Proton sensitivity of ASIC1 appeared with the rise of fishes by changes of residues in the region that follows TM1 in the ectodomain of the channel

Tatjana Coric, Deyou Zheng, Mark Gerstein, Cecilia M. CanessaThe Journal of Physiology 2005 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that proton sensitivity in ASIC1 channels, crucial for mammalian nervous system functions like pain and synaptic transmission, is not a universal feature but evolved later in vertebrate history, specifically with the emergence of bony fishes. Key regions within the extracellular domain of mammalian ASIC1 are responsible for this proton sensitivity, suggesting a significant evolutionary adaptation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Acid-sensing ion channels (ASICs) are a family of ion channels that are activated by external protons. ASIC1, in particular, plays a vital role in mammalian physiology, mediating processes like synaptic transmission and pain perception. However, it was unclear whether this proton sensitivity was an ancient, conserved feature across all vertebrates or a more recent evolutionary development. This paper aims to pinpoint the structural elements responsible for proton sensitivity in ASIC1 and to understand its evolutionary origins within the chordate lineage.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Cloning and Functional Expression: They cloned ASIC1 genes from various chordate species, including lamprey, shark, toadfish, and chicken. These genes were then expressed in Xenopus oocytes to study their functional properties, specifically their response to changes in pH.
  • Chimeric Constructs: To identify the regions responsible for proton sensitivity, they created chimeric channels by swapping segments between proton-sensitive mammalian ASIC1 and proton-insensitive ASIC1 from lower vertebrates (lamprey and shark).
  • Site-Directed Mutagenesis: While not extensively detailed in the abstract, the methods section implies the use of site-directed mutagenesis to probe the role of specific residues.
  • Western Blotting and Surface Biotinylation: These techniques were used to confirm protein expression and localization to the plasma membrane, ensuring that observed functional differences were not due to a lack of protein or improper trafficking.
  • Sequence Analysis: Comparative sequence analysis, including calculating conservation scores and evolutionary rates (Ka/Ks ratios), was performed to identify regions under different selective pressures in proton-sensitive versus proton-insensitive ASIC1s.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on gene sequences obtained from various species and functional data generated from experiments.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Proton Sensitivity is a Recent Evolutionary Trait: The most striking finding is that ASIC1 from early vertebrates like lamprey and shark is not sensitive to protons, despite high amino acid conservation with mammalian counterparts. This suggests that proton gating evolved relatively late in vertebrate evolution, likely with the rise of bony fishes.
  • Extracellular Domain is Key: The ectodomain of mammalian ASIC1, particularly regions following the first transmembrane domain (TM1), is crucial for conferring proton sensitivity and dictating the kinetics of channel activation and desensitization.
  • Noncontiguous Regions Contribute: Proton sensitivity isn't localized to a single small region but arises from the interplay of several noncontiguous segments within the extracellular domain.
  • Evolutionary Adaptation: The acquisition of proton sensitivity likely provided an evolutionary advantage, potentially for new functions or the enhancement of existing ones like nociception or synaptic plasticity.

Key Results

  • ASIC1 from lamprey and shark were found to be proton-insensitive, while chicken ASIC1 was proton-sensitive but with distinct kinetics compared to mammalian ASIC1.
  • Chimeric constructs revealed that the extracellular domain of rat ASIC1 was largely responsible for proton sensitivity. Specifically, the segment from residue 78 to 136, along with residues D351, Q358, and E359, were identified as important.
  • However, chimeras containing only parts of the rat extracellular domain did not fully replicate the activation and desensitization kinetics of rat ASIC1, indicating that multiple regions contribute to these processes.
  • Sequence analysis showed that while overall conservation is high, specific regions exhibit differential evolutionary pressures between proton-sensitive and proton-insensitive ASIC1s, with the segment following TM1 showing signs of becoming "fixed" in proton-sensitive channels.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Agonists in Lower Vertebrates: The paper strongly implies that ASIC1 in lower vertebrates is gated by agonists other than protons, but the identity of these primordial agonists remains unknown and is a key area for future investigation.
  • Precise Mechanisms of Gating: While key regions were identified, the exact molecular mechanisms by which these regions mediate proton binding and conformational changes leading to channel gating are still to be fully elucidated. The proposed Ca²⁺-binding site hypothesis is discussed but not definitively proven by the identified residues.
  • Functional Significance in Mammals: While proton sensitivity is linked to mammalian functions, the precise impact of the identified structural determinants on these functions requires further exploration.

The study opens up exciting avenues for understanding the evolution of ion channel function and the diverse roles ASIC1 plays across the vertebrate spectrum.

Summary updated

Abstract

The acid-sensitive ion channel 1 (ASIC1) is a neuronal Na+ channel insensitive to changes in membrane potential but is gated by external protons. Proton sensitivity is believed to be essential for the role of ASIC1 in modulating synaptic transmission and nociception in the mammalian nervous system. To examine the structural determinants that confer proton sensitivity, we cloned and functionally characterized ASIC1 from different species of the chordate lineage: lamprey, shark, toadfish and chicken. We observed that ASIC1s from early vertebrates (lamprey and shark) were proton insensitive in spite of a high degree of amino acid conservation (66-67%) with their mammalian counterparts. Sequence analysis showed that proton-sensitive ASIC1s could not be distinguished from proton-insensitive channels by any signature in the protein sequence. Chimeras made with rat ASIC1 (rASIC1) and lamprey or shark indicated that most of the ectodomain of rASIC1 was required to confer proton sensitivity and the distinct kinetics of activation and desensitization of the rat channel. Proton-sensitive chimeras contained the segment D78-E136, together with residues D351, Q358 and E359 of the rat sequence. However, none of the functional chimeras containing only part of the rat extracellular domain retained the kinetics of activation and desensitization of rASIC1, suggesting that residues distributed in several regions of the ectodomain contribute to allosteric changes underlying activation and desensitization. The results also demonstrate that gating by protons is not a feature common to all ASIC1 channels. Proton sensitivity arose recently in evolution, implying that agonists different from protons activate ASIC1 in lower vertebrates.
BibTeX
@article{coric2005proton,
  author = {Tatjana Coric and Deyou Zheng and Mark Gerstein and Cecilia M. Canessa},
  title = {{Proton sensitivity of ASIC1 appeared with the rise of fishes by changes of residues in the region that follows TM1 in the ectodomain of the channel}},
  journal = {The Journal of Physiology},
  year = {2005},
  doi = {10.1113/jphysiol.2005.087734},
}
Figure