Abstract
Existing video object tracking (VOT) research often focuses on scene-dependent challenges like occlusion and clutter, frequently overlooking the impact of authentic in-capture and post-capture distortions. This paper introduces the Authentically Distorted Surveillance Videos (AD-SVD) dataset, comprising 4,476 videos featuring various distortions and surveillance activities. We propose a novel approach for performance prediction and quality-aware feature selection using 3D Convolutional Neural Networks (C3D) and Support Vector Regression (SVR). By predicting tracker performance across spatial resolutions, our framework enables a strategic reduction in computational resources—achieving up to a 34% reduction in execution time with only a marginal 3% decrease in tracking accuracy.
Introduction
Video Object Tracking (VOT) is a fundamental component of modern computer vision systems, particularly in the realm of automated surveillance. However, a significant gap exists between benchmark performance and real-world deployment. Most current VOT benchmarks prioritize scene-level challenges such as background clutter or target occlusion. In practice, surveillance footage is often plagued by "authentic distortions"—sensor-level issues like defocus, over-exposure, or low-light graininess that are not adequately represented in standard datasets.
State-of-the-art trackers are computationally expensive. Running these high-end algorithms at full resolution on distorted footage where they are likely to fail—or on clear footage where lower resolutions would suffice—is inefficient. This research addresses this by developing a system that predicts tracker performance before execution, allowing for intelligent resource management.
The AD-SVD Dataset
To bridge the gap in authentic distortion research, we introduced the Authentically Distorted Surveillance Videos (AD-SVD) dataset. This dataset is specifically designed to evaluate how trackers handle real-world sensor limitations rather than just environmental geometry.
Key characteristics of the dataset include:
- Scale and Scope: 4,476 videos recorded across seven distinct indoor and outdoor locations.
- Activity Diversity: Eight surveillance-specific activities, including fighting, robbery, and abandoned packages.
- Distortion Focus: Systematic inclusion of in-capture distortions such as Defocus, Exposure (over and under), and Mixed distortions.
- Benchmarking: We provided baseline results for 11 state-of-the-art trackers from the VOT 2017–2018 challenges, revealing that many top-tier trackers are surprisingly fragile when faced with simple lens blur.
Methodology: Performance Prediction and Optimization
Our framework utilizes a two-stage process to optimize tracking efficiency:
1. Quality-Aware Feature Extraction
Traditional video quality metrics often fail to correlate with the semantic needs of a tracking algorithm. Instead, we employ a 3D Convolutional Neural Network (C3D) to extract spatio-temporal features. These features are uniquely capable of capturing both the visual texture of distortions and the underlying motion dynamics of the scene.
2. SVR-Based Performance Mapping
These C3D features are fed into a Support Vector Regression (SVR) model. The model is trained to predict the expected Area Under Curve (AUC) of a tracker’s success plot. By analyzing the video chunks offline, the system can estimate the performance loss ($pl$) that would occur if the video were processed at a lower spatial resolution.
Results and Resource Reduction
The primary innovation of this study is the ability to balance processing time and accuracy. We discovered a "Goldilocks" zone for many trackers: downscaling to 1/4 resolution typically yields significant speedups with negligible impact on the tracker's ability to maintain its target.
- Efficiency Gains: The system achieved a 34% reduction in execution time with only a 3% decrease in performance across the dataset.
- Extreme Optimization: For specific trackers like TFCR, we observed a 65% reduction in time with a marginal performance loss of only 0.03 AUC.
- Prediction Accuracy: The C3D+SVR model demonstrated high reliability, with Pearson Linear Correlation Coefficient (PLCC) scores exceeding 0.90 in several test scenarios.
Conclusion
By distinguishing between scene-dependent challenges and sensor-dependent distortions, this research provides a more realistic benchmark for surveillance technology. The proposed performance prediction framework allows for a significant reduction in computational and storage requirements, making high-quality automated surveillance more sustainable for large-scale deployments. Future work will focus on adapting these tools for real-time, first-frame prediction and expanding the dataset to include environmental distortions like heavy rain and fog.
Summary updated