Public Auditing with Privacy Protection in a Multi-User Model of Cloud-Assisted Body Sensor Networks

Lu Liu, Song Li, Jie Cui, Hong Zhong, Lu Liu 0001Sensors 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel certificateless public auditing scheme for cloud-assisted Wireless Body Sensor Networks (WBSNs) that supports multi-user data sharing while ensuring robust privacy protection. The scheme addresses the critical need for secure and verifiable storage of sensitive health data in cloud environments, particularly in community settings, by enabling group collaboration and revoking malicious members.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Wireless Body Sensor Networks (WBSNs) are increasingly vital for remote healthcare monitoring, offering continuous patient data collection. However, the limited resources of wearable sensors pose challenges for data processing and security. Cloud computing offers a solution by providing computational and storage resources, but this introduces significant data security and privacy concerns. Specifically, sensitive medical records stored on public cloud servers are vulnerable to unauthorized access and manipulation. While public auditing schemes exist to verify data integrity, they often fall short in protecting user privacy or supporting collaborative environments where multiple users (e.g., patients and their doctors in a community hospital) need to share data securely. Existing solutions struggle with issues like key escrow, certificate management, and the need for efficient revocation of malicious users in a group setting.

Methods

The paper proposes a certificateless public auditing scheme designed for a multi-user WBSN model. Key aspects of their approach include:

  • Certificateless Cryptography: This approach avoids the overhead of traditional public key infrastructure (PKI) by eliminating the need for certificates. Instead, user keys are split into two parts, generated by the user and a trusted Key Generation Centre (KGC), mitigating issues like key escrow and certificate management, which is crucial for resource-constrained WBSN devices.
  • Multi-User Model with Group Keys: Users can form groups to share data stored in the cloud. A shared group encryption key is used for data encryption, ensuring that only authorized group members can access the data.
  • Public Auditing: An auditor can verify the integrity of the data stored on the cloud server without accessing the sensitive data itself. This is achieved through an interactive protocol between the auditor and the cloud server.
  • Privacy Protection: Data is encrypted using a group key before being uploaded to the cloud. Even if the cloud server has access to the encrypted data, it cannot decipher its content. The auditing process is also designed to prevent the auditor from accessing user data.
  • Revocation and Forward Security: The scheme includes mechanisms for revoking users who engage in illegal activities (e.g., data modification). Upon revocation, the group key is updated, ensuring forward security, meaning that revoked users cannot access data encrypted with the new key.
  • Random Oracle Model (ROM) Proof: The security of the proposed scheme is formally proven under the Random Oracle Model, demonstrating its resilience against various attacks, including key replacement attacks.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on a theoretical cryptographic scheme and its security proofs, with experimental evaluations based on simulated cryptographic operations rather than real-world datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging the Gap between Cloud and WBSN Security: The paper effectively addresses the inherent tension between the need for cloud-based scalability and the stringent privacy requirements of medical data from WBSNs.
  • Certificateless Cryptography for Resource Constraints: The adoption of certificateless cryptography is a smart move, significantly reducing the computational and storage burden on wearable devices, making the scheme more practical for WBSN deployments.
  • Group Collaboration is Key for Healthcare: Recognizing that modern healthcare often involves collaboration (e.g., patient-doctor networks), the multi-user model with secure group sharing is a critical and well-implemented feature.
  • Auditing Without Compromising Privacy: The design of the public auditing mechanism, where the auditor verifies integrity without seeing the data, is a significant achievement for sensitive applications like healthcare.
  • Proactive Security with Revocation and Forward Security: The inclusion of robust revocation and forward security mechanisms is essential for maintaining trust and security in dynamic group environments.

Key Results

The paper presents a novel scheme that is proven secure against key replacement attacks in the random oracle model. Experimental evaluations show that the proposed scheme's ProofVerify algorithm is more efficient than existing schemes (specifically Wang et al.'s scheme [43]), achieving nearly a 30% improvement in efficiency due to requiring fewer pairing operations. The scheme also demonstrates good performance in other cryptographic operations like PartialPrivateKeyExtract and JoinGroup, with efficiency scaling reasonably with the number of users and data blocks.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Assumption of Semi-Trusted Cloud Server: While the scheme assumes a semi-trusted cloud server, it relies on the cloud server complying with the communication protocol. A fully untrusted cloud server might present further challenges.
  • Performance in Real-World Deployments: The experimental evaluation is based on simulated cryptographic operations. Real-world performance might vary depending on network conditions, device capabilities, and the specific implementation of cryptographic libraries.
  • Scalability for Very Large Groups: While the scheme supports multi-user sharing, the performance implications for extremely large groups or a very high number of concurrent auditing requests are not extensively detailed.

The authors suggest that their scheme is more suitable for cloud-assisted WBSN applications and outperforms other existing schemes in the same context, implying that further research could explore its application in diverse healthcare scenarios and potentially optimize it for even greater efficiency.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{liu2017public,
  author = {Lu Liu and Song Li and Jie Cui and Hong Zhong and Lu Liu},
  title = {{Public Auditing with Privacy Protection in a Multi-User Model of Cloud-Assisted Body Sensor Networks}},
  journal = {Sensors},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/s17051032},
}
Figure