Quality Assessment of Regional Primary English Education Based on Big Data: A Case Study of Gansu Province

Jialan Nan, Yu Fu, xinying Xu, Ren Feng, Wenhui LiangResearch Square 2022 · DOI

Abstract

This study addresses the scarcity of quantitative assessments for elementary education in China by leveraging big data from English academic proficiency tests (2018–2020) across 322 senior high schools in Gansu Province. By developing the "English Excellence Degree" (EED) metric and applying spatial-temporal analysis methods, the research identifies significant disparities in educational quality. Findings reveal a staggering 759-fold difference between the highest and lowest performing schools, with excellence concentrated in the provincial capital, Lanzhou, and "cold spots" prevalent in minority and impoverished regions. These results underscore the utility of big data in guiding regional education policy and resource allocation.

Introduction

In the era of digital transformation, big data has become a pivotal tool for industries and governments. However, its application in assessing elementary education levels—particularly in developing regions—remains limited. Gansu Province, located in northwest China, represents an economically challenged area where English education quality varies significantly. Traditionally, educational assessments have relied on subjective generalizations. This study shifts the paradigm by using large-scale test data to scientifically map educational inequality and provide a foundation for balanced regional development.

Methodology

The researchers analyzed score data from 322 senior high schools over a three-year period. Central to the study is the English Excellence Degree (EED), a composite indicator calculated as:

$$EED = M_j \times E_j$$

where $M_j$ is the school's average English score and $E_j$ is its passing rate. This metric offers a more comprehensive view of performance than raw scores alone.

To analyze the spatial distribution of these scores, the team employed:

  • Anomaly Analysis: To measure deviations from the regional mean.
  • Kernel Density Estimation (KDE): To visualize the concentration of high-performing schools.
  • Getis-Ord $G_i^*$ Statistics: To identify statistically significant "hot spots" (high-performance clusters) and "cold spots" (low-performance clusters).
  • Cluster Analysis: To categorize schools into four distinct performance groups based on similarity.

Results and Spatial Patterns

The analysis uncovered extreme educational stratification within the province:

  • The Excellence Gap: The highest average EED recorded was 759 times greater than the lowest, highlighting a massive divide in educational outcomes.
  • Negative Anomalies: More than 50% of the surveyed schools performed below the regional average, indicating that a majority of institutions struggle to meet baseline quality standards.
  • The "Lanzhou Effect": Spatial analysis confirmed that Lanzhou, the provincial capital, serves as the primary hot spot for English education. Conversely, cold spots are heavily concentrated in the Linxia autonomous region, Longnan, and eastern Qingyang—areas often characterized by higher poverty rates or minority populations.
  • Temporal Trends: While violin plot analysis showed a general upward trend in EED values from 2018 to 2020, the progress was uneven; 136 schools actually saw a decrease in quality during this period.

Discussion: The Teacher Factor

To understand the drivers behind these data points, the researchers conducted questionnaires. The qualitative findings suggest that the "cold spots" are trapped in a cycle of disadvantage. High-quality teachers overwhelmingly prefer urban centers with better living conditions and professional opportunities. This "teacher flight" leaves rural and minority-area schools with fewer resources, further depressing student performance and widening the regional gap.

Conclusion

This case study demonstrates that big data is an essential tool for the quantitative assessment of basic education. By pinpointing specific geographic areas and schools that are falling behind, policymakers can move beyond anecdotal evidence to implement targeted interventions. Future research will expand this framework to include micro-level factors, such as individual student study behaviors and the specific impact of teacher rotation policies, to further refine strategies for educational equity.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Introduction: Recently, big data attract great attention from industries, academia, and governments. Education big data from teaching and learning processes used to assess elementary education level is scarce in China. Case description: Gansu province, located in the northwest China, is one of the most backward economy areas where the development of elementary English education falls far behind developed areas of the country. Taking Gansu province as a case study and English subject in senior high schools as the study object, we use score data of English academic proficiency test (2018-2020) from 322 senior high schools to explore spatial-temporal differences of English education level among those schools in order to promote the balanced development of regional education. First we briefly describe the generation of English big data from senior high schools, and then, we mine the big data to analyze the difference of the English education level using the anomaly method, the comparison method, the cluster analysis method, and hot point analysis method. English excellence degree is developed as an indicator to assess elementary English education level. Discussion and Evalution: The results show that: (1) there exists obvious difference in English education level among the selected senior high schools: the highest average value of English excellence degree is 759 times the lowest, and the number of schools with negative anomalies accounts for more than 50%; (2) English excellence degree displays an obvious agglomeration characteristic in Lanzhou city, the provincial capital, that is, the hot spots (high English level) of English excellence degree are located in Lanzhou, while the cold spots (low English level) are concentrated in minority and poor areas such as Linxia autonomous region, the major part of Longnan and the eastern part of Qingyang; (3) The investigation in the form of questionnaires confirms the fact that disadvantage schools in English level are usually lack of good teachers who have a preference to teach in areas with good conditions. Conclusion: From the results, we can draw the conclusion that big data play an important role in quantitatively assessing basic education level, which lays foundation for improving the regional education level. Individuals’ value orientation of study, attitude towards study and the study behavior will be investigated in the future.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{nan2022quality,
  author = {Jialan Nan and Yu Fu and xinying Xu and Ren Feng and Wenhui Liang},
  title = {{Quality Assessment of Regional Primary English Education Based on Big Data: A Case Study of Gansu Province}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-1114036/v1},
}
Figure