Proton-Boron Fusion Yield Increased by Orders of Magnitude with Foam Targets

Wenqing Wei, Shizheng Zhang, Zhigang Deng, Qi Wei, Hao Xu, Lirong Liu, Jialin Zhang, Fangfang Li, Xing Xu, Zhongmin Hu, Benzheng Chen, Bubo Ma, Jianxing Li, Xueguang Ren, Zhong-Feng Xu, D. H. H. Hoffmann, Quanping Fan, Weiwu Wang, Shaoyi Wang, Jian Teng, Bo Cui, Feng Lu, L. Yang, Yuqiu Gu, Zongqing Zhao, Rui Cheng, Zhao Wang, Yu Lei, Guoqing Xiao, Hongwei Zhao, Bing Liu, Guan-Chao Zhao, Minsheng Liu, Huasheng Xie, L. H. Cao, Jieru Ren, Weimin Zhou, Yongtao ZhaoarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

A novel intense beam-driven scheme for high yield of the tri-alpha reaction $^{11}B(p,\alpha)2\alpha$ was investigated. We used a foam target made of cellulose triacetate (TAC, $C_9H_{16}O_8$) doped with boron. It was then heated volumetrically by soft X-ray radiation from a laser heated hohlraum and turned into a homogenous, and long living plasma. We employed a picosecond laser pulse to generate a high-intensity energetic proton beam via the well-known Target Normal Sheath Acceleration (TNSA) mechanism. We observed up to $10^{10}/sr$ $\alpha$ particles per laser shot. This constitutes presently the highest yield value normalized to the laser energy on target. The measured fusion yield per proton exceeds the classical expectation of beam-target reactions by up to four orders of magnitude under high proton intensities. This enhancement is attributed to the strong electric fields and nonequilibrium thermonuclear fusion reactions as a result of the new method. Our approach shows opportunities to pursue ignition of aneutronic fusion.

Introduction

Proton-boron ($p-^{11}B$) fusion is often considered the "holy grail" of clean energy because it is aneutronic, producing charged alpha particles instead of high-energy neutrons. This eliminates the need for complex radioactive shielding and allows for direct energy conversion. However, triggering this reaction is notoriously difficult due to its high cross-section peak at 600 keV and significant energy losses through Bremsstrahlung radiation at thermal equilibrium. To overcome these barriers, researchers are exploring non-thermal, beam-driven approaches to achieve high fusion yields without heating the entire fuel mass to extreme temperatures.

Experimental Methodology

The study utilized a "pitcher-catcher" configuration at the XG-III laser facility. The "pitcher" component consisted of a high-intensity picosecond (ps) laser striking a copper-aluminum foil to generate an energetic proton beam (up to 14 MeV) via Target Normal Sheath Acceleration (TNSA).

The "catcher" was a low-density cellulose triacetate (TAC) foam doped with 20% natural boron. Crucially, a nanosecond (ns) laser was used to heat a gold hohlraum, generating soft X-rays that volumetrically transformed the foam into a homogeneous, quasi-static plasma state before the arrival of the proton beam.

Schematic of the experimental setup showing the pitcher-catcher configuration with the boron-doped foam target.

Diagnostics included Radiochromic Film (RCF) stacks and Thomson Parabola Spectrometers (TPS) to characterize the proton beam, while CR39 track detectors measured the resulting alpha particle yields.

Results and Discussion

The experimental results demonstrated a massive enhancement in fusion yield. The team recorded up to $10^{10}$ alpha particles per steradian per laser shot. When normalized to the laser energy on target, this represents a new world record for $p-^{11}B$ fusion efficiency.

Key findings include:

  • Yield Enhancement: The measured fusion yield per proton exceeded classical beam-target predictions by four orders of magnitude (10,000x) under high-intensity conditions.
  • Plasma Effect: Converting the foam into a plasma state increased the yield by an order of magnitude compared to cold foam, likely due to reduced energy losses and enhanced stopping power.
  • Collective Effects: The 3D sponge-like structure of the foam induces strong transient electromagnetic fields that may "pinch" the proton beam, facilitating non-linear scaling of the fusion rate with beam intensity.
Comparison of normalized alpha yields from this work against historical results, demonstrating the record-breaking performance.

The fusion probability ($P$) reached $2.3 \times 10^{-2}$ in the high-intensity plasma case, significantly higher than the $7.3 \times 10^{-7}$ predicted by standard beam-target models.

Conclusion

This work demonstrates that using boron-doped foam targets in a plasma state can dramatically increase $p-^{11}B$ fusion yields. The combination of 3D target geometry and intense beam-driven physics provides a promising new route toward achieving ignition in aneutronic fusion. Future research will focus on optimizing foam parameters and scaling the process to higher laser intensities to further explore the potential for clean, neutron-free energy.

Summary updated

Abstract

A novel intense beam-driven scheme for high yield of the tri-alpha reaction 11B(p,α)2α was investigated. We used a foam target made of cellulose triacetate (TAC, C_9H_{16}O_8) doped with boron. It was then heated volumetrically by soft X-ray radiation from a laser heated hohlraum and turned into a homogenous, and long living plasma. We employed a picosecond laser pulse to generate a high-intensity energetic proton beam via the well-known Target Normal Sheath Acceleration (TNSA) mechanism. We observed up to 10^{10}/sr α particles per laser shot. This constitutes presently the highest yield value normalized to the laser energy on target. The measured fusion yield per proton exceeds the classical expectation of beam-target reactions by up to four orders of magnitude under high proton intensities. This enhancement is attributed to the strong electric fields and nonequilibrium thermonuclear fusion reactions as a result of the new method. Our approach shows opportunities to pursue ignition of aneutronic fusion.
BibTeX
@misc{wei2023proton,
  author = {Wenqing Wei and Shizheng Zhang and Zhigang Deng and Qi Wei and Hao Xu and Lirong Liu and Jialin Zhang and Fangfang Li and Xing Xu and Zhongmin Hu and Benzheng Chen and Bubo Ma and Jianxing Li and Xueguang Ren and Zhong-Feng Xu and D. H. H. Hoffmann and Quanping Fan and Weiwu Wang and Shaoyi Wang and Jian Teng and Bo Cui and Feng Lu and L. Yang and Yuqiu Gu and Zongqing Zhao and Rui Cheng and Zhao Wang and Yu Lei and Guoqing Xiao and Hongwei Zhao and Bing Liu and Guan-Chao Zhao and Minsheng Liu and Huasheng Xie and L. H. Cao and Jieru Ren and Weimin Zhou and Yongtao Zhao},
  title = {{Proton-Boron Fusion Yield Increased by Orders of Magnitude with Foam Targets}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2308.10878},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2308.10878},
}

Loading related content...

Figure