Public–private partnerships in fostering outer space innovations

Gordon C. Rausser, Elliot Choi, Alexandre M. BayenProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a new framework for space innovation: Public-Private Research and Development Partnerships (PPRDPs) governed by Decentralized Autonomous Organizations (DAOs). By moving away from traditional "linear" research models and using blockchain-based "smart contracts," the authors argue we can align the incentives of NASA, universities, and private firms to prevent a "tragedy of the commons" in orbit and accelerate the burgeoning space economy.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Outer space is currently an "open-access" resource and a global common. As the "New Space" era accelerates, we face a systemic risk of exuberant, uncoordinated competition—a classic "tragedy of the commons" where individual actors pursuing short-term gains (like satellite over-deployment or debris neglect) ruin the resource for everyone.

Traditional Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs) often suffer from "coordination failures." Public institutions (like NASA) focus on long-term basic research, while private firms prioritize short-term commercialization. This often leads to "crowding out," where public research is neglected in favor of immediate profits. Furthermore, traditional contracts are often "incomplete," leading to bureaucratic delays and disputes over intellectual property (IP) when unexpected breakthroughs occur.

Methods

The authors synthesize economic theory and emerging technology to propose a Polycentric Autonomous Governance structure. Key components include:

  • Research Cluster Synthesis: The paper identifies six critical "innovation clusters" (Transportation, In-space Manufacturing, Bioproduction, Nuclear Propulsion, Agriculture, and Satellite Services) and maps out the current public and private players in each.
  • Nonlinear Research Paradigm: Moving away from the "Bush Paradigm" (a straight line from basic to applied research), the authors adopt a feedback-loop model where basic and applied research augment each other.
  • DAO Framework: The core proposal is to manage these clusters via a Decentralized Autonomous Organization (DAO). This uses blockchain-based "smart contracts" to automate governance, resource allocation, and IP distribution without a centralized, bureaucratic authority.
  • Three-Token System:
    • Soulbound Tokens (SBTs): Non-transferable IDs to verify the credentials and history of participants (preventing "Sybil attacks").
  • Governance Tokens: Distributed based on investment, allowing members to vote on fund allocation and new entries.
  • NFTs: Representing a member's share in a specific research cluster, used to distribute royalties or licensing rights from IP.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. This is a theoretical and framework-oriented paper that relies on qualitative case studies (e.g., the International Space Station National Lab, UC Berkeley’s BAIR lab) and economic literature rather than a primary quantitative dataset.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Agglomeration Externalities: The paper argues that space R&D benefits from "clustering." Just as Silicon Valley thrived on "knowledge spillovers" and labor pooling, space innovation needs proximity—either physical or via high-trust digital networks—to trigger "Marshallian" and "Jacobs-type" externalities that increase productivity.
  • Control Rights as Options: In research agreements, "control rights" (who decides what happens when things go off-script) should be tied to the goal. If the goal is basic research, the public partner should hold more control; if it's commercialization, the private partner should lead.
  • Trustless Collaboration: By using DAOs, partners don't need to "trust" each other in the traditional sense. The "smart contract" acts as a digital constitution that is immutable and self-executing, reducing the risk of "procedural drift" or administrative interference.
  • Crowding-In vs. Crowding-Out: Instead of private funding replacing public research, a well-structured PPRDP creates a "virtuous cycle" where commercial success generates more resources for high-risk, high-reward basic research.

Key Results

The paper provides a conceptual roadmap rather than quantitative metrics. However, its primary "results" are:

  • A Governance Blueprint: A detailed structure for how a Space DAO would function, from initial investment to IP distribution.
  • Identification of 6 Strategic Clusters: A clear taxonomy of the sectors that will drive the space economy over the next two decades.
  • Policy Recommendation: A call for NASA and universities to move toward "open-source" research models (like UCB’s BAIR lab) to maximize knowledge spillovers, rather than hoarding exclusive IP.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Regulatory Friction: The authors acknowledge that current international treaties (like the 1967 Outer Space Treaty) and domestic laws (like the Artemis Accords) are still evolving and may clash with decentralized governance models.
  • DAO Maturity: While the theory is sound, DAOs are still a nascent technology. Implementing them at the scale of NASA-level contracting involves significant technical and security hurdles.
  • Physical Proximity: While the paper emphasizes "agglomeration," it remains to be seen how "proximity" works when the research is happening in Low Earth Orbit (LEO) while the researchers are scattered across the globe.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest further research into the "constitutional design" of these smart contracts to ensure they can handle the extreme complexity of aerospace engineering and international law.

Summary updated

Abstract

As public and private institutions recognize the role of space exploration as a catalyst for economic growth, various areas of innovation are expected to emerge as drivers of the space economy. These include space transportation, in-space manufacturing, bioproduction, in-space agriculture, nuclear launch, and propulsion systems, as well as satellite services and their maintenance. However, the current nature of space as an open-access resource and global commons presents a systemic risk for exuberant competition for space goods and services, which may result in a "tragedy of the commons" dilemma. In the race among countries to capture the value of space exploration, NASA, American research universities, and private companies can avoid any coordination failures by collaborating in a public-private research and development partnership (PPRDP) structure. We present such a structure founded upon the principles of polycentric autonomous governance, which incorporate a decentralized autonomous organization framework and specialized research clusters. By advancing an alignment of incentives among the specified participatory members, PPRDPs can play a pivotal role in stimulating open-source research by creating positive knowledge spillover effects and agglomeration externalities as well as embracing the nonlinear decomposition paradigm that may blur the distinction between basic and applied research.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{rausser2023publicprivate,
  author = {Gordon C. Rausser and Elliot Choi and Alexandre M. Bayen},
  title = {{Public–private partnerships in fostering outer space innovations}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.2222013120},
}
Figure