Proton Spin in the Instanton Background

Marcus HütterarXiv 1995 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: The proton form factors are reduced to vacuum correlators of 4 quark fields by assuming independent constituent quarks. The axial singlet quark and gluonic form factors are calculated in the instanton liquid model. A discussion of gauge(in)dependence is given.

Introduction

The "Proton Spin Crisis" remains one of the most significant challenges in quantum chromodynamics (QCD). While the naive quark model suggests that the three valence quarks (uud) should account for the entirety of the proton's spin, experiments conducted by the European Muon Collaboration (EMC) and the Spin Muon Collaboration (SMC) in the late 1980s revealed a startling discrepancy: quarks contribute only about 20-30% of the total spin. This paper, authored by Marcus Hutter in 1995, investigates this mystery through the lens of the Instanton Liquid Model (ILM).

The Instanton Liquid Model (ILM)

The ILM treats the QCD vacuum not as an empty void, but as a "liquid" populated by instantons—topological fluctuations of the gluon field that represent transitions between different vacuum states. These instantons are crucial because they provide a mechanism for chiral symmetry breaking, explaining how nearly massless "current" quarks acquire the effective mass of "constituent" quarks.

Hutter's approach involves reducing the complex dynamics of the proton to vacuum correlators of four quark fields, under the assumption that the proton can be modeled as three nearly independent constituent quarks. This simplification allows for the calculation of axial singlet quark and gluonic form factors.

Methodology and Gauge Dependence

A central theme of the work is the handling of the axial anomaly. The axial current $J_{5\mu}$ is not conserved due to quantum effects, leading to the relation $\partial^\mu J_{5\mu} = 2N_f \partial^\mu K_\mu$, where $K_\mu$ is the anomaly current.

The paper provides a detailed analysis of gauge dependence. Specifically, it contrasts the "singular" and "regular" gauges. In the regular gauge, the anomaly current $K_\mu$ exhibits a massless "ghost pole," a mathematical feature that must be carefully interpreted to ensure physical results remain gauge-invariant.

Key Results

The primary goal was to calculate the Gauge Invariant (GI) axial current and the anomaly form factor $A(q)$. The model successfully yields an anomaly form factor $A(0) = -1$. However, the resulting prediction for the total quark spin contribution, $\Delta\Sigma^{GI}$, presents a theoretical hurdle.

Comparison of form factor relations under different physical limits, showing the model's prediction of the naive spin value.

As shown in the table above, the Instanton Liquid Model (in the "Instanton" row) predicts a value of $\Delta\Sigma^{GI} = 1$. This aligns with the "naive" quark model but fails to match the experimental value of $\Delta\Sigma \approx 0.27$. This discrepancy is a "positive" result in a theoretical sense, as it pinpoints the limitations of the current approximation.

Discussion and Limitations

The failure of the basic ILM to replicate the low experimental spin values is attributed to the neglect of non-zero modes—higher-energy fluctuations in the instanton background. While the "one-instanton" or "zero-mode" approximation captures the mass generation of quarks, it appears insufficient to satisfy the axial Ward identities required for a realistic description of proton spin.

Future refinements of this work would require incorporating these non-zero modes and moving beyond the independent constituent quark approximation to account for stronger interactions in the axial singlet channel. Despite the numerical discrepancy, the paper provides a rigorous framework for understanding how topological vacuum structures influence the internal distribution of proton spin.

Summary updated

Abstract

The proton form factors are reduced to vacuum correlators of 4 quark fields by assuming independent constituent quarks. The axial singlet quark and gluonic form factors are calculated in the instanton liquid model. A discussion of gauge(in)dependence is given.
BibTeX
@misc{hutter1995proton,
  author = {Marcus Hütter},
  title = {{Proton Spin in the Instanton Background}},
  year = {1995},
  eprint = {hep-ph/9509402},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/9509402},
}

Loading related content...

Figure