TL;DR
In response to the global COVID-19 pandemic, eLife is implementing significant policy changes to its peer review process. The journal aims to reduce pressure on researchers, accelerate the dissemination of vital findings, and adapt to the new realities of scientific work, emphasizing flexibility and support for the community.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The COVID-19 pandemic has created unprecedented challenges for the scientific community. Researchers are on the front lines battling the virus, redirecting their efforts to develop diagnostics, therapies, and vaccines. Simultaneously, many labs are closed, and scientists are grappling with personal worries, making traditional research and publishing workflows unsustainable. The core problem eLife addresses is how to maintain a robust and supportive publishing environment that acknowledges these extraordinary circumstances without compromising scientific rigor. The authors highlight the need to adapt to a reality where publishing may not be a priority, experiments are stalled, and speed is of the essence.
Methods
This paper is an editorial outlining policy changes, not a research paper with experimental methods. The "methods" here refer to the editorial and policy adjustments eLife is making:
- Curtailing requests for additional experiments during revisions: eLife is shifting from a policy that allowed for additional experiments to be requested (within a two-month window) to one that accepts manuscripts that can stand as eLife papers as is, even if further work could strengthen them. Revisions will be limited to clarity and presentation. If modest new data are needed, authors can either alter claims or clearly state that conclusions require additional data, with the expectation of future reporting via preprints or Research Advances.
- Suspending the two-month limit on revisions: Authors will be given as much time as needed to submit revised manuscripts, acknowledging that the pandemic may significantly delay their ability to complete revisions.
- Making preprint posting the default: eLife will now default to posting submitted manuscripts on bioRxiv or medRxiv, either by the authors or the journal. Authors can opt out, but are strongly encouraged not to, to accelerate dissemination. eLife is also experimenting with attaching its peer reviews to manuscripts on preprint servers.
- Extending "scoop protection" to preprints: The journal's policy of not penalizing authors if competing work is published during review will now explicitly include preprints, ensuring that posting a preprint to establish priority does not negatively impact a submission.
- Mobilizing early-career researchers: eLife is accelerating plans to invite early-career researchers to become reviewing editors, aiming to increase their editorial experience and diversify the editorial board.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Prioritizing Researcher Well-being: The editorial explicitly states that "nothing is more important than taking care of your health and sanity," signaling a fundamental shift in how the journal views the author's circumstances.
- Embracing Preprints as a Norm: The pandemic has accelerated the adoption of preprints, and eLife is now actively promoting this as the default for rapid dissemination, recognizing its role in speeding up research.
- Flexibility Over Rigidity: The policy changes demonstrate a move towards greater flexibility in the peer review process, acknowledging that traditional timelines and expectations are no longer feasible for many.
- Maintaining Standards While Adapting: Despite the significant changes, eLife emphasizes that these adjustments are made "without compromising eLife's standards," aiming to balance speed and support with scientific integrity.
- The Future of Publishing is Author-Driven and Immediate: The editorial frames these changes as a step towards a future where immediate, author-driven publishing through preprints is the norm, with journals playing a crucial role in peer review and curation.
Key Results
This is an editorial outlining policy changes, not a paper reporting experimental results. The "results" are the implemented policy shifts:
- Revised Revision Policy: Manuscripts will be accepted if they meet eLife standards, with revisions limited to clarity and presentation, rather than requiring new experiments.
- Extended Revision Timelines: The previous two-month limit for revisions is suspended indefinitely.
- Default Preprint Posting: All eLife submissions will default to being posted on bioRxiv or medRxiv.
- Expanded Scoop Protection: The policy now explicitly covers preprints.
- Increased Early-Career Researcher Involvement: Plans to invite early-career researchers as reviewing editors are being fast-tracked.
Limitations and Future Work
- Operational Challenges: The authors acknowledge that operating at "peak efficiency" may not be realistic for a while due to the strain on editors, reviewers, and staff. They ask for patience from the community.
- Future of Peer Review: While not explicitly stated as a limitation, the paper implies that eLife will continue to experiment with integrating peer reviews with preprints and further developing its editorial board diversity. The success of these policy shifts will likely inform future directions in scientific publishing.
Summary updated