Introduction
Scientific progress relies on the absolute precision of reported data and scales. In the January 2019 issue of Nature Geoscience, two significant corrections were issued for high-impact studies. These corrections address critical numerical thresholds in climate modeling and fundamental spatial scales in geological imaging, ensuring the physical consistency of the published record.
Correcting the Scale of Crustal Fluid Flow
The primary correction concerns the study by Plümper et al. regarding fluid-driven metamorphism. This research investigated the mechanisms by which fluids migrate through the continental crust, a process fundamental to geological transformations.
A technical error in the original publication resulted in the omission of the Greek letter "μ" (mu) in several scale bar measurements within Figure 2. This omission misrepresented the spatial scale of the observed phenomena by six orders of magnitude. In the context of "nanoscale" fluid flow, the distinction between meters and micrometers is physically transformative.
The Importance of Micrometers vs. Meters
The original print suggested scales of 50 m, 20 m, 1 m, and 1 m for Figure 2b-e. These measurements would describe macro-geological features visible to the naked eye. The corrected scales—50 μm, 20 μm, 1 μm, and 1 μm—restore the intended context of grain-scale interactions. These micro-scale observations are essential for understanding how fluid-driven chemical changes propagate through the crust at the nanoscale.
Refining the Global Carbon Budget
In the same issue, an author correction was issued for the work of Gasser et al., which examined the impact of permafrost carbon release on global $CO_2$ emission budgets. The original study explored "path-dependent" reductions in the remaining carbon budget necessary to limit global warming to 1.5 °C and 2 °C.
The correction resolves discrepancies between the main text and Supplementary Table 1. Specifically, the total $CO_2$ exceedance budgets—the amount of $CO_2$ that can be emitted before reaching a temperature target—were slightly underestimated in the original publication.
Quantitative Adjustments
The updated figures show a consistent increase of 30 Gt $CO_2$ across the primary targets:
- 1.5 °C Target: The budget was corrected from 2,320 Gt $CO_2$ (range 2,260–2,450) to 2,350 Gt $CO_2$ (range 2,290–2,480).
- 2.0 °C Target: The budget was corrected from 3,230 Gt $CO_2$ (range 3,080–3,530) to 3,260 Gt $CO_2$ (range 3,110–3,550).
While these adjustments represent a relatively small percentage of the total budget (~3% difference from IPCC estimates rather than the 2% originally stated), they are vital for the accuracy of climate policy benchmarks.
Conclusion
These corrections underscore the importance of rigorous proofreading and the verification of supplementary data. Whether defining the microscopic pathways of crustal fluids or adjusting global climate targets, precision is the cornerstone of reliable geoscience. The updated values and scales ensure that future research building on these studies starts from a physically accurate foundation.
Summary updated