Pumped Storage Hydropower in Abandoned Mine Shafts: Key Concerns and Research Directions

Xin Lyu, Tong Zhang, Yuan Liang, Ke Yang, Juejing Fang, Shanshan Li, Shuai LiuSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores the potential of using abandoned mine shafts for Pumped Storage Hydropower (PSH) as a critical component of China's carbon neutrality goals. It identifies key challenges and proposes research directions for developing intelligent, stable, and green PSH systems within these unique underground environments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

China is undergoing a massive energy transition, aiming for carbon neutrality by 2060. This involves a significant shift from fossil fuels to renewable energy sources like wind and solar. However, the intermittent nature of these renewables creates challenges for grid stability and energy management, leading to significant energy wastage. Simultaneously, China faces a growing number of abandoned coal mines due to overcapacity. This paper addresses the problem of how to effectively utilize these abandoned mine shafts to address the energy storage needs of a renewable-heavy grid, thereby contributing to carbon neutrality goals and repurposing industrial waste.

Methods

The paper adopts a comprehensive review and analysis approach. It synthesizes existing literature on energy storage technologies, particularly PSH, and examines the current status of PSH development in abandoned mine shafts both globally and within China. The authors analyze relevant national policies and identify key scientific problems and research gaps. They propose a framework for future research and development, emphasizing intelligence, stabilization, and greening, alongside integration, completion, and coordination of PSH projects.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper relies on existing literature, policy documents, and statistical data from various sources (e.g., CNESA, National Energy Administration) rather than presenting new experimental datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Abandoned mines as a valuable resource: The paper highlights that abandoned mine shafts offer a significant, underutilized resource for PSH development, potentially reducing construction costs and land use compared to conventional PSH.
  • Addressing intermittency: PSH in abandoned mines is presented as a crucial solution for managing the intermittency of wind and solar power, improving grid stability, and reducing energy wastage.
  • Six key scientific problems: The authors identify six critical areas requiring further research for successful PSH implementation in abandoned mines, including site selection, water purification, reservoir stability, and operational dispatching.
  • Shift towards intelligent, green, and integrated PSH: The paper advocates for a future direction in PSH development that prioritizes intelligent control systems, environmentally friendly practices, and integrated approaches that combine PSH with other energy sources and urban development.
  • Policy alignment is crucial: The authors emphasize the need for streamlined national policies and coordinated efforts between government, industry, education, and research to accelerate PSH development in abandoned mines.

Key Results

The paper does not present quantitative experimental results but rather a qualitative assessment and strategic roadmap. Key findings include:

  • China's commitment to carbon neutrality by 2060 necessitates a substantial increase in renewable energy and, consequently, energy storage capacity.
  • PSH is currently the dominant global energy storage technology, accounting for 92.6% of global capacity in 2019 and 86.3% of China's capacity in 2021.
  • China has a substantial number of abandoned coal mines (estimated at 15,000 by 2030), offering significant potential for PSH development.
  • The paper identifies six key scientific problems that need to be addressed for the successful implementation of PSH in abandoned mine shafts.
  • The authors propose a framework for future research and development, focusing on intelligence, stabilization, greening, integration, completion, and coordination.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations:

  • The paper acknowledges that the technical bottleneck for large-scale application of PSH plants in coal mines still exists, and current designs may adapt poorly to varying mine conditions.
  • The paper focuses heavily on China's context, and while it mentions international examples, a deeper comparative analysis of global challenges and solutions could be beneficial.

Future Work:

The paper strongly advocates for future research in several key areas:

  • Site Selection: Developing robust evaluation models for identifying suitable abandoned mine shafts, considering geographical, sectoral, and technical features.
  • Water Quality Management: Investigating and developing advanced purification technologies for mine water to ensure operational efficiency and environmental safety.
  • Reservoir Stability: Researching the long-term stability of underground reservoirs, particularly concerning water infiltration, seismic activity, and the integrity of dam structures.
  • Operational Optimization: Proposing intelligent dispatching and operating models for PSH plant groups, especially in a distributed manner, to maximize energy utilization and grid integration.
  • Grid Integration: Developing efficient grid-level energy transmission modes and optimizing the utilization rate of energy generated by cluster generator sets.
  • Policy and Standardization: Streamlining national policies and developing comprehensive standards for the development and utilization of abandoned mine shaft resources for PSH.
  • Integrated Development: Promoting integrated development models that combine PSH with other energy sources and urban planning in resource-depleted regions.

Summary updated

Abstract

The quest for carbon neutrality raises challenges in most sectors. In coal mining, overcapacity cutting is the major concern at this time, and the increase in the number of abandoned mine shafts is a pervasive issue. Pumped storage hydropower (PSH) plants built in abandoned mine shafts can convert intermittent electricity into useful energy. However, studies on basic theories and key technologies are a pressing issue. Six key scientific problems have been identified in PSH development in abandoned mine shafts that are relevant to China’s national conditions, current resource structure, and relative status of energy storage technologies in China and other countries. It is proposed that the research on pumped storage should move closer to the direction of intelligence, stabilization, and greening, and the construction and development should gradually realize integration, completion, and coordination. The goal is to realize integrated, complete, and coordinated development of PSH in abandoned mine shafts, streamline national policies concerning PSH, drive the co-development of industry, education and research, and achieve the carbon neutrality targets set by China.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lyu2022pumped,
  author = {Xin Lyu and Tong Zhang and Yuan Liang and Ke Yang and Juejing Fang and Shanshan Li and Shuai Liu},
  title = {{Pumped Storage Hydropower in Abandoned Mine Shafts: Key Concerns and Research Directions}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su142316012},
}
Figure