TL;DR
Nearly half of nursing interns in China experience psychological workplace violence (WPV), primarily in the form of discrimination and verbal abuse from patients and their relatives. This study quantifies a significant negative correlation between these experiences and an intern's "professional commitment," suggesting that psychological abuse is a major driver of the nursing shortage by discouraging new talent before they even graduate.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The global nursing shortage is a critical public health challenge, and China is no exception. While physical violence against healthcare workers often makes headlines, psychological workplace violence (WPV)—including verbal abuse, bullying, and discrimination—is more pervasive and often goes unreported.
Nursing interns are particularly vulnerable because they lack clinical experience and the professional status to defend themselves. This paper investigates the prevalence of psychological WPV among Chinese nursing interns, identifies the primary risk factors, and measures how these negative experiences erode "professional commitment"—the psychological bond and sense of duty an individual feels toward their career.
Methods
The researchers conducted a multicenter cross-sectional study involving 1,095 nursing interns from 14 medical colleges in Shandong Province.
- Instruments: They used two validated scales: a Chinese version of the "Workplace Violence against Nurses Questionnaire" and a 26-item "Professional Commitment Scale" (covering willingness to make effort, membership maintenance, and belief in goals).
- Analysis: Beyond descriptive statistics, the authors employed binary logistic regression to identify factors that predict whether an intern will experience violence. They then used linear regression to quantify the impact of that violence on the interns' professional commitment scores, adjusting for demographic variables like age, sex, and hospital level.
Datasets
The study utilized a primary dataset collected specifically for this research via an anonymous electronic survey (Sojump platform).
- Sample Size: $N = 1,095$ valid responses (84.3% response rate).
- Demographics: 86.8% female, average age ~21, with a mix of Bachelor’s and sub-Bachelor’s degree students.
- Setting: Interns were placed across various hospital tiers, with 76.6% in "Grade III-A" hospitals (the highest tier in China).
Key Insights and Ideas
- The "Invisible" Epidemic: 45% of interns reported at least one instance of psychological WPV. The most common forms were discrimination (56.4%) and verbal abuse (35.3%).
- Perpetrator Profile: Interestingly, the primary perpetrators weren't just the patients (75.9%), but even more frequently the patients' relatives (78.3%). This highlights a systemic tension in the patient-provider-family triad.
- The Reporting Gap: A staggering 75.9% of incidents were never reported. The top reasons for silence were viewing violence as a "normal phenomenon" (53.8%) or believing that "reporting doesn't solve the problem" (34.1%).
- The "Newbie" Window: Over half (54.8%) of all violence occurred within the first 1–3 months of the internship. This suggests a critical "hazing" or adjustment period where interns are most at risk.
- The Paradox of High-Tier Hospitals: Interns at Grade III-A hospitals (top-tier facilities) were significantly more likely to experience violence compared to those at lower-level hospitals. The authors attribute this to higher patient expectations and heavier workloads in elite institutions.
Key Results
- Impact on Commitment: Linear regression showed that psychological WPV had a significant negative effect on professional commitment ($\beta = -0.14, p < 0.01$). When interns are abused, their desire to stay in the profession drops measurably.
- Risk Factors:
- Hospital Level: Practicing in a Grade III-A hospital increased the odds of experiencing WPV (OR = 1.75).
- Duration: Longer internship duration and living in urban areas acted as protective factors, likely because interns developed better "street smarts" and coping mechanisms over time.
- Psychological Toll: 72.2% of victims reported a decline in work enthusiasm, and 52.5% expressed a desire to leave the nursing department entirely.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Cross-sectional Design: The study captures a snapshot in time, meaning it can show correlation but cannot strictly prove that WPV causes lower commitment (though the link is theoretically strong).
- Selection Bias: The use of convenient sampling from one province (Shandong) may not perfectly represent all of China.
- Self-Reporting: Data relies on the interns' memories and willingness to disclose, which can lead to recall bias.
Future Work: The authors call for longitudinal studies to track interns from school through their first few years of employment. They also recommend that nursing curricula include specific "de-escalation and coping" courses and that hospitals implement robust, non-punitive reporting mechanisms to break the culture of silence.
Summary updated