TL;DR
This paper details the public participation process within the TERRAIN project, which aims to develop an audio-tactile navigation system for visually impaired pedestrians. By involving non-visually impaired citizens in a co-design process, the project gathered crucial insights into societal acceptance, potential impacts, and necessary adaptations for the technology, highlighting the importance of integrating diverse perspectives early in development.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Visually impaired individuals face significant challenges navigating urban environments safely and independently. These challenges stem from difficulties in perceiving obstacles, understanding spatial layouts, and a resulting fear of accidents and disorientation, which can lead to restricted mobility and social isolation. The TERRAIN project seeks to address this by developing a technical guidance system for orientation and navigation. However, the development of such a system requires more than just technical feasibility; it necessitates understanding and integrating ethical, legal, and social implications (ELSI) and ensuring societal acceptance. This paper specifically focuses on how public participation, particularly from citizens without visual impairments, can inform this process and provide valuable feedback from an "outer" perspective.
Methods
The core methodology involved a co-design approach integrating reflexive, responsive, and deliberative dimensions. A key component was a workshop with 39 non-visually impaired citizens. This workshop utilized:
- Brainwriting Pool Method: For initial idea generation on technology use in public spaces.
- Simulated Impairment Experience: Participants used special glasses to simulate visual impairments and were guided by a second person to foster empathy.
- Narrative-Based Discussions: Participants were presented with narratives of real-life application situations to help them imagine the technology's use and potential impacts.
- Qualitative Content Analysis: Transcribed workshop discussions were analyzed using an iterative process to identify and categorize themes, with "open coding" used for detailed analysis.
- Technology Assessment (TA): A roundtable moderated discussions between technical partners, experts, and affected stakeholders.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The focus is on qualitative data gathered through workshops and discussions.
Key Insights and Ideas
- The "Outer" Perspective is Crucial: Involving citizens without visual impairments provided a valuable external viewpoint on the technology's potential impacts, acceptance, and necessary adaptations, complementing the direct user feedback.
- Empathy Through Experience: Simulating visual impairments and experiencing guided navigation significantly enhanced participants' understanding of the challenges faced by visually impaired individuals.
- Beyond Technical Functionality: Citizens raised concerns and identified needs that extend beyond the core technical features, including social interaction, financing, and potential stigmatization.
- Camera System Acceptance: Surprisingly, the use of camera systems within the assistive technology was viewed less critically than anticipated by the developers, suggesting potential for greater integration of visual components.
- Timing of Participation Matters: While the participation provided valuable insights, the authors note that earlier involvement of citizens could have allowed for greater integration of feedback into the technology development process.
Key Results
- Broad Acceptance: No outright rejection of the technical innovation was found among the participating citizens. The potential for inclusion through increased mobility was highly appreciated.
- Identification of Key Themes: Discussions revealed a wide range of concerns and expectations, categorized into technology-centered issues (visibility, data collection, handling) and non-technology-centered issues (social participation, financing, fears, user characteristics, liability, freedom).
- Societal Impact Awareness: Participants actively discussed potential societal impacts, such as changes in human interaction, the risk of exclusion, and the need for societal contributions to financing.
- Desirability and Acceptability: The participation process provided strong indications of the desirability and acceptability of the TERRAIN system from a general societal perspective.
Limitations and Future Work
- Sample Representativeness: The study acknowledges that the participant sample was not representative of the general population, aiming instead to capture a variety of potential chances and challenges.
- Limited Funding and Time: The project's duration and funding constraints limited the ability to fully explore all identified issues, particularly those requiring further research (e.g., the risk of exclusion due to visible technology).
- Translating Non-Technical Input: A methodological challenge remains in effectively translating non-technical results from participation processes into actionable insights for technology developers.
- Future Work: The authors suggest the need for accompanying research tasks that involve reflexive and responsive loops, potentially starting with needs assessment before specific technical development. They also propose further scientific accompaniment of everyday technology use to assess real-world impacts and continued citizen involvement.
Summary updated