Provably efficient multi-task Reinforcement Learning in large state spaces

Baihe Huang, Jason D. Lee, Zhaoran Wang, Zhuoran YangICLR 2023 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel framework for multi-task Reinforcement Learning (RL) in large state spaces, enabling agents to learn more efficiently by sharing knowledge across related tasks. They achieve this by proposing a new "Low-rank Multi-task Bilinear class" and an accompanying algorithm that provably finds near-optimal policies with significantly fewer samples than learning each task independently.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Reinforcement Learning (RL) agents often struggle to learn effectively in complex environments with vast state spaces, especially when dealing with multiple related tasks. While multi-task learning aims to improve sample efficiency by leveraging shared information, existing methods often rely on simplified models (like tabular or linear) and don't scale well to general function approximation. The core challenge is to develop RL algorithms that can learn from limited data across multiple tasks, exploiting underlying shared structures in large, complex state spaces, without sacrificing performance.

Methods

The authors introduce a new structural framework called the Low-rank Multi-task Bilinear class. This framework models multiple RL tasks (MDPs) where the Bellman error (a measure of how well a policy satisfies the Bellman equation) can be represented by a bilinear form. The key innovation is the assumption that the features of these bilinear forms across different tasks share a low-dimensional structure.

Their proposed algorithm, Algorithm 1, is an online representation learning algorithm based on the Optimism in the Face of Uncertainty (OFU) principle. It works by:

  1. Learning Shared Representations: Using Empirical Risk Minimization (ERM), the algorithm jointly learns task-specific features and a common, low-dimensional shared representation. This is the core of exploiting the "low-rank" structure.
  2. Constructing Confidence Sets: It builds an optimistic confidence set that is guaranteed to contain the true underlying model. This set is informed by the learned representations and historical data from all tasks.
  3. Exploiting Optimism: The algorithm selects the most optimistic hypothesis (policy) within this confidence set to guide exploration and data collection.

This approach differs from prior work like Bilin-UCB by explicitly learning and utilizing the shared low-dimensional structure, leading to improved sample efficiency.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical analysis and algorithmic design rather than empirical evaluation on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Low-Rank Structure is Key: The paper highlights that the presence of a low-rank structure in the features of the bilinear forms is crucial for achieving sample efficiency gains in multi-task RL with general function approximation. This structure allows for effective knowledge sharing.
  • Shared Representation for Efficiency: By learning a common, low-dimensional representation across tasks, the algorithm can significantly reduce the amount of data needed compared to learning each task in isolation.
  • OFU with Representation Learning: Combining the optimism principle with learned representations provides a powerful mechanism for efficient exploration and policy improvement in multi-task settings.
  • Generalization Beyond Linear Models: The framework extends beyond linear function approximation, offering a more general approach to multi-task RL that can handle complex, non-linear environments.

Key Results

The paper presents theoretical guarantees for their algorithm:

  • Provable Sample Efficiency: The algorithm is shown to find near-optimal policies with a sample complexity that is significantly improved compared to single-task learning methods (like Bilin-UCB). Specifically, they demonstrate a $(d/k)$-time improvement, where $d$ is the ambient dimension and $k$ is the intrinsic low dimension of the shared representation.
  • First Provably Sample-Efficient Algorithm: The authors claim this is the first provably sample-efficient multi-task RL algorithm with general function approximation.
  • Theoretical Bounds: Theorem 5.3 provides a formal bound on the regret (difference between optimal and achieved reward) achievable by the algorithm, showing it scales favorably with the number of tasks ($M$), horizon ($H$), and the low-rank dimension ($k$), while being less dependent on the high ambient dimension ($d$).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Complexity: While the algorithm is theoretically efficient, the paper notes that the ERM step (Line 3 in Algorithm 1) can be computationally intensive in general. However, they suggest that for specific instances of the bilinear class, efficient gradient-based methods might be applicable.
  • Dependence on $d$: The dependence on the ambient dimension $d$ cannot be entirely eliminated, as the algorithm needs to estimate a $d \times k$ matrix for shared representation.
  • Polynomial Improvement in $M$: The authors believe that without further assumptions, a polynomial improvement with respect to the number of tasks ($M$) is likely impossible, as the algorithm must learn task-specific features for each of the $M$ tasks.
  • Future Directions: The paper suggests that future work could explore transfer learning for rapidly adapting prior knowledge to new, unseen tasks with limited data and computational resources, building upon the success of representation learning in multi-task RL.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study multi-task Reinforcement Learning where shared knowledge among different environments is distilled to enable scalable generalization to a variety of problem instances. In the context of general function approximation, Markov Decision Process (MDP) with low Bilinear rank encapsulates a wide range of structural conditions that permit polynomial sample complexity in large state spaces, where the Bellman errors are related to bilinear forms of features with low intrinsic dimensions. To achieve multi-task learning in MDPs, we propose online representation learning algorithms to capture the shared features in the different task-specific bilinear forms. We show that in the presence of low-rank structures in the features of the bilinear forms, the algorithms benefit from sample complexity improvements compared to single-task learning. Therefore, we achieve the first sample efficient multi-task reinforcement learning algorithm with general function approximation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{huang2023provably,
  author = {Baihe Huang and Jason D. Lee and Zhaoran Wang and Zhuoran Yang},
  title = {{Provably efficient multi-task Reinforcement Learning in large state spaces}},
  booktitle = {International Conference on Learning Representations},
  year = {2023},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=p6wiThIOS5m},
}
Figure