Psychometric Properties of the Canadian Little Developmental Coordination Disorder Questionnaire for Preschool Children

Brenda N. Wilson, Dianne Creighton, Susan Crawford, Jennifer Heath, Lisa Semple, Benjamin Tan, Shannon HansenPhysical 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper validates the Canadian version of the Little Developmental Coordination Disorder Questionnaire (Little DCDQ) as a reliable and valid screening tool for identifying motor coordination difficulties in preschoolers aged 3-4 years. Early identification is crucial for timely intervention and preventing secondary developmental issues.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Developmental Coordination Disorder (DCD) is a common childhood condition characterized by motor in-coordination, affecting daily living and academic achievement. While DCD is typically diagnosed after age 5, this delay limits opportunities for early intervention. Existing screening tools are often not suitable for children under 5. This paper addresses the need for a reliable and valid screening tool to identify young children at risk of DCD, enabling earlier intervention and mitigating negative consequences.

Methods

The study employed a multi-faceted approach to evaluate the psychometric properties of the Canadian Little DCDQ:

  • Reliability:
    • Test-retest reliability: Assessed by having parents re-complete the questionnaire within a month to ensure stability over time.
  • Internal consistency: Evaluated using Cronbach's alpha to confirm that all items measure the same underlying construct (motor coordination).
  • Validity:
    • Construct validity:
      • Factor analysis: Used to explore the underlying structure of the questionnaire, expecting distinct gross and fine motor factors.
  • Group comparisons: Compared scores between children identified as "at risk" for motor problems and those typically developing.
  • Concurrent validity: Assessed by comparing Little DCDQ scores with standardized motor assessments (MABC-2 and Beery VMI) in a subgroup of children.
  • Discriminant validity: Examined the ability of individual items and the total score to differentiate between children with and without motor impairment (MI) identified through standardized testing.
  • Screening Tool Validity:
    • Logistic regression modeling: Used to identify significant predictors of MI and to develop optimal cut-off scores.
  • Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC) curves: Employed to visualize the trade-off between sensitivity and specificity and to determine the best cut-off values.

Datasets

The study utilized data from:

  • Preschool children aged 3 to 4 years and 11 months:
    • Typically Developing (TD) group: 108 children.
  • At-Risk (AR) group: 245 children, identified through preschool programs, specialized clinics, or preterm follow-up clinics.
  • Subgroup for standardized testing: 119 children from the larger sample who underwent motor testing.

No new benchmarks were introduced; existing standardized tests like the MABC-2 and Beery VMI were used as comparison measures.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Age-appropriateness: The Little DCDQ is specifically designed for 3-4 year olds, addressing a gap in existing screening tools.
  • Parental reporting is reliable: The high test-retest reliability indicates that parents can consistently report on their young children's motor skills over a short period.
  • Two distinct motor factors: Factor analysis confirmed that the Little DCDQ effectively captures both gross and fine motor skills, aligning with theoretical expectations.
  • Gender-specific cut-offs are important: The study found that gender is a significant predictor of Little DCDQ scores, necessitating gender-specific cut-off scores for accurate risk identification.
  • SDQ as a confounder control: The inclusion of the Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire (SDQ) allowed researchers to account for potential confounding factors like peer problems and hyperactivity, strengthening the confidence in the Little DCDQ's findings.

Key Results

  • High Reliability:
    • Test-retest reliability was very high (ICC = 0.96, p < .001).
  • Internal consistency was also high (Cronbach's alpha = 0.94 for the total sample).
  • Strong Validity:
    • Factor analysis revealed two factors (gross and fine motor) accounting for 61.4% of variance.
  • Significant differences were found between at-risk and typically developing children on the Little DCDQ total score and its factors.
  • Children with motor impairment (MI) identified by standardized tests had significantly lower Little DCDQ scores.
  • The Little DCDQ scores correlated well with MABC-2 and Beery VMI scores, with a few exceptions.
  • Effective Screening:
    • All 15 items demonstrated fair to good discrimination between children with and without MI.
  • Logistic regression identified lower total scores and being a boy as significant predictors of MI.
  • Gender-specific cut-off scores were established: <67 for boys (sensitivity 86%, specificity 63%) and <68 for girls (sensitivity 80%, specificity 49%).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Generalizability: The sample was recruited from a single city in Canada, which may limit the generalizability of the findings to other populations. A normative stratified sample was not recruited.
  • Low Numbers of Girls with MI: The subgroup of girls with motor impairment was small, which could impact the robustness of findings related to this group.
  • Specificity Below Standard: While sensitivity was good, the specificity for boys (63%) did not reach the commonly cited standard of 80%.
  • Future Research:
    • Larger sample sizes, particularly for girls with MI, would strengthen the psychometric properties.
  • Future research could examine the utility of teacher observations in comparison with parent reports.
  • Longitudinal studies are needed to understand the relationship between Little DCDQ scores and the actual diagnosis of DCD at school age.
  • The questionnaire with cut-off scores is planned to be available online in 2014.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Little DCDQ is a reliable, valid instrument for early identification of children with motor difficulties.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wilson2014psychometric,
  author = {Brenda N. Wilson and Dianne Creighton and Susan Crawford and Jennifer Heath and Lisa Semple and Benjamin Tan and Shannon Hansen},
  title = {{Psychometric Properties of the Canadian Little Developmental Coordination Disorder Questionnaire for Preschool Children}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.3109/01942638.2014.980928},
}
Figure