Pumping-induced reactivation of a pre-existing normal fault: insights from a centrifuge model test

Jiawei Wan, Bin Li, Yang Gao, Chengxuan Tan, Łi ZhuangFrontiers in Earth Science 2023 · DOI

Abstract

Pumping-induced normal fault reactivation and the resultant ground fracture have been observed in faulted basins worldwide, but the process and mechanism are poorly understood thus far. In this study, we conducted centrifuge model tests to investigate and analyze these issues. Two simplified faulted models, Models 1 and 2, were developed based on an actual event that occurred in the Beijing Plain, China. Our model tests reproduced the pumping-induced normal fault reactivation, characterized by localized hanging wall subsidence with new fault scarp formation in the models. The monitoring results showed that water table decline drastically accelerated uneven subsidence. Although the deformation pattern did not respond to variations in the material properties of the hanging wall and footwall, the magnitude of the reactivated normal faulting was influenced. The maximum vertical offset in Model 2 was much larger than that in Model 1 due to a larger compression modulus in the hanging wall and footwall in Model 2. Furthermore, the reactivation mechanism was revealed based on Anderson’s faulting theory. Groundwater pumping increases the effective stress, leading to the addition of vertical stress and the resultant normal fault reactivation. Our findings provide a better understanding of human interactions with the Earth’s surface and are helpful for mitigating faulting-caused disasters.

Introduction: The Geohazard of Reactivated Faults

In many faulted basins globally—such as the Beijing Plain in China or the Querétaro basin in Mexico—groundwater overexploitation has led to dramatic land subsidence and the appearance of "earth fissures." These fissures often appear along the tracks of pre-existing, dormant faults. While the correlation between pumping and fault reactivation is known, the specific mechanical process and the influence of different soil types (e.g., clay vs. sand) remained poorly understood. This research, published in Frontiers in Earth Science, seeks to bridge that gap by providing a controlled, physical simulation of fault reactivation to help engineers better predict and mitigate infrastructure damage.

Field evidence of earth fissures in the Beijing Plain, China, showing significant vertical offsets and damage to infrastructure.

Methodology: Geotechnical Centrifuge Modeling

The authors employed Geotechnical Centrifuge Modeling, a technique that uses centrifugal force to simulate high gravitational loads. This allows a small-scale model to experience the same stress levels as a massive, real-world geological structure.

  • The Apparatus: A large beam centrifuge (3.5m radius) capable of reaching 100g.
  • The Models: Two simplified 1/100 scale models were built based on the Beijing Plain.
  • Model 1: Represented a faulted aquitard (primarily clay).
  • Model 2: Represented a faulted aquifer (primarily sand).
  • The Fault: Both models featured a pre-existing normal fault with a 70° dip angle, filled with a clay-sand mixture.
  • The Simulation: After spinning the models to 100g to simulate field-scale gravity, the researchers opened a solenoid valve to drain water from the bottom of the model, simulating a declining water table.

Key Insights and Results

The "Effective Stress" Trigger

The primary driver of reactivation is Terzaghi’s effective stress principle. As water is pumped out, pore water pressure drops. This "unweights" the water's buoyancy, causing the effective vertical stress on the soil grains to increase. The study confirms that pumping shifts the stress state of the ground toward the conditions required for normal faulting (where vertical stress is the maximum principal stress), as described by Anderson’s faulting theory.

Pattern vs. Magnitude

A crucial finding was that the pattern of deformation (localized hanging wall subsidence) is controlled by the fault geometry, but the magnitude of the break is controlled by the soil's stiffness.

  • Successful Replication: Both models successfully reproduced pumping-induced fault reactivation and the formation of new surface scarps.
  • Material Influence: Model 2 (sand-heavy) showed much larger vertical offsets than Model 1 (clay-heavy). Specifically, the maximum vertical offset in Model 2 reached 30 mm, compared to 18.67 mm in Model 1.
  • Stiffness Matters: The larger displacement in Model 2 was attributed to the higher compression modulus of sand. Because the sand was stiffer, it didn't "squish" as uniformly as the clay, leading to more dramatic differential movement at the fault line.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The study demonstrates that while some minor movement occurred due to gravity alone, the decline of the water table drastically accelerated the rate of uneven subsidence. These findings provide a better understanding of human interactions with the Earth’s surface and are helpful for mitigating faulting-caused disasters.

Future work should address limitations such as initial compaction issues in small-scale models and the simplified 2D geometry used. The researchers suggest investigating the impact of aquifer recharge to see if fault reactivation can be halted or partially reversed, and exploring more complex multi-layered soil stratigraphy.

Summary updated

Abstract

Pumping-induced normal fault reactivation and the resultant ground fracture have been observed in faulted basins worldwide, but the process and mechanism are poorly understood thus far. In this study, we conducted centrifuge model tests to investigate and analyze these issues. Two simplified faulted models, Models 1 and 2, were developed based on an actual event that occurred in the Beijing Plain, China. Our model tests reproduced the pumping-induced normal fault reactivation, characterized by localized hanging wall subsidence with new fault scarp formation in the models. The monitoring results showed that water table decline drastically accelerated uneven subsidence. Although the deformation pattern did not respond to variations in the material properties of the hanging wall and footwall, the magnitude of the reactivated normal faulting was influenced. The maximum vertical offset in Model 2 was much larger than that in Model 1 due to a larger compression modulus in the hanging wall and footwall in Model 2. Furthermore, the reactivation mechanism was revealed based on Anderson’s faulting theory. Normal faulting occurs once the maximum principal stress becomes vertical and the intermediate and minimum principal stresses become horizontal. Groundwater pumping increases the effective stress, leading to the addition of vertical stress and the resultant normal fault reactivation. Our findings provide a better understanding of human interactions with the Earth’s surface and are helpful for mitigating faulting-caused disasters.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wan2023pumping,
  author = {Jiawei Wan and Bin Li and Yang Gao and Chengxuan Tan and Łi Zhuang},
  title = {{Pumping-induced reactivation of a pre-existing normal fault: insights from a centrifuge model test}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Earth Science},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/feart.2023.1289568},
}
Figure