Purkinje Cell Activity in Medial and Lateral Cerebellum During Suppression of Voluntary Eye Movements in Rhesus Macaques

Eric Avila, Nico A. Flierman, Peter Holland, Pieter R. Roelfsema, Maarten A. Frens, Aleksandra Badura, Chris I. De ZeeuwbioRxiv 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that the cerebellum, specifically its medial and lateral regions, plays a crucial role in volitional eye movement control, including the suppression of unwanted movements. The lateral cerebellum, in particular, appears to encode crucial information about the task's identity before the eye movement even begins, suggesting a more sophisticated role in planning and decision-making than previously appreciated.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Voluntary suppression of responses to external stimuli, a key aspect of executive control, is often attributed primarily to the cerebral cortex. However, recent evidence suggests the cerebellum also contributes to this complex behavior. A key question is whether different parts of the cerebellar cortex have distinct or complementary roles in planning and executing these volitional movements, especially when inhibition is required. This paper investigates this by examining Purkinje cell (PC) activity in the medial and lateral cerebellum during a task that requires animals to either make a rapid eye movement towards a target (prosaccade) or away from it (antisaccade), the latter demanding volitional inhibition.

Methods

The researchers used electrophysiological recordings to measure the activity of Purkinje cells (PCs) in two rhesus macaques performing a pro- and antisaccade task. They recorded from PCs in both the medial (oculomotor vermis) and lateral (crus I/II) cerebellum.

Key techniques and analyses included:

  • Single-unit recordings: Capturing the electrical activity of individual neurons.
  • Pro- and Antisaccade Task: A well-established behavioral paradigm to study volitional control and response inhibition.
  • Simple Spike (SS) and Complex Spike (CS) analysis: Differentiating between the two main types of PC output to understand their roles.
  • Statistical analysis: Comparing firing rates, identifying saccade-related activity, and assessing modulation during different task epochs (instruction and execution).
  • Demixed Principal Component Analysis (dPCA): A dimensionality reduction technique used to identify population-level activity patterns related to stimulus identity (pro- vs. antisaccade). This allowed them to determine if neural activity could predict the upcoming trial type.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from two adult male rhesus macaques (Mi and Mo). No new datasets were introduced; the study relies on in vivo electrophysiological recordings from these animals during the described behavioral task.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Cerebellum is actively involved in volitional inhibition: The study provides strong evidence that the cerebellum isn't just about motor execution but also plays a role in suppressing unwanted movements, as required in the antisaccade task.
  • Lateral cerebellum encodes task identity before movement: A major finding is that the lateral cerebellum's PC activity contains information that can distinguish between pro- and antisaccade trials during the instruction period, before the eye movement even begins. This suggests a role in planning and decision-making, not just motor output.
  • Medial vs. Lateral Cerebellum: Different roles: While both regions show modulation, the lateral cerebellum appears to be more involved in discriminating trial types and potentially in the planning phase, whereas the medial cerebellum might be more focused on the execution phase.
  • Facilitation vs. Suppression Cells: PCs were categorized based on whether their activity increased (facilitation) or decreased (suppression) during specific task periods. These cell types showed differential roles, with facilitation cells being more prominent during instruction and suppression cells during execution.
  • Reciprocal Interaction: The lateral cerebellum showed a stronger reciprocal interaction between simple and complex spike activity, hinting at more complex processing within this region.

Key Results

  • Widespread PC modulation: PCs in both medial and lateral cerebellum showed significant modulation of their simple spike (SS) activity during both the instruction and execution periods of pro- and antisaccade trials.
  • Lateral cerebellum's predictive power: dPCA analysis revealed that PCs in the lateral cerebellum could reliably distinguish between pro- and antisaccade trials during the instruction period. This was not observed in the medial cerebellum.
  • Saccade execution differences: SS activity during saccade execution was significantly higher in the lateral cerebellum compared to the medial cerebellum for both pro- and antisaccade trials.
  • Facilitation/Suppression timing: Suppression PCs in the lateral cerebellum showed longer latencies for their trough activity after saccade onset compared to the medial cerebellum. Facilitation PCs showed similar peak timing across regions.
  • Modulation ratios: PCs in the lateral cerebellum showed a relatively stronger modulation for both instruction and saccade periods, and also for pro- vs. antisaccade conditions, compared to the medial cerebellum.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited error trial analysis: Due to the high performance of the animals, the study focused on correct trials, limiting the analysis of incorrect antisaccade trials. The authors suggest that future work could explore error-triggered CS responses in more detail.
  • Generalizability: While using non-human primates provides valuable insights, direct translation to human cognitive processes requires further investigation.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that the cerebellum's role in decision-making and its interaction with frontal cortical areas during tasks requiring volitional control warrants further exploration. The findings also open avenues for investigating how cerebellar modules contribute to complex behaviors with different propensities.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Volitional suppression of responses to distracting external stimuli enables us to achieve our goals. This volitional inhibition of a specific behavior is supposed to be mainly mediated by the cerebral cortex. However, recent evidence supports the involvement of the cerebellum in this process. It is currently not known whether different parts of the cerebellar cortex play differential or synergistic roles in planning and execution of this behavior. Here, we measured Purkinje cell (PC) responses in the medial and lateral cerebellum in two rhesus macaques during a pro- and antisaccade task. During an antisaccade trial, non-human primates were instructed to make a saccadic eye movement away from a target, rather than towards it, as in prosaccade trials. Our data shows that the cerebellum plays an important role not only during execution of the saccades, but also during the volitional inhibition of eye movements towards the target. Simple Spike (SS) modulation during the instruction and execution period of pro- and antisaccades was prominent in PCs of both medial and lateral cerebellum. However, only the SS activity in the lateral cerebellar cortex contained information about trial identity and showed a stronger reciprocal interaction with complex spikes. Moreover, SS activity of different PC groups modulated bidirectionally in both regions, but the PCs that showed facilitating and suppressive activity were predominantly associated with instruction and execution, respectively. These findings show that different cerebellar regions and PC groups contribute to goal-directed behavior and volitional inhibition, but with different propensities, highlighting the rich repertoire of cerebellar control in executive functions. Significance Statement The antisaccade task is commonly used in research and clinical evaluation as a test of volitional and flexible control of behavior. It requires volitional suppression of prosaccades, a function that has been attributed to the neocortex. However, recent findings indicate that cerebellum also contributes to this behavior. We recorded from neurons in the medial and lateral cerebellum to evaluate their responses in this task. We found that both regions significantly modulated their activity during this task, but only cells in the lateral cerebellum encoded the stimulus identity in each trial. These results indicate that the cerebellum actively contributes to the control of flexible behavior and that lateral and medial cerebellum play different roles during volitional eye movements.
BibTeX
@misc{avila2021purkinje,
  author = {Eric Avila and Nico A. Flierman and Peter Holland and Pieter R. Roelfsema and Maarten A. Frens and Aleksandra Badura and Chris I. De Zeeuw},
  title = {{Purkinje Cell Activity in Medial and Lateral Cerebellum During Suppression of Voluntary Eye Movements in Rhesus Macaques}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.03.26.437236},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure