Abstract
Purpose: To identify the psychological impact of canceling cataract operations on patients during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Methods: 99 participants aged 55–89 years old, whose cataract surgeries were either postponed or proceeded as scheduled, were studied using the standardized Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9) and Generalized Anxiety Disorder questionnaire (GAD-7) from April to June 2020 at Kowloon East Cataract Center, Tseung Kwan O Hospital, Hong Kong.
Results: None of the patients who had their cataract surgeries rescheduled reached the cutoff score for major depression in PHQ-9. For GAD-7, five patients had mild symptoms of anxiety and one had severe symptoms (p-value = 0.76).
Conclusion: There was no significant psychosocial impact of the cancellation of cataract surgeries on patients.
Introduction
The COVID-19 pandemic necessitated a global shift in healthcare priorities, leading to the widespread suspension of "elective" surgeries to conserve resources and minimize infection risks. Cataract surgery, while often classified as elective, is critical for maintaining the quality of life in elderly populations. Visual impairment is historically linked to social isolation, depression, and increased mortality. This study aimed to quantify the mental health burden on patients facing surgical delays during the initial waves of the pandemic.
Methods and Participant Demographics
The researchers conducted a comparative study at the Kowloon East Cataract Center in Hong Kong between April and June 2020. The study population consisted of 99 participants, all aged 55 or older. These patients were categorized into two groups: a treatment group whose surgeries were postponed (either by the facility or by personal choice) and a control group who underwent surgery as scheduled.
To assess psychological well-being, two validated clinical instruments were utilized:
- PHQ-9 (Patient Health Questionnaire-9): A 9-item tool for screening and measuring the severity of depression.
- GAD-7 (Generalized Anxiety Disorder-7): A 7-item scale used to monitor the severity of generalized anxiety disorder.
Statistical analysis was performed using R, employing chi-square tests and regression analysis to identify correlations between surgery status and psychological distress.
Key Results
The study found no statistically significant difference in anxiety levels between patients whose surgeries were postponed and those whose surgeries proceeded (p-value = 0.76). Remarkably, over 80% of patients reported no symptoms of anxiety or depression.
Specific findings from the PHQ-9 indicated that zero patients reached the clinical cutoff score (≥ 10) for major depression. As shown in the data below, the vast majority of participants reported being "not at all" bothered by common depressive symptoms over the two weeks preceding the survey.
In the GAD-7 results, only one patient reported severe anxiety symptoms, while five reported mild symptoms. Subgroup analyses further revealed no significant differences in psychological symptoms based on gender, age (comparing those over 70 to those under 70), or preoperative visual acuity.
Discussion and Insights
The lack of significant psychological impact may be attributed to several factors:
- Expectation Alignment: Because the postponements occurred during a well-publicized global crisis, patients likely understood the necessity of the delay. This alignment between expectation and reality may have mitigated typical medical stress.
- Elderly Resilience: The study suggests that older adults may possess more robust coping mechanisms or experience fewer stressful life events compared to younger cohorts, making them more resilient to healthcare disruptions.
- Proactive Hygiene: While 65% of patients practiced high-frequency hand washing (>10 times per day), this behavior did not correlate with increased anxiety, suggesting it was a proactive health measure rather than a manifestation of obsessive-compulsive distress.
Limitations and Conclusion
A primary limitation of this study is its retrospective nature; questionnaires were administered after surgeries eventually took place, which may have introduced a "relief effect" that masked earlier distress. Additionally, the small sample size (n=99) and specific demographic (elderly patients in Hong Kong) may limit the generalizability of the findings to younger populations or different cultural contexts.
In conclusion, the postponement of cataract surgery during the COVID-19 pandemic did not result in a significant increase in depression or anxiety among the elderly patients studied. Future research should consider longitudinal designs to evaluate the cumulative impact of repeated surgical cancellations during prolonged healthcare crises.
Summary updated