Putting Natural Time into Science

Roger White, Wolfgang BanzhafarXiv 2019 · arXiv · OpenReview

Abstract: This contribution argues that the notion of time used in the scientific modeling of reality deprives time of its real nature. Difficulties from logic paradoxes to mathematical incompleteness and numerical uncertainty ensue. How can the emergence of novelty in the Universe be explained? How can the creativity of the evolutionary process leading to ever more complex forms of life be captured in our models of reality? These questions are deeply related to our understanding of time. We argue here for a computational framework of modeling that seems to us the only currently known type of modeling available in Science able to capture aspects of the nature of time required to better model and understand real phenomena.

Introduction: The Crisis of Timeless Science

For centuries, Western science has pursued certainty through mathematical formalization. However, this pursuit has encountered significant barriers: logical paradoxes (such as Russell’s Paradox), mathematical incompleteness (Gödel), and the inherent unpredictability of deterministic chaos. Authors Roger White and Wolfgang Banzhaf argue that these issues are not mere technical hurdles but symptoms of a fundamental flaw in how we model reality: we have stripped time of its natural essence.

In traditional physics and mathematics, time is treated as a coordinate ($t$) that can be traversed forward or backward—a concept the authors call "spatialized time." This allows science to "double-click" (a term borrowed from Bruno Latour) straight to a conclusion, skipping the actual process of becoming. Because these equations are essentially timeless, they are unable to represent the "strong emergence" seen in biology and complex systems, where entirely new structures and rules are generated that did not exist previously.

Resolving Paradoxes through Process

The paper proposes a shift from static logic to algorithmic execution. Consider a logical paradox such as "This statement is false." In a timeless mathematical framework, this is a contradiction that halts progress. However, if treated as an algorithm executed in "natural time," the paradox becomes a simple oscillation (True → False → True). By reintroducing the flow of time, logical "dead ends" are resolved into dynamic, temporal behaviors.

This perspective extends to mathematical incompleteness. The authors suggest that mathematical intuition is a creative process occurring in time. Under this view, the "unprovable" statements identified by Gödel are not failures of logic, but rather "yet-to-be-constructed" truths that require the passage of time and the creative act of discovery to be realized.

Computation as the Medium of Reality

The core of the authors' argument is that computation is the only framework currently available to science that can capture the nature of time required to model complex phenomena. Unlike an analytical equation, an algorithm running on a computer operates in "natural time." It must step through its process; its "execution time" is a fundamental property that cannot be bypassed.

Key features of this computational framework include:

  • Reflective Programming: The authors point to "reflective" computer languages (like SELF) that can modify their own structure during execution. This mirrors how living systems use internal models to guide their own evolution and survival.
  • Time-Stamping: They propose that every object in the universe—and every mathematical object—should carry a "time-stamp" of when it first appeared. Transformations should only be able to utilize what already exists at their specific "time of creation."
  • Open-Endedness: Traditional algorithms are often designed to "halt" to provide an answer. However, to model reality, we need processes that do not terminate—much like biological evolution, the climate, or the economy.

Defining Life and Strong Emergence

Within this framework, the authors distinguish between "weak emergence" (predictable patterns like a storm forming from molecules) and "strong emergence" (the development of a cell or a city). Strong emergence requires an internal "model" that guides the system’s behavior. They define life itself as entities containing these "first-order models," acting as algorithms that allow the system to navigate the "adjacent possible"—the states the system can reach next based on its current history.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While the authors acknowledge challenges—such as the precise measurement of natural time and the limitations of discrete, quantized computer clocks—their work provides a conceptual roadmap for a new kind of science. They conclude that computation is not just a tool for simulating science; it is the only medium that can embody the natural time necessary to understand the creativity and complexity of the universe. To truly capture the emergence of novelty, science must move beyond timeless equations and embrace the irreversible flow of the computational process.

Summary updated

Abstract

This contribution argues that the notion of time used in the scientific modeling of reality deprives time of its real nature. Difficulties from logic paradoxes to mathematical incompleteness and numerical uncertainty ensue. How can the emergence of novelty in the Universe be explained? How can the creativity of the evolutionary process leading to ever more complex forms of life be captured in our models of reality? These questions are deeply related to our understanding of time. We argue here for a computational framework of modeling that seems to us the only currently known type of modeling available in Science able to capture aspects of the nature of time required to better model and understand real phenomena.
BibTeX
@misc{white2019putting,
  author = {Roger White and Wolfgang Banzhaf},
  title = {{Putting Natural Time into Science}},
  year = {2019},
  eprint = {1901.07357},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1901.07357},
}
Figure