Public attitude toward tiger farming and tiger conservation in <scp>B</scp>eijing, <scp>C</scp>hina

Zhiyu Liu, Zhigang Jiang, changsheng li, Han Fang, Xiaoge Ping, Z. Luo, Shuangshuang Tang, L. Li, Ziqi Meng, Yan ZengAnimal 2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This study surveyed Beijing residents and college students to understand their attitudes towards tiger farming and trade. Findings reveal a public prioritizing ecological and cultural values of tigers, supporting traditional conservation methods, and largely opposing commercial tiger trade, with college students showing stronger support for trade bans.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The conservation of wild tigers (Panthera tigris) is a critical global issue, facing threats like habitat loss and poaching for illegal trade. Tiger farming has emerged as a controversial conservation strategy, with arguments both for and against its use. Proponents suggest it can reduce poaching pressure by providing an alternative source for tiger products, while opponents fear it legitimizes the trade and may not effectively protect wild populations. To inform conservation policy and public engagement, understanding public attitudes towards tiger farming and trade is crucial, especially in key consumer markets like China. This paper addresses the knowledge gap regarding public opinion on these complex issues within Beijing, China.

Methods

The researchers employed a questionnaire survey to gather data from 677 citizens and 381 college students in Beijing. The survey design included:

  • Ranking Questions: Participants ranked the importance of various values of tigers (e.g., ecological, medicinal), threatening factors (e.g., poaching, habitat loss), and conservation methods (e.g., nature reserves, captive breeding).
  • Multiple-Choice Questions: These covered attitudes towards tiger farming, including whether tigers should be farmed, suitable farmers, funding sources, and the number of tigers to be farmed.
  • Attitude Scales (Likert Scale): A 7-point Likert scale was used to gauge agreement or disagreement with arguments for and against lifting the ban on tiger trade. Participants were presented with six pairs of opposing arguments, categorized as "blue side" (against lifting the ban) and "red side" (for lifting the ban).

Statistical analyses included Kendall's W-test for ranking questions, Cochran's Q-test for multiple-choice questions, and Pearson's chi-square test for cross-table data. For attitude scales, Wilcoxon and Mann-Whitney U-tests were used for related and independent samples, respectively.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from a survey of 677 citizens and 381 college students in Beijing, China, conducted between December 2011 and January 2012. No external datasets were used for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Value Hierarchy: The public clearly prioritizes the intrinsic and ecological values of tigers (ecological, cultural, aesthetic, scientific, educational) over utilitarian ones (medicinal, edible). This suggests a growing awareness of conservation beyond direct human benefit.
  • Conservation Preferences: Traditional conservation methods like establishing nature reserves and legislation are favored over captive breeding, indicating a preference for in-situ conservation.
  • Threat Perception: Poaching and illegal trade are identified as the primary threats to tigers, with medicinal and status symbol uses being key drivers of this illegal activity.
  • Tiger Farming as a Social Undertaking: A significant portion of respondents view tiger farming as a social initiative, primarily for population continuation and reintroduction, rather than for commercial purposes.
  • Support for Trade Ban: There is a strong inclination to support the ban on trading tiger products, particularly among college students, highlighting the impact of education on conservation attitudes.
  • Nuance in Farming Arguments: While generally opposing commercial trade, respondents showed a more balanced attitude towards arguments for the use of farmed tigers compared to arguments against it, suggesting a complex view on the role of farming.

Key Results

  • Top Values: Ecological, cultural, aesthetic, and scientific/educational values were ranked highest for tigers.
  • Top Conservation Methods: Legislation on wildlife protection and establishment of nature reserves were ranked as the most effective methods.
  • Top Threats: Poaching and illegal trade, human disturbance, and habitat loss were identified as the most significant threats.
  • Tiger Farming Support: Approximately 63% of citizens and 62.7% of students believed tigers should be farmed, primarily for population continuation and reintroduction.
  • Commercial Trade Opposition: Respondents generally agreed more with arguments against lifting the ban on tiger trade (blue side) than for it (red side), with average attitude scores indicating some agreement with the "anti-ban" stance and some disagreement with the "pro-ban" stance.
  • Student vs. Citizen Attitudes: College students showed a stronger inclination to support the ban on trading tiger products and had a clearer position on the arguments compared to citizens.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Geographic Scope: The study was conducted solely in Beijing, which may not represent the attitudes of the entire Chinese population. Future research could expand to other regions.
  • Commercial Use Ambiguity: While respondents largely viewed farming as non-commercial, there was some support for "commercial trade in products made of dead tigers" when considering disposal options, indicating a potential for future conflict or policy challenges.
  • Behavior vs. Attitude Gap: The paper notes that despite positive attitudes towards conservation, actual consumption of legally protected wildlife still exists. Future work should focus on bridging this gap between attitude and behavior through public awareness campaigns and behavioral change strategies.
  • Disposal of Farmed Tigers: The study found that "temporary storage for future consideration" was the most chosen option for disposing of dead farmed tigers, but "commercial trade in tiger products" was favored over "destruction," suggesting the dilemma of how to manage farmed tiger carcasses remains unresolved.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract There are arguments in support of and against use of tiger farming as a tool for the conservation of wild tigers P anthera tigris . Public attitude toward tiger farming can be a useful reference for tiger conservation. To fill this knowledge gap, we surveyed 677 citizens and 381 college students in B eijing to understand their knowledge of tiger conservation and attitude toward tiger farming. The results of ranking questions showed that with regard to the value of tigers, ecological, cultural and aesthetic, and scientific and educational value were ranked as the top three; legislation on wildlife protection and establishment of nature reserves were ranked as the top conservation methods; and poaching and illegal trade, human disturbance and loss of habitat were ranked as the top threatening factors. Apparently, medicinal and healthcare use as well as value as status symbols can be considered the main consumption motivations that trigger poaching and illegal trade. With regard to farming of tigers and the aspects of whether tigers should be farmed, the number of farmed tigers, how to dispose of farmed tigers and so on, we found that most of respondents considered farming of tigers to be a social undertaking and found it difficult to relate to commercial purposes. The results showed that people hold clear positions on arguments for and against the ban on tiger trade and were inclined to support the ban on trading tiger products, especially college students. We also found that the respondents were more balanced toward arguments in support of the use of farmed tigers than arguments against it.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2015public,
  author = {Zhiyu Liu and Zhigang Jiang and changsheng li and Han Fang and Xiaoge Ping and Z. Luo and Shuangshuang Tang and L. Li and Ziqi Meng and Yan Zeng},
  title = {{Public attitude toward tiger farming and tiger conservation in <scp>B</scp>eijing, <scp>C</scp>hina}},
  booktitle = {Animal},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1111/acv.12181},
}
Figure