Proton-air cross section measurement with the ARGO-YBJ cosmic ray experiment

G. Aielli, C. Bacci, B. Bartoli, P. Bernardini, X. J. Bi, C. Bleve, P. Branchini, A. Budano, S. Bussino, A. K. Calabrese Melcarne, P. Camarri, Z. Cao, A. Cappa, R. Cardarelli, S. Catalanotti, Claudio Cattaneo, Paola Celio, S. Z. Chen, Yupeng Chen, Ning Cheng, P. Creti, S. W. Cui, B. Z. Dai, G. D’Alí Staiti, Danzengluobu Danzengluobu, M. Dattoli, I. De Mitri, B. D′Ettorre Piazzoli, M. De Vincenzi, T. Di Girolamo, X. H. Ding, G. Di Sciascio, C. F. Feng, Zhaoyang Feng, Zhenyong Feng, F. Galeazzi, P. Galeotti, R. Gargana, Q. B. Gou, Y. Q. Guo, H. H. He, Haibing Hu, Hongbo Hu, Q. Huang, M. Iacovacci, R. Iuppa, I. James, H. Y. Jia, Labaciren Labaciren, H. J. Li, J. Y. Li, X. X. Li, B. Liberti, G. Liguori, C. Liu, Manguo Liu, J. Liu, H. Lu, X. H., G. Mancarella, S. M. Mari, G. Marsella, D. Martello, S. Mastroianni, X. R. Meng, P. Montini, C. C. Ning, A. Pagliaro, M. Panareo, Lorenzo Perrone, P. Pistilli, X. B. Qu, E. Rossi, F. Ruggieri, L. Saggese, P. Salvini, R. Santonico, P. R. Shen, X. D. Sheng, F. Shi, C. Stanescu, A. Surdo, Y. H. Tan, P. Vallania, S. Vernetto, C. Vigorito, B. Wang, H. Wang, C. Y. Wu, H. Wu, Benda Xu, L. Xue, Yingwen Yan, Q. Y. Yang, X. C. Yang, A. F. Yuan, M. Zha, Honglin Zhang, Jilong ZhangPhysical 2009 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The proton-air cross section in the energy range 1–100 TeV has been measured by the ARGO-YBJ cosmic ray experiment. The analysis is based on the primary cosmic ray flux attenuation for different atmospheric depths (i.e., zenith angles) and exploits the detector capabilities of selecting the shower development stage by means of hit multiplicity, density, and lateral profile measurements at ground. The effects of shower fluctuations, the contribution of heavier primaries, and the uncertainties of the hadronic interaction models have been taken into account. The results have been used to estimate the total proton-proton cross section at center-of-mass energies between 70 and 500 GeV, where no accelerator data are currently available.

Introduction

In high-energy particle physics, the "cross section" (σ) represents the effective target area for interactions between particles. While the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) provides precise measurements at specific energies, cosmic rays offer a unique "natural beam" of protons reaching energies far beyond current terrestrial capabilities. Measuring the proton-air cross section ($σ_{p-air}$) using these cosmic rays is a fundamental step in understanding hadronic interactions at extreme energies. This paper details the measurement of $σ_{p-air}$ in the 1–100 TeV range using the ARGO-YBJ experiment and the subsequent derivation of the fundamental proton-proton cross section ($σ_{p-p}$).

The ARGO-YBJ Experiment

The ARGO-YBJ experiment, located at the YangBaJing Cosmic Ray Laboratory in Tibet (4300 m a.s.l.), consists of a large "carpet" of Resistive Plate Chambers (RPCs). Unlike traditional sparse arrays, ARGO-YBJ provides a nearly continuous active area (92% coverage in the central carpet), enabling a detailed digital image of Extensive Air Showers (EAS).

A high-resolution event display showing the hit pattern (left) and the 3D arrival time profile (right) of an extensive air shower recorded by the ARGO-YBJ detector.

The high granularity of the detector allows for the precise measurement of hit multiplicity ($N_{strip}$), arrival times, and the lateral distribution of particles, which are essential for reconstructing the primary particle's energy and direction.

Methodology: The Attenuation Method

The primary technique employed is the flux attenuation method. This method exploits the fact that the atmosphere acts as an absorber. Protons entering the atmosphere at larger zenith angles ($θ$) traverse a greater slant depth (more air) than those arriving vertically. The rate of observed showers decreases as the atmospheric depth increases.

By measuring the event rate $I(θ)$ at different zenith angles, the interaction length $λ_{p-air}$ can be determined. This length is inversely proportional to the cross section: $σ_{p-air} = \langle A \rangle / (λ_{p-air} \cdot N_A)$, where $\langle A \rangle$ is the average atomic mass of air and $N_A$ is Avogadro's number.

To ensure a robust measurement, the team focused on selecting showers at a specific stage of their longitudinal development. This "shower stage selection" minimizes the impact of shower-to-shower fluctuations. Parameters such as the distance between the detector and the shower maximum ($X_{dm}$) were used to categorize events.

Data Selection and Systematic Corrections

The analysis utilized a dataset of approximately 650 million events. To translate the experimental observations into physical cross sections, several critical corrections were applied:

  1. The $k$-factor: A correction factor derived from Monte Carlo simulations (using models like QGSJET and SIBYLL) to account for the difference between the observed attenuation and the true interaction length, primarily due to detector response and shower fluctuations.
  2. Helium Contamination: Since the primary cosmic ray flux includes heavier nuclei, a correction factor ($η$) was developed to account for Helium-induced showers that might mimic proton signals, ensuring the sample remained "proton-enriched."

Results and Discussion

The proton-air cross section was measured across five energy bins from 1 to 100 TeV. The results show a clear increase in the cross section with energy. For instance, in the 1–2 TeV range, $σ_{p-air}$ was measured at $272 \pm 13 \text{ (stat)} \pm 9 \text{ (syst)}$ mb.

Event rate distributions as a function of reconstructed energy (left) and the shower development parameter $X_{dm}$ (right) for three different zenith angle intervals.

Using Glauber multiple scattering theory, these values were converted into the total proton-proton cross section ($σ_{p-p}$). The derived $σ_{p-p}$ values (43–56 mb) at center-of-mass energies of 70–500 GeV are consistent with an asymptotic growth following a $\ln^2 s$ dependence, known as the Froissart bound. This finding aligns with trends observed in lower-energy accelerator data and early results from the LHC.

Conclusion

The ARGO-YBJ experiment has successfully extended the measurement of the proton-air cross section into the 100 TeV regime. By utilizing a full-coverage detector and sophisticated shower selection techniques, the collaboration provided a model-robust measurement that bridges the gap between accelerator physics and high-energy astrophysics. Future work involving analog RPC readouts will aim to extend these measurements into the PeV energy range, further testing our understanding of hadronic interactions at the highest energies.

Summary updated

Abstract

The proton-air cross section in the energy range 1--100 TeV has been measured by the ARGO-YBJ cosmic ray experiment. The analysis is based on the primary cosmic ray flux attenuation for different atmospheric depths (i.e. zenith angles) and exploits the detector capabilities of selecting the shower development stage by means of hit multiplicity, density and lateral profile measurements at ground. The effects of shower fluctuations, the contribution of heavier primaries and the uncertainties of the hadronic interaction models, have been taken into account. The results have been used to estimate the total proton-proton cross section at center-of-mass energies between 70 and 500 GeV, where no accelerator data are currently available.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{aielli2009proton,
  author = {G. Aielli and C. Bacci and B. Bartoli and P. Bernardini and X. J. Bi and C. Bleve and P. Branchini and A. Budano and S. Bussino and A. K. Calabrese Melcarne and P. Camarri and Z. Cao and A. Cappa and R. Cardarelli and S. Catalanotti and Claudio Cattaneo and Paola Celio and S. Z. Chen and Yupeng Chen and Ning Cheng and P. Creti and S. W. Cui and B. Z. Dai and G. D’Alí Staiti and Danzengluobu Danzengluobu and M. Dattoli and I. De Mitri and B. D′Ettorre Piazzoli and M. De Vincenzi and T. Di Girolamo and X. H. Ding and G. Di Sciascio and C. F. Feng and Zhaoyang Feng and Zhenyong Feng and F. Galeazzi and P. Galeotti and R. Gargana and Q. B. Gou and Y. Q. Guo and H. H. He and Haibing Hu and Hongbo Hu and Q. Huang and M. Iacovacci and R. Iuppa and I. James and H. Y. Jia and Labaciren Labaciren and H. J. Li and J. Y. Li and X. X. Li and B. Liberti and G. Liguori and C. Liu and C. Q. Liu and Manguo Liu and J. Liu and H. Lu and X. H. and G. Mancarella and S. M. Mari and G. Marsella and D. Martello and S. Mastroianni and X. R. Meng and P. Montini and C. C. Ning and A. Pagliaro and M. Panareo and Lorenzo Perrone and P. Pistilli and X. B. Qu and E. Rossi and F. Ruggieri and L. Saggese and P. Salvini and R. Santonico and P. R. Shen and X. D. Sheng and F. Shi and C. Stanescu and A. Surdo and Y. H. Tan and P. Vallania and S. Vernetto and C. Vigorito and B. Wang and H. Wang and C. Y. Wu and H. Wu and Benda Xu and L. Xue and Yingwen Yan and Q. Y. Yang and X. C. Yang and A. F. Yuan and M. Zha and Honglin Zhang and Jilong Zhang},
  title = {{Proton-air cross section measurement with the ARGO-YBJ cosmic ray experiment}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.80.092004},
}
Figure