Qualitative Dynamics and Pattern Formation of COVID-19 in the Modified SIR Model

Qianqian Zheng, Vikas Pandey, Jianwei Shen, Yong Xu, Linan GuanResearch 2021 · DOI

Abstract

The SIR (susceptible-infective-recovery) model is a fundamental tool for understanding infectious disease evolution. However, the spread of COVID-19 is heavily influenced by the diffusion of infected individuals across social networks, a factor often overlooked in standard models. This paper presents a modified SIR model tailored to COVID-19 characteristics and integrates it into a random diffusion network. Through stability and bifurcation analysis, we identify critical thresholds for pandemic control. Our findings reveal that network stability is determined by the maximum eigenvalue of the network matrix, which is proportional to the connection and infection rates. We propose a novel "reduced system method" for investigating complex network-organized systems and provide evidence-based strategies to mitigate viral spread.

Introduction

Traditional epidemiological models often rely on the assumption of "homogeneous mixing," where every individual has an equal probability of contact. In reality, human society is organized into complex spatial networks. COVID-19 presents unique challenges, including infectiousness during incubation and varying mortality rates across different population compartments. This study addresses these gaps by combining local biological dynamics with global network topology to understand the mechanisms triggering large-scale outbreaks, specifically through the lens of Turing instability.

Methodology

The researchers developed a modified SIR model incorporating distinct death rates ($\beta_1, \beta_2, \beta_3$) and dual infection rates: $\gamma_1$ for symptomatic individuals and $\gamma_2$ for those in the incubation phase. This model was then mapped onto a random network of $N$ nodes, where connections are defined by a probability $p$.

To analyze the system's stability, the authors employed Jacobian matrices and eigenvalue analysis. A key innovation is the "Reduced System Method," which simplifies the $N$-node network into a single approximate system. By applying the Gershgorin circle theorem, they estimated the network's influence via its maximum eigenvalue ($\Lambda_{max}$).

Stability and bifurcation analysis of the modified SIR model, showing transitions between disease-free and endemic states.

Key Insights and Results

The analysis identifies two primary equilibria: the disease-free state ($E_1$) and the endemic state ($E_2$). The transition between these states is governed by critical parameters such as the birth rate ($\alpha$) and the incubation infection rate ($\gamma_2$).

  1. The $\Lambda_{max}$ Threshold: The stability of the networked population is fundamentally tied to the maximum eigenvalue of the network matrix. The authors approximate this as $\Lambda_{max} \approx Npq$. When this value exceeds a specific threshold, the system undergoes a bifurcation, leading to the formation of "Turing patterns" or sustained outbreaks.
  2. The Impact of Incubation: The infection rate during the incubation period ($\gamma_2$) is a primary driver of instability. This mathematical result underscores the critical importance of testing and isolating asymptomatic carriers.
  3. Endemic Dynamics: When the stability conditions for the disease-free state are violated, the system settles into an endemic equilibrium where the virus persists in the population.
Time series of the S, I, and R populations settling into a stable endemic equilibrium ($E_2$).

Conclusion and Policy Implications

Based on the mathematical analysis, the most effective strategies for pandemic control are:

  • Aggressive Isolation: Reducing $\gamma_2$ through widespread testing and early quarantine.
  • Social Distancing: Lowering the connection probability $p$ directly reduces the network's maximum eigenvalue, pushing the system toward the stable disease-free state.
  • Healthcare Support: Increasing the recovery rate ($\delta$) to move individuals out of the infectious compartment more rapidly.

While the use of random networks provides a strong theoretical foundation, real-world social structures are often more complex (e.g., scale-free networks). Future research will focus on applying this framework to diverse network topologies and integrating real-time data to enhance predictive accuracy for future variants or different infectious diseases.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract SIR (susceptible-infective-recovery) model is a widely investigated model to explain the time evolution of infectious diseases. Outbreak of infectious diseases is affected by diffusion of infected, which is true especially in COVID-19 outbreak. Therefore, it is imperative to construct a diffusion network in the model for spatial consideration; However, the inclusion of a diffusion network is seldom considered for the studies. In this work, we first modified the SIR model for COVID-19 and then performed its stability and bifurcation analysis in qualitative research. Based on our analysis, we propose some of the advice to mitigate the spread of COVID-19. Then, a random diffusion network is constructed, which shows its vital role in the Turing instability and bifurcation. We noticed that the stability of network-organized SIR could be determined by the maximum of eigenvalues of the network matrix. The maximum of eigenvalues of the network matrix is proportional to network connection rate and infection rate of the network. Therefore, these two rates play a critical role in Turing instability. We perform the numerical simulations to verify the analytical results. We try to explain the spread mechanism of infectious diseases and provide some feasible strategies based on our analysis of these two models. Also, the reduced system method for a network-organized system is proposed, which is a novel approach to investigate the complex system.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zheng2021qualitative,
  author = {Qianqian Zheng and Vikas Pandey and Jianwei Shen and Yong Xu and Linan Guan},
  title = {{Qualitative Dynamics and Pattern Formation of\ COVID-19 in the Modified SIR Model}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-184648/v1},
}
Figure