Abstract
Selecting the best policy to keep the balance between what a company holds in cash and what is placed in alternative investments is by no means straightforward. We here introduce PyCaMa, a Python module for multiobjective cash management based on linear programming that allows to derive optimal policies for cash management with multiple bank accounts in terms of both cost and risk of policies.
Introduction
For any medium-to-large company, managing cash is a constant balancing act. Holding too much cash in a standard checking account is inefficient because that money could be earning interest elsewhere. However, moving money between accounts or into investments incurs transaction fees and administrative costs.
This problem becomes exponentially more complex when a company operates across multiple banks and accounts. Most existing theoretical models are either too simplified or too academic to be useful for a practitioner. PyCaMa addresses this gap by providing an accessible software tool that handles multi-account systems while simultaneously optimizing for both cost (fees and lost interest) and risk (the likelihood of costs exceeding a certain threshold).
Methods: A Networked Approach
PyCaMa treats a company's bank accounts as a networked system, where nodes represent accounts and edges represent the flow of funds.
The core of the tool is a Linear Programming (LP) solver that utilizes several key components:
- Incidence Matrix: An $n \times m$ matrix mathematically represents allowed transactions between accounts, reflecting real-world banking restrictions.
- Multi-objective Optimization: Users can weigh "Cost" against "Risk" using a weighted sum approach.
- Conditional Cost-at-Risk (CCaR): This primary risk metric focuses on "tail risk"—the expected cost in worst-case scenarios where costs exceed a specific reference point.
- Integration: The module is built to work with the Gurobi optimizer, a state-of-the-art mathematical programming solver.
Illustrative Case Study
To demonstrate PyCaMa's capabilities, the authors provide a synthetic example involving a three-account system (two current accounts and one investment account). The setup includes a 5-day planning horizon with specific cash flow forecasts, fixed and variable transaction costs, and daily holding costs of 0.01%. The objective is to maintain a minimum balance of €2 million in the current accounts while minimizing total costs and risk.
Key Results
The illustrative example demonstrates that PyCaMa successfully generates a 5-day policy that satisfies all constraints while optimizing transfers. The system automatically identifies when it is more cost-effective to pay a transaction fee to move money into a high-yield account versus leaving it idle.
As shown in the figure above, the tool outputs optimal balances, providing a clear visual strategy for how cash should be distributed across the accounts over the planning horizon to minimize the objective function.
Key Insights
- Distribution Agnostic: Unlike classic models like Miller-Orr, PyCaMa makes no assumptions about cash flow probability distributions; it works directly with provided forecasts.
- Coherent Risk: CCaR is a "coherent" risk measure, making it more mathematically robust for optimization than simpler measures like variance.
- Decision Support: PyCaMa moves cash management from manual, intuition-based tasks to an automated, data-driven Decision Support System (DSS).
Limitations and Future Work
While powerful, PyCaMa's optimality is dependent on the accuracy of cash flow forecasts ("garbage in, garbage out"). Future research will focus on the impact of forecasting accuracy and incorporating "Robust Optimization" techniques to handle financial uncertainty. Additionally, while the module is flexible, it currently relies on the commercial Gurobi solver, and future versions may explore more diverse risk metrics to cater to different corporate appetites.
Summary updated