement activity for improving pain management in acute extremity injuries in the emergency department}},
  booktitle = {Clinical},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.15441/ceem.17.260},
}
Figure