Quality Factor Enhancement of Piezoelectric MEMS Resonator Using a Small Cross-Section Connection Phononic Crystal

Lixia Li, Chuang Zhu, Haixia Liu, Yan Li, Qi Wang, Kun Su2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel phononic crystal structure (SCC-PnC) designed to significantly reduce energy loss in piezoelectric MEMS resonators. By integrating this structure, the researchers achieved dramatic improvements in the quality factor (Q) of the resonators, paving the way for more stable and efficient microelectronic devices.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Micro-Electro-Mechanical Systems (MEMS) resonators are crucial components in modern electronics, particularly in 5G communication systems, for applications like oscillators and filters. A key performance metric for these resonators is their quality factor (Q), which quantifies how efficiently they store energy versus how much they lose. A major bottleneck for achieving high Q in MEMS resonators is "anchor loss," where acoustic energy leaks from the resonator into the substrate through its support structures. This energy dissipation limits the resonator's stability, phase noise, and overall performance. While various methods exist to mitigate anchor loss, such as optimizing anchor points or using acoustic mirrors, there's a continuous need for more effective solutions, especially for ultra-wide bandgap phononic crystals that can offer broader suppression of acoustic waves.

Methods

The researchers employed a finite element method (FEM) using COMSOL Multiphysics to design and analyze their proposed Small Cross-Section Connection Phononic Crystal (SCC-PnC) structure.

  • Phononic Crystal Design: They proposed a specific SCC-PnC unit structure made of monocrystalline silicon, detailing its geometric parameters (lattice constant, height, connecting plate dimensions).
  • Band Gap Analysis: FEM simulations were used to calculate the dispersion curves of the SCC-PnC to identify its acoustic band gap – a frequency range where acoustic wave propagation is prohibited. They also analyzed the effect of structural parameters (height 'h' and position 'h₁' of the connecting plate) on the band gap's width and center frequency.
  • Transmission Characteristics: To validate the acoustic isolation capabilities of the SCC-PnC, they simulated delay lines with and without the phononic crystal structure and compared their transmission spectra (S21).
  • MEMS Resonator Integration: The SCC-PnC structure was then integrated into a piezoelectric MEMS resonator model. FEM simulations were performed to analyze the performance of both traditional and SCC-PnC-enhanced resonators across different overtone modes (third, fifth, and seventh).
  • Performance Metrics: Key performance indicators like resonant frequency (fr), insertion loss (IL), motional resistance (Rm), coupling coefficient (Keff²), simulated anchor loss quality factor (Qanchor), loaded quality factor (Q1), and unloaded quality factor (Qu) were calculated and compared.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on simulated data derived from material properties of silicon and aluminum nitride.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Ultra-Wide Bandgap Achieved: The SCC-PnC structure exhibits a remarkably wide band gap (56.6–269.6 MHz) with a high relative band gap width (BG% = 130.6%), significantly outperforming previously reported phononic crystal designs in a similar frequency range.
  • Structural Sensitivity: The height 'h' of the connecting plate was found to be more sensitive to the band gap width than its position 'h₁', offering a clear design parameter for tuning performance.
  • Effective Anchor Loss Suppression: Integrating the SCC-PnC into piezoelectric MEMS resonators dramatically reduces anchor loss, leading to substantial increases in the anchor quality factor (Qanchor).
  • Minimal Impact on Resonant Frequency: While the SCC-PnC alters the resonator's effective density, the change in resonant frequency is minimal and controllable through structural adjustments.
  • Broad Applicability: The SCC-PnC is shown to be effective across multiple overtone modes (third, fifth, and seventh), indicating its versatility for different resonator designs.

Key Results

The integration of the SCC-PnC structure into piezoelectric MEMS resonators yielded significant improvements:

  • Qanchor Enhancement:
    • Third-order overtone: Increased by 1656 times (from 35,039 to 58,012,627).
  • Fifth-order overtone: Increased by 2027 times (from 61,207 to 124,052,163).
  • Seventh-order overtone: Increased by 16 times (from 28,026 to 462,009).
  • Insertion Loss Reduction:
    • Third-order overtone: Reduced from 10.54 dB to 1.02 dB.
  • Fifth-order overtone: Reduced from 4.18 dB to 1.87 dB.
  • Seventh-order overtone: Reduced from 15.13 dB to 3.28 dB.
  • Motional Resistance Reduction: In the three overtones, motional resistance was reduced from 235.29 Ω, 18.18 Ω, and 156.25 Ω to 3.39 Ω, 4.29 Ω, and 48.31 Ω, respectively.
  • Loaded Quality Factor (Q1) Improvement: For the three overtones, Q1 increased from 25,068, 16,629, and 26,513 to 85,948, 21,079, and 103,585, respectively.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simulation-Based: The study is based on FEM simulations. Experimental validation would be the next crucial step to confirm these promising results in real-world devices.
  • Specific SCC-PnC Design: While the SCC-PnC shows excellent performance, further exploration into optimizing its geometry and material composition for even wider band gaps or specific frequency ranges could be beneficial.
  • Fabrication Challenges: The practical fabrication of such intricate phononic crystal structures at the micro-scale might present challenges that need to be addressed in future work.
  • Broader Overtone Analysis: While three overtones were analyzed, investigating the performance across a wider range of overtones and different resonator modes could provide a more comprehensive understanding.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{li2022quality,
  author = {Lixia Li and Chuang Zhu and Haixia Liu and Yan Li and Qi Wang and Kun Su},
  title = {{Quality Factor Enhancement of Piezoelectric MEMS Resonator Using a Small Cross-Section Connection Phononic Crystal}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/s22207751},
}

Loading related content...

Figure