Pulsed Dye Laser for Port Wine Stains in 974 Children: A 20-Year Study in China

Bingyu Xiu, Zhe Xu, Zigang Xu, Bin Zhang, Wei Li, Lin MaClinical 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This 20-year retrospective study of 974 pediatric patients in China confirms that 595nm pulsed dye laser (PDL) is a safe and effective treatment for port-wine stains (PWS), achieving an overall efficacy rate of 65.3%. The study identifies that clinical success is significantly influenced by non-obvious factors, including the patient's gender, the anatomical location of the lesion (limbs performed best), and the total number of treatment sessions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Port-wine stains (PWS) are congenital vascular malformations—essentially dilated capillaries in the skin—that appear as pink or purple patches. Because they do not regress and often thicken or darken with age, they can cause significant psychological distress and physical complications.

While the 595nm pulsed dye laser (PDL) is the "gold standard" treatment based on the principle of selective photothermolysis (using specific light wavelengths to destroy blood vessels without damaging surrounding tissue), clinical outcomes vary wildly. Most existing literature focuses on small cohorts or adult patients. This paper addresses the lack of large-scale, long-term pediatric data, specifically within the Chinese population, to determine which clinical factors actually predict a successful outcome.

Methods

The researchers conducted a retrospective analysis of 974 children (under 18) treated at Beijing Children’s Hospital between 2003 and 2021.

  • Technology: They used the Vbeam 595nm PDL system equipped with a dynamic cooling device (DCD) to protect the epidermis.
  • Parameters: Energy densities ranged from 9–12.5 J/cm² with pulse widths of 1.5–20 ms.
  • Evaluation: Efficacy was measured using Achauer’s clearance criteria, which categorizes results into four tiers: Ineffective (<25% clearance), Effective (26-50%), Remarkable (51-75%), and Cured (76-100%).
  • Analysis: The team employed Ridit analysis, a statistical method specifically suited for comparing ordered categorical data (like the Achauer tiers) across different groups.

Datasets

The "dataset" consists of the clinical records and standardized pre/post-treatment photographs of the 974 pediatric patients.

  • Demographics: 432 males, 542 females; median age of 24 months at the first visit.
  • Inclusion: Solitary PWS, Fitzpatrick skin types II–IV.
  • Exclusion: Patients with previous treatments, thickened/hyperplastic lesions, or incomplete follow-up data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Gender Gap: Females showed a significantly higher efficacy rate (69.7%) than males (59.7%). The authors hypothesize this isn't biological, but rather driven by higher aesthetic expectations from parents of girls, leading to better adherence to treatment protocols and reaching the "endpoint" of therapy.
  • Anatomical Surprises: Contrary to some previous studies suggesting facial lesions respond best, this study found that limbs (87.5%) and the neck (75.0%) had the highest efficacy. The authors suggest that thicker skin on the extremities may actually reduce light scattering, allowing for more focused energy delivery to the target vessels.
  • The "Persistence" Multiplier: Efficacy is cumulative. The success rate jumped from 41.4% after a single session to 84.0% after four or more sessions. This underscores the importance of managing parental expectations regarding the "long game" of treatment.
  • Size Matters: Lesions smaller than 3 cm² had a 76.8% efficacy rate, significantly higher than larger lesions. Smaller lesions likely correlate with higher parental compliance and lower treatment costs, leading to more consistent follow-ups.

Key Results

  • Overall Efficacy: 65.3% (combined "Remarkable" and "Cured" cases).
  • Age Performance: Adolescents (12-18y) achieved a 100% efficacy rate in this cohort, likely due to better physical compliance during the procedure and higher personal motivation for clearance.
  • Trigeminal Nerve Distribution: For facial PWS, lesions in the V3 (mandibular) branch responded best (68.5%), while the V1 (ophthalmic) branch was the most resistant (58.2%).
  • Safety Profile: The adverse reaction rate was remarkably low at 4.31%. Most issues were temporary pigmentation changes (2.87% hyperpigmentation, 1.03% hypopigmentation), with minimal scarring (0.41%) that resolved over 1-5 years of follow-up.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  1. Retrospective Bias: As a retrospective study, there is inherent selection bias; patients who saw no improvement early on may have dropped out, potentially inflating the "long-term" success rates.
  2. Lack of Hyperplastic Data: The cohort consisted entirely of "flat" PWS. Results might differ significantly for older patients with thickened or nodular lesions.
  3. Depth of Penetration: While 595nm is effective, it has limited depth. The authors suggest future research should explore combining PDL with lasers of greater penetration (like Nd:YAG) to target deeper vascular structures that PDL alone cannot reach.

Summary updated

Abstract

The efficacy of 595nm PDL for treating PWS in children is influenced by gender, age, lesion location, size, and the number of treatment sessions. PDL is an effective treatment for pediatric PWS with minimal adverse reactions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xiu2024pulsed,
  author = {Bingyu Xiu and Zhe Xu and Zigang Xu and Bin Zhang and Wei Li and Lin Ma},
  title = {{Pulsed Dye Laser for Port Wine Stains in 974 Children: A 20-Year Study in China}},
  booktitle = {Clinical},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.2147/ccid.s487229},
}
Figure