Publisher’s Note

Miriam Blum, M.e. Werchow, Daniel Yeshurun, Bryan Larsen, David J. Hurry, Ramon E. Miro, David Charles, Seppo Kivinen, Frej Stenbäck, Israel G. Gorodeski, Lina Wasserman, Alexander Neri, Charles M. Bahari, Ove Axelssön, Henric Malmström, David R. Garris, Lamar T. Blankenship, Dan S. Whitehead, Antti Kauppila, Anna‐Liisa Hartikainen‐Sorri, Mikko Koivisto, P Ryhänen, Amos Fein, Vladimir Toder, L. NebelGynecologic 1983 · DOI

TL;DR

In 1983, the journal Gynecologic and Obstetric Investigation announced a strategic shift to monthly publication to handle a surge in manuscript submissions. To offset rising production costs and keep subscription prices stable, the publisher introduced author page charges—a move designed to both subsidize the expansion and encourage more concise scientific writing.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

This "Publisher’s Note" addresses the logistical and financial pressures facing academic journals during a period of growth. Specifically, the journal was grappling with two conflicting forces:

  1. Submission Overload: The volume of submitted research far exceeded the available physical space in the journal's existing schedule.
  2. Economic Sustainability: Increasing the number of issues to accommodate more research naturally drives up production costs. The publisher needed a way to expand capacity without passing the full financial burden onto subscribers through massive price hikes.

The note outlines a transition from a lower-frequency schedule to a monthly publication cycle, aiming to increase the "throughput" of peer-reviewed research in the field of gynecology and obstetrics.

Methods

As this is an administrative announcement rather than a research study, the "methods" described are strategic and financial rather than experimental:

  • Frequency Expansion: Increasing the volume by two additional issues per year to reach a monthly cadence.
  • Price Restructuring: Lowering the base price per issue to mitigate the total price increase per volume.
  • Introduction of Page Charges: Implementing a fee for authors (SFr. 185.- / DM 230.- / US$ 100.00 per printed page). This fee covers tables, illustrations, and references.
  • Brevity Incentivization: Using these page charges as a "soft" editorial tool to encourage authors to write more concisely, thereby allowing more individual papers to fit within the same page count.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. (The note refers generally to the "quantity of submitted manuscripts," but no specific data or benchmarks are provided.)

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Brevity Nudge": Perhaps the most interesting insight is the dual purpose of page charges. While they are a revenue stream, the editors explicitly view them as a mechanism for "encouraging brevity." By putting a price tag on length, the journal forces authors to prioritize their most impactful data, theoretically increasing the information density of the journal.
  • Subsidizing the Reader: The publisher chose a model that shifts some of the financial burden from the consumer (the subscriber) to the producer (the author/institution). This was a precursor to the discussions we see today regarding Open Access and Article Processing Charges (APCs), though in 1983, this was likely a hybrid model where both parties still paid.
  • Conversion Metrics: The note provides a practical metric for authors: 1 printed page is roughly equivalent to 1.5 manuscript pages. This gives us a glimpse into the typesetting standards of the early 1980s.

Key Results

The note formalizes the 1983 operational parameters for the journal:

  • Publication Schedule: Monthly.
  • Subscription Rates: SFr. 148.- / DM 185.- / US$ 79.00 per volume.
  • Author Costs: US$ 100.00 per printed page (with equivalent rates in SFr and DM).
  • Grandfather Clause: The new charges did not apply to manuscripts that had already been accepted prior to the announcement, ensuring a fair transition for authors already in the pipeline.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations: The note does not address the potential negative impact on authors with limited funding or those from institutions that do not subsidize page charges. It also does not discuss how "brevity" might affect the depth of complex technical reporting or the inclusion of raw data.

Future Work: Not discussed in the paper. (However, the move to monthly publication implies a commitment to monitoring the impact of these changes on submission quality and journal turnaround times.)

Summary updated

Abstract

In 1983, Gynecologic and Obstetric Investigation will expand to include 2 additional issues per volume.In spite of the added production costs brought on by this move to
BibTeX
@inproceedings{blum1983publishers,
  author = {Miriam Blum and M.E. Werchow and Daniel Yeshurun and Bryan Larsen and David J. Hurry and Ramon E. Miro and David Charles and Seppo Kivinen and Frej Stenbäck and Israel G. Gorodeski and Lina Wasserman and Alexander Neri and Charles M. Bahari and Ove Axelssön and Henric Malmström and David R. Garris and Lamar T. Blankenship and Dan S. Whitehead and Antti Kauppila and Anna‐Liisa Hartikainen‐Sorri and Mikko Koivisto and P Ryhänen and Amos Fein and Vladimir Toder and L. Nebel},
  title = {{Publisher’s Note}},
  booktitle = {Gynecologic},
  year = {1983},
  doi = {10.1159/000299394},
}
Figure